11 ms·
I think its important for Hacker News readers to read this because techno-communism is becoming a very serious force in western politics. It needs to be temper
by ilaksh 11y ago
I think its important for Hacker News readers to read this because techno-communism is becoming a very serious force in western politics. It needs to be tempered with a historical context.
The problem we should focus on is over-centralization, which comes easily out of a competitive OR cooperative society.
Yes to holistic measurements, efficiency and equality. But do that on a meta, protocol level that allows for diverse decentralized systems to evolve while still integrating information.
- digi_owl 11y agoOn that note, if one go back to old guy Marx we find that he was no fan of centralization. His thinking was towards workers owning the factory they worked at. Then again he also apparently had himself talked in circles to make his findings fit the labor theory of value. Still, while mostly we hear about worker exploitation etc he did dial in on the issue of debt and banking. And how there was a second struggle between industrial capitalists and financial capitalists. From that an later sources it may well help to think about a economy as a systems of flows. Goods in one direction, and money in the other. And much like with all asynchronous flow systems, there has to be buffers to even out peaks and slumps. Banks do that for the money flow via their issuance of debt.
- ilaksh 11y agoNot sure what you are ultimately aiming at but although flows is a good way to think of traditional economics, economics as commonly understood is fundamentally flawed and unable to serve the purposes it is supposed to. Effectively the money flow regulates ALL aspects of our society. The problem with this is that its like doing medical science where the only aspect of the body anyone really understands is the cardiovascular system. We need to integrate more physical and social sciences and better values into our economic systems. The moneyflow religion must be converted somehow into a dynamic technological decentralized automated system incorporating data and feedback loops ensuring human and environmental health. And this needs to enable freedom and the ability to evolve. But elitist VC or technocratic engineers rationalizing the flawed, limited belief system around the one-dimensional money system is not constructive.
- obrero 11y ago> Then again he also apparently had himself talked in circles to make his findings fit the labor theory of value. And what are the record and movie companies imploring us with, when they say we shouldn't copy ("pirate") songs, movies or software? They say that the value of the product came from the work of the artists or programmers, and they deserve to be paid for their efforts. Well what is that but the labor theory of value? Even corporate America has cast off the subjective theory of value. The labor theory of value was and is correct, but more and more we see things with a new form. A commodity used to be a scarce thing, but nowadays people increasingly create "commodities" which once built are infinitely reproducible for almost no cost, or actually no cost. To where it is not even a commodity any more. So even Marx's theory of the 19th century commodity is upended. Not only that - these new commodities are reusable - from hiphop artists sampling older songs, to developers reusing components. Production is changing, so theories of production must change also. Neither the marginalists nor Marx described what is going on now and will be increasingly so. Although in the sense that Marx posited that production would be radically changed in the future from the 19th century factory system, in that sense he was correct.
- coldtea 11y ago>think its important for Hacker News readers to read this because techno-communism is becoming a very serious force in western politics. It needs to be tempered with a historical context. Tempered why? The worst thing he could say about Poland was a corrupt police. Constrast with the hundrends of innocent police killings in the US, or the hundrens of thousands incarcerated for BS charges (like drug pocession or three-strikes) and it's not that different. Widespread surveillance? Check, and even more detailed. Of course there are differences too. E.g. now nobody is guaranteed to have a job or a home, and inequality can be much higher than in those old times (where a party functionary just made something like a few times more, not several orders of magnitude more, like a CEO does).
- V-2 11y ago> The worst thing he could say about Poland was a corrupt police. It hardly means that this is the worst thing that could be said about Soviet-controlled Poland > Constrast with the hundrends of innocent police killings in the US US police is notorious for its brutality, but are these killings ordered by top officials in chain of command? If factory workers go on a strike in the US, are police troops sent in to "shoot to kill" them? They did in Poland 30 years ago, eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Wujek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Wujek > E.g. now nobody is guaranteed to have a job or a home A guaranteed home for which you would wait 20 years :)) While earning 20 bucks a month. For which you often couldn't even buy basic goods... http://i.wp.pl/a/f/jpeg/22380/kolejka_prl_internauta_550.jpeg http://i.wp.pl/a/f/jpeg/22380/kolejka_prl_internauta_550.jpe... http://i.wp.pl/a/f/jpeg/23333/puste_haki_550.jpeg http://i.wp.pl/a/f/jpeg/23333/puste_haki_550.jpeg ^ Equality.
- obrero 11y ago> US police is notorious for its brutality, but are these killings ordered by top officials in chain of command? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Fred_Hampton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Fred_Hampton > If factory workers go on a strike in the US, are police troops sent in to "shoot to kill" them? They did in Poland 30 years ago, eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Wujek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacification_of_Wujek Oh god yes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockton_cannery_strike_of_1937 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockton_cannery_strike_of_193... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Petersburg_sanitation_strike_of_1968#Riots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Petersburg_sanitation_stri... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auto-Lite_strike#The_.22Battle_of_Toledo.22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auto-Lite_strike#The_.22Battle... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Steel_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Steel_strike