5 ms·
> 2) Has a rapidly adaptive culture, able to implement changes at a fast pace despite its immense scale. That includes things like legalizing and decriminalizin
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
> 2) Has a rapidly adaptive culture, able to implement changes at a fast pace despite its immense scale. That includes things like legalizing and decriminalizing drugs, which is now underway across numerous states, and marriage equality.
The US is able to implement seemingly big changes quickly, but they're not necessarily as big as you think them to be. "Marriage equality" (a name many disagree with, by the way) is not a massive change, for example. It's a tiny change that, while providing some benefit to some gay people, does not fundamentally change power structures. In fact, it strengthens an existing one: the cultural institution of marriage.
> 11) Where the murder rate for 99% of the population in cities is closer to 2/100k (and half that in rural areas), on par nicer urban parts of Europe.
If you exclude the places where murder happens most, of course you appear to have a low murder rate.
> 12) Where unarmed minorities are not regularly shot dead by the police.
Perhaps you have not paid attention to the news. Quite literally hundreds of black people have been shot by US police this year so far. People who, if their skin was a different colour, would not have been shot.
> 13) Where minorities have a greater opportunity for success than in nearly any other nation.
This statement would be amusing were it not so terrifying. Minorities in the US, once in the poverty trap, have virtually no chance of getting out of it. Even those outside it face significant obstacles in getting anywhere.
> See: the vast wealth and prosperity of Asians in America, they're the best off of any race of people here. In fact, American Asians are among the best off of any people anywhere on this planet.
Asians in America are a relatively privileged minority. Now look at how other ethnic groups fare. Not so rosy.
> 14) Where you have more opportunities than in any other nation, to make any kind of life for yourself that you want.
If you're rich.
- adventured 11y ago> is not a massive change In fact marriage equality, and the increasingly broad acceptance of homosexuality in America, is an extraordinary accomplishment. And it's only going to keep getting better. That contrasts sharply with the majority of the world, that is the exact opposite and opposed to marriage equality. > If you exclude the places where murder happens most, of course you appear to have a low murder rate. Not excluding at all. The whole of the US has a murder rate 1/3 that of Russia, and on par with Amsterdam. Few Americans as a percentage live in very high murder rate neighborhoods or areas. Those areas have extremely high murder rates, the other 99%+ of America where most people live does not. That's an exceptionally critical distinction. The worst areas of eg Chicago do not threaten most of the people that live in Chicago, most of those citizens are under very little risk of being murdered or harmed by that crime. It's context dropping to pretend otherwise. To pretend that all of Chicago suffers from an equally high murder rate is absurd. > Perhaps you have not paid attention to the news. Quite literally hundreds of black people have been shot by US police this year so far. In fact I do more than just watch the headlines, I read the stats. Police caused deaths have been falling for 40 years. The US is almost so diverse at this point, that it will soon have no majority. The parent comment claimed unarmed minorities were being killed left and right. In fact, there are typically around 500 police caused deaths per year in the US, a small fraction of which are unarmed minorities that are shot, and a fraction of which are unjustified in terms of use of force. Nearly half of those deaths are white people, not minorities. To put these numbers in context, China executes 2,500+ people per year, with some record execution years that are truly astounding. They've executed more people in the last 10 years, than cops have killed in the US total in the last 100 years. > Asians in America are a relatively privileged minority. Now look at how other ethnic groups fare. Not so rosy. I find it fascinating how you excuse the success of Asian Americans by slandering them as privileged. Fact: Asians in America are among the richest Asians on earth; Blacks in America are the richest blacks on earth; Latinos in America are the richest Latinos on earth. > If you're rich. Nope, America has the world's largest middle class, and has good upward mobility: "A surprising and increasing number of middle-skill workers are moving up rather than down the economic ladder." The fact that the US has one of the highest standards of living, median incomes, and median disposable incomes, proves the point easily. You very clearly don't have to be rich at all to do well in America. The US also has one of the highest rates of college degree acquisition in the world. http://www.cbsnews.com/news/some-hopeful-job-news-for-a-hard-hit-group/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/some-hopeful-job-news-for-a-hard...
- DanBC 11y ago> Not excluding at all. The whole of the US has a murder rate [...] on par with Amsterdam. Amsterdam, a dangerous city, has a murder rate of about 4.4 murders per 100,000 population. The entire US, including the empty rural bits, has a murder rate of 4.7 per 100,00. But if we include all of Holland we see a rate of less than 1 per 100,000 population. Your comparison of a single dangerous city with the entire US is dishonest. Let's look at a single US city: Detroit. Detroit has a murder rate of 44 per 100,000 population. Amsterdam, one of the most dangerous cities in Western Europe has a murder rate of 4.4 per 100,000 population.
- adventured 11y agoIt's not dishonest in the least. For a country supposedly as violent and dangerous as the US, with the vast number of guns that we have, to have a murder rate on par with Amsterdam is worth noting - it's also worth noting that it has been improving for decades almost non-stop. As we gradually end the war on drugs, it's likely to drop a lot further. If we get that 4.x rate down to a high 2.x rate in the next 20 years, would that not be a solid accomplishment given the guns in America? At the rate violent crime has been dropping over time, that's likely to be the outcome. And as I've noted previously, America in fact has a lot of cities with extremely low murder rates. If you want to live in a very safe city, there are plenty of options. Let's look at San Diego versus Amsterdam: nearly twice the population and nearly half the murder rate.
- IkmoIkmo 11y ago1) you're comparing the safest US cities to the 'murder capital' of Europe. That's a total joke. It's like comparing the standard of living of a European billionaire to an American homeless person and saying 'look!'. That's why he's saying it's dishonest. 2) Even if the comparison was reasonable, you completely fail to understand the cause of the numbers and what they say. And they say nothing about safety for ordinary people living in Amsterdam, I can tell you that right away. Here's some more info on nr (2) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10102529 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10102529
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> If you exclude the places where murder happens most, of course you appear to have a low murder rate. There is no "of course" about it. If the murder rate were uniform throughout the US then excluding any handful of locations would have minimal effect, but excluding those locations causes it to drop precipitously. That isn't to say it isn't a problem, but it's a localized problem. So if you're moving here and are worried about being murdered, all you have to do is live in New York and not Baltimore.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]