12 ms·
Financial Misstatements
- mynegation 11y agoI can recommend Brian Bushee's accounting course on Coursera: https://www.coursera.org/course/whartonaccounting https://www.coursera.org/course/whartonaccounting http://www.investopedia.com/ http://www.investopedia.com/ is helpful for occasional reference
- rglover 11y agoThanks! Signed up for the next session.
- cryptoz 11y agoThere are so many startup accelerators that take a team of engineers / product people and do their best to make businesspeople out of them. I'm one of those CEOs, for sure, and learning about the financial world, accounting, and trying to make sure to not mis-speak was quite difficult. The primary training I received during the accelerator helped a lot, but it was more along the lines of how to more accurately model in excel. It was up to the CEO (?CFO? if you're lucky) to get all this exactly right, and it's not easy. I think that when an accelerator knows that its teams are not well-versed in the financial part of running a startup, there should be more emphasis on helping them learn. It's daunting to try to do that alone.
- codemac 11y agoWhat are the reasons startups can't hire good finance people? Or at least contract with an expert? Is it a difficulty in judging their abilities when it's not your area? Is it something where only at a certain size would it be worth the reduced financial risk to have someone on it? Learning from scratch has to be the slowest, highest risk way of doing it -- which is the exact opposite of what a startup should be optimizing for (reduce risk where possible, move fast) It seems like helping identify business talent is what an accelerator should be helping with, not becoming a half assed B-school for engineers.. There's some implicit assumption here that learning from scratch is better than hiring talent, and I think that's a mistake.
- dandare 11y ago"What are the reasons startups can't hire good finance people?" I think the reason is that you are in stage where the CEO personally empties the rubbish bins in the office, that's why.
- dllthomas 11y agoOffloading finance should arguably come before offloading janitorial. You can be thinking about other things while emptying rubbish bins.
- dandare 11y agoI certainly agree - my metaphor was about how little money startups have for hiring professionals in general.
- logicallee 11y agoyou're a company. you're built to make something and grow it. outsourcing financials (I don't mean getting help with them, but actually offloading them) is in some ways like outsourcing development. the "CEO" personally does finances for the same reason the "CTO" personally codes. If either of them can't do something they learn it. Sam is saying: learn these words.
- dllthomas 11y agoI do want to make a distinction between "offloading" and "outsourcing". That said, you may very well be correct. My point was simply that, if it's a good idea, it's mostly not for the same reason that has the CEO emptying waste baskets.
- ska 11y agoThey can, and do if they are being sensible. One of your fairly early hires should be a real finance person (not an executive but someone experienced enough to take over the day to day effectively). Not doing this is false economy. Well before that point, you should have a contract accountant of course.
- chollida1 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_merchandise_volume https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_merchandise_volume https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_of_intent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_of_intent for people like me who weren't aware of the term. This is yet another way in which Y Combinator can differentiate themselves as a place for startups. A once a week course on this type of material would probably be very useful for most founders, I'm working under the assumption that most Y Combinator founders are first time founders. As a side note, it feels like this type of communication straddles the boundary between something that could have been a tweet vs a blog post.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>This is a felony and it’s called fraud, even though it’s usually unintentional. This is incorrect. Fraud requires intent. Otherwise it's just negligence. Should probably throw a legal dictionary in with the financial one.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoBut you can still get in legal hot water, and getting (mostly) back out involves having to prove that you were ignorant of the rules rather than deliberately trying to deceive. It's still going to be an incredible mess, and it's still going to wreck your reputation.
- mindcrime 11y agoBut even without intent, negligence can, at times, rise to the level of being criminal[1]. Not sure if there's even been a case of a white-collar/financial negligence charge being considered a felony or not though... Either way, I think sama's point was that this stuff can be A Big Deal and is really important. I don't think any of this discussion contradicts that. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_negligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_negligence
- jsprogrammer 11y agoOh, negligence can certainly be criminal. Sam didn't claim that though, he specifically claimed that unintentionally stating incorrect jargon is a felony crime called 'fraud'. That is incorrect and somewhat ironic in a post about using correct terminology.
- mindcrime 11y agoThat is incorrect and somewhat ironic in a post about using correct terminology Sure. I'm just saying it doesn't detract from the underlying point. But you're right, it is ironic and slightly amusing... Just goes to show, we're all susceptible to making silly mistakes when we step outside of our primary domain(s).
- 11y ago
- mcarthur_gill 11y agoAnybody else have solid resources to learn this stuff?
- 7Figures2Commas 11y ago> Although investors should be doing more diligence than is currently in fashion, this issue is on the founders to fix. What incentive do founders have to "fix" this when investors aren't doing adequate due diligence?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoThe fact that they can be prosecuted for it.
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoHow many Silicon Valley startup founders have faced felony charges for making financial misrepresentations in recent years?
- jbenz 11y agoIf you're choosing between "should I commit a felony or not" should it matter how often other are charged with it? What happens if law enforcement suddenly becomes more interested?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoHave you considered the possibility that founders aren't being charged with felonies left and right because they're not committing felonies left and right?
- tptacek 11y agoCurrent bubble? I believe the answer is zero. Last bubble? I believe the answer is nonzero.
- kevin 11y agoHere's the biggest offenders I see when talking to founders: revenue vs GMV (if you give GMV, give me your cut/margin) contract vs LOI burn vs expenses users vs customers (customers pay) signups vs users vs active users (you should give active with time interval and measurement of active. eg. logged in last 30 days) profitable vs cash flow positive Others people should know: diff between retention rate vs churn rate (both should be given with time interval. eg. 30 day retention rate is... monthly churn rate is...) voluntary churn vs involuntary churn gross vs net top line vs bottom line
- duaneb 11y agoIANAL, and Sam mentioned a felony charge. Are there any legal protections for investors (or.... whoever this is protecting) for e.g. misrepresenting "signups vs users vs active users"? Surely that falls under subjective fraud rather than a straight up objective lie, especially for sites e.g. reddit where the line between "active user" and "lurker" is extremely murky. EDIT: Clearly I have no understanding of fraud.
- dudurocha 11y agoUsually and investor makes a Due Diligence in the company. Depending on the stage of the company, investor profile, this due diligence can be a formal one, where you hire external auditors to make the process or in a more early-stage phase you can do VC firm (or angel) makes the due diligence themselves. Either way, at least in Brazilian Law (I work with VC in Brazil, but I imagine there is something similiar in USA), we have a "Hidden Liabilities" clause in our termsheet. It says that anything prior to the investors investiment is liable to the founders only.
- jbverschoor 11y agoIf an investor does not include such a clause and doesn't do proper due diligence but everything was handed over... It works the other way around with all the ways people get screwed over by the other side.
- deleted 11y ago
- t23 11y agoI'd recommend the following books: Financial Statements Step by Step (http://www.amazon.com/Financial-Statements-Step-Step-Understanding/dp/1601630239 http://www.amazon.com/Financial-Statements-Step-Step-Underst...) Financial Intelligence (http://www.amazon.com/Financial-Intelligence-Revised-Edition-Managers/dp/1422144119/ref=pd_bxgy_14_img_z http://www.amazon.com/Financial-Intelligence-Revised-Edition...) Financial Intelligence for Entrepreneurs (http://www.amazon.com/Financial-Intelligence-Entrepreneurs-Really-Numbers/dp/1422119157/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1440176755&sr=1-1&keywords=financial+intelligence+for+entrepreneurs http://www.amazon.com/Financial-Intelligence-Entrepreneurs-R...)
- api 11y agoSome of the more extreme stuff is the fault of "stretch the truth till it breaks" ideology in business culture. This stuff is dubious in any form IMHO, but when naive first-timers without MBAs pick it up it easily devolves into outright fraud. Someone who knows finance, law, and accounting inside and out knows when and where to stop stretching, but non-experts in these areas do not. I've heard some jaw-droppers myself in conversations with other founders/entrepreneurs over the years. It's okay to put a positive spin on it, but it's not okay to lie. You can't say you are "cash flow positive" if you are not in any way shape or form collecting actual cash from anyone. If you don't understand MBA-level accounting and finance, then the safest and most honest thing to do is stick to concrete numbers and things you clearly do understand. Revenue is actual dollars that land in your bank account-- real money that really exists. Profit is revenue minus expense. Customers are actual people or businesses who have given you money for an actual thing. Contracts are actual promises to do so in the future for some length of time. Users are people who are actually handling, running, or consuming your product right now, etc. It's also perfectly okay to say "I'm not an accountant" in response to questions you don't understand. Your prospective investors are looking for someone to build a product and sell it, and if you can do that then that's your expertise. Accountants and lawyers can be hired on a consulting basis just like any other domain expert. It's okay not to have expertise in all areas as long as your expertise is where it counts and you have traction/results. Investors will appreciate that too, since anyone operating as a VC or serious angel will see right through any nonsense you spew. It will simply discredit you, and any investor who doesn't have very sensitive radar for blowhards and con men will not be an investor long.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago"""I’ve seen people use GMV for revenue or refer to an LOI as a contract many times in the past year when talking to investors. This is a felony.""" How come it's only "disruption" when it happens to somebody else.
- edpichler 11y agoAccounting is so important and so underrated. With a good accounting you can check the health of any company with just minute reading of the statements, cash flow, profit/losses, debits for short term, investments, etc. With accounting you can easily know how your investments are going, when you have many and other people administrating. You can also use accounting to invest in good companies for long term, and for this, I recommend Peter Lynch books.
- rbcgerard 11y agoI find most people can't name the summery lines of an income statement (Revenue>COGS>gross profit>sg&A>operating profit> etc.) let alone a balance sheet or cash flow statement. but frankly the one annoys me the most is is the way "cash flow" is misused. BTW this comes into play https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEC_Rule_10b-5 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SEC_Rule_10b-5
- Nicholas_C 11y agoNot a startup guy but a finance guy, how is cash flow misused?
- 001sky 11y ago"This is a felony." This is probably a too-broad-brush use of the word. Other than that, I like this essay. People should be taught financial literacy early and accurately. Like learning maths notation: It's useful, compact and efficient. But...it must be precisely grasped/implemented to be of any benefit to speaker or the audience.
- w1ntermute 11y agoIt's pretty amusing to see this post coming from a guy who's publicly stated: > I can't read a balance sheet or income statement or anything like that. I have to have someone explain it to me, every Board meeting. http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/07/sam_altman_on_s.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/07/sam_altman_on_s.htm...
- domdip 11y agoThere's no hypocrisy there. He's probably had to personally be super-cautious about opening his mouth about things like this.
- cwp 11y agoAs an engineer it's pretty easy to get used to dismissing opinions about technology from people that don't understand it. At times that's reasonable, but it's also easy to take it way too far. Sam seems to have a healthy respect for his own ignorance, and encourages others do to do the same, particularly in areas where that ignorance can have significant practical consequences. That's not "amusing", it's commendable.
- jbverschoor 11y agoAnd walking away from a handshake deal is breach of contract.
- bengali3 11y agobut only if the contract period was for less than 1 year, iirc. and also the issue of authority-to-bind comes into play as well.. for protection from a verbal deal going bad, see also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estoppel#Promissory_estoppel_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estoppel#Promissory_estoppel_2
- smacktoward 11y agoThis post leaves a bad taste in my mouth, at least to the degree it's talking about executives of YC companies. I mean, the whole model of YC is to take kids straight out of college (if not before) and turn them into startup CEOs. If those CEOs come out of that process not understanding the legal obligations of their new position, whose fault is that, exactly? It's not like they're bringing decades of business experience to the gig. The only thing they know about what being a CEO requires is what YC teaches them. If their only preparation for the post is YC, and they're ending up ignorant of stuff that could get them slapped with a felony charge, I would think that would say more about YC than it does about them.
- exelius 11y agoIt's not YC's job to teach executives anything. Their entire model is self-service: they give founders access to people who know this stuff, but you have to ask for help to receive it. At the same time, a lot of these founders don't know what they don't know, so IMO this blog post is a way of saying to current and prospective founders "Hey, you need to be careful about this because creative accounting is often illegal". The startup mindset is to find creative solutions to problems, but that doesn't work in finance/accounting. > I mean, the whole model of YC is to take kids straight out of college Isn't the average age of YC founders closer to 30?
- teisman 11y agoIt is interesting how this blog-post directly follows the "The Post-YC Slump" post [0]. One can easily make the mistake of considering time spent on financial statements "fake work", fake work being identified as one of the reasons for the slump. The fact that there are financial misstatements indicates that there is more need for this type fake work, or perhaps the whole fake work thing isn't so fake after all. [0] http://blog.samaltman.com/the-post-yc-slump http://blog.samaltman.com/the-post-yc-slump
- mildbow 11y agoExactly what I thought too. Why not have a bootcamp for a few basic finance rules/jargon? Assuming they see the same sort of issues crop up, surely a 1-3 day bootcamp is a lot less "fake work" than every founder now needing to figure out what they need to know and then know it?
- BreakoutList 11y agohttps://quip.com/32zVAMYAi29n https://quip.com/32zVAMYAi29n
- joshjkim 11y agoInteresting idea: VCs should have in-house finance folks specifically meant to work with portfolio companies who spent a few days a month for year 1 after investment, or until the company gets it own finance team. Most VCs do less than 10-15 deals a year, so this seems tolerable and a relatively low cost way of to really know what's going on with the portfolio. (I know some VCs already kind of do this (Vantage Point). Also, harder for YC, given # of investments, so maybe not as applicable for true seed funds but still might be worth it - I'm sure they could get 5 mid-career CPAs for the price of one partner, and they would love the job! I think) The fun part is that then the VCs will have a direct line into the company's nitty-gritty operations, which really they are entitled to receive anyhow (though usually they just take the board deck at its word..which is not always good). This might suck for the company since you have the VC in-the-know on your nitty-gritty (though I'd argue that if you don't want them in-the-know, you should not have taken their $$...though I understand it's more complicated than that haha), BUT that might also serve to incentivize the company to build out the finance team quickly, and also give the management team a taste of what a good finance person can provide (assuming the person the VC provides is good, which they should be if they are to be trusted with multiple portfolio companies).
- OliverJones 11y agoNot such a great idea, in my opinion. There are honest and competent people willing to work one day a week as contract CFO. Such a person works as part of the management team and doesn't have divided loyalty (management / investors).
- joshjkim 11y agoyou are right, I've worked with a few. Problem is that it's a cost to the company they often don't want and they don't value the work (I think this is what SA is trying to change). Also, vetting/hiring folks etc. is it's own burden. VC pushing this gets rid of the friction and forces founders to take this seriously. Agreed they may have divided loyalty, hopefully mitigated by a very temporary relationship and the fact that at early stages, VCs and founders should be super aligned, at least around the ops numbers (sale decisions, etc. are a totally different ballgame for sure).
- jknightco 11y agoCan someone clarify the difference? Using Uber as an example: their GMV is the sum of all fares, whereas revenue is the 10% they take off that number—is this correct?
- pyrrhotech 11y agoI like Sam, and I even agree with him in this post. However, I don't think everything he blogs about needs to shoot straight to the number one spot on HN. I'm not sure if this is the community's voting or the YC algorithm's bias, but it would benefit the community if we could stop the fawning and treat his posts like we would anyone else's.
- OliverJones 11y agoA voice recognition company was in the process of IPO in the mid 1990s. They had some big purchase orders from institutional customers. The trouble was, those POs had side letters giving the customers the right to return the products for credit if they didn't work correctly. Not disclosing those side agreements to investors was treated as felony securities fraud. It made the company seem more valuable than it really was. That's the whole dealio. Don't cook the books. Don't make stuff up. There's enough that can go wrong even if you are transparent with investors about your deals.
- tptacek 11y agoThat's a nutshell description of "cash flow positive" versus "profitable", right? It's about revenue recognition.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mathattack 11y agoI've seen this is in many businesses. The biggest offense is gross vs net revenue. "Oh, we're an X million revenue firm" is frequently tossed out, when the company only keeps 15% of that to pay the bills. This is especially prevalent in AdTech. I used to think this was lack of financial knowledge on the part of the founders. Lately I've started thinking it's deliberate. I see Virtual being an example of this too, though not in AdTech. Some of this does fall on the VCs. It's very important for the VCs to dig into financials before investing, and asking for precise definitions. It also highlights the need for professional financial talent in startups.
- tkiley 11y agoI agree with Sam's message, but I sympathize with founders who make mistakes here. Founders are told to hustle, to aggressively push themselves and their visions in order to build momentum for their businesses. Founders are encouraged to bend - if not break - the rules in order to get things done. First-time founders are thrown into the world of finance with a good deal of ignorance about the meanings and conventions of specific financial terms, combined with a culturally ingrained bias towards spinning things as positively as possible. Broadly speaking, this seems like a recipe for disaster.
- someear 11y agoSell and outsell your vision, dreams, and potential, not the facts.
- cbhl 11y agoThis requires founders to be mindful and realistic with what the facts are. See also: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/07/03/419543470/episode-363-why-people-do-bad-things http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/07/03/419543470/episo...
- rokhayakebe 11y agomistakes Color me stupid, but I am sure the vast majority of founders know exactly what they are doing when they give GVM in place of revenue. For example no one would buy a home for $200M, sell it for $201M and say I made $201M last year.
- tempestn 11y agoNot necessarily; many would consider $201M the revenue and $1M the "profit" or "earnings" in that case.
- dkural 11y agobut they'd know they didn't make 201M - and conceptually that them buying and selling that house doesn't value them like a 201M revenue publicly traded company with billions in market cap. Founders know exactly what they're overselling. They do it for spin.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- clairity 11y agothis is where having an MBA (or undergrad business degree) can be helpful. note, i'm not saying you need a business degree to be a founder, just that it can help if you already have it. =) in business school, you learn that much of finance & accounting is storytelling with numbers, but with the added twist that there are legal consequences for crossing over (and sometimes, just into) the gray area. that's what sam is pointing out, where the gray area ends and the legal consequences start. as others have pointed out, quantitative finance & accounting classes can be very helpful: * financial accounting * managerial accounting * financial markets * investment finance * corporate valuation * entrepreneurial finance
- jamram82 11y agoSo where can one learn about financial terms or processes before running a company ?. Most people are familiar with AWS than with SEC.
- Maro 11y agoThere's a great book called 'The HBR Guide to Finance Basics for Managers', about 200 pages: https://hbr.org/product/hbr-guide-to-finance-basics-for-managers/an/11185E-KND-ENG https://hbr.org/product/hbr-guide-to-finance-basics-for-mana... It doesn't specifically address the terms in the OP, but it should be the starting point for non-MBAs (like myself) to start understanding basic Finance. In my experience, if you're a co-founder and you don't understand basic Finance and let your Finance department do whatever it's doing you may be setting yourself up for trouble. The OP described the other case of simply saying non-sense because you don't understand the terms :)
- brobdingnagian 11y agoThis sounds like fake work that is not tied to success.
- brobdingnagian 11y agoI'm loving the downvotes. And to what end am I being downvoted? It's a clever joke and a relevant and pertinent point.
- brobdingnagian 11y agoThis site's moderation system is crap.
- brobdingnagian 11y agoDissent is not tolerated, despite that the criticism comes attached to clear evidence of poor moderation? Keep the downvotes coming - it only goes to prove how arbitrary and non-information bearing they are.
- dang 11y agoPlease stop.
- embedding 11y agoStop what, exactly? A post that makes references to Sam Altman's previous post in the context of his present post has 3 downvotes. It's a legitimate point. You want me to stop making legitimate points? I am under the distinct impression that downvotes are not intended to be used when you simply disagree with someone, yet that's exactly what they are being used here for. Hypocrisy.
- embedding 11y agoSo, Mr. dang, what exactly are these downvotes for, and why are they being tolerated?
- codezero 11y agoWhat are some books or resources to get a crash course on these terms and their context?
- aet 11y agoThe Wall Street MBA by Advani
- sama 11y ago(By the way, we do teach this stuff at YC. But obviously we only fund a small percentage of the startups in the world.)
- dboreham 11y agoThis post sounds fishy to me. If the "financial statements" are sufficiently important for the fine details to matter, then they need to be produced by someone who knows exactly what they are doing (a properly qualified accountant). If they aren't important (why are the financial statements for a YC _applicant_ important?? surely they have zero revenue typically and nobody believes their projections), then who cares if the terminology is slightly wrong? Certainly if I were given such a document, I'd ask who prepared it and go from there as regards how accurate I expected it to be. Also, if your role is an incubator investor, isn't it your job to educate the inexperienced founders about things like this? fwiw I don't understand how anyone could confuse LOI with executed contract. I mean, really the only way that the concept of a LOI can arise is when you ask "can we get a contract in place?" and the answer is "not at this time" so you counter with "how about an LOI?". Hard to get confused about that..
- evo_9 11y agoMr. Altman is talking about the basic misunderstanding of these terms and it's surprising to me that he didn't take a bit of time to define the terms himself. Maybe I'm naive and those terms are a lot harder to define than I'm imagining, but even then some references linking to other sites could have been provided. I really enjoy reading Sam's posts and I'm usually bookmarking and/or forwarding his articles to a ton of friends. This one is a nice amuse-bouche but I guess I'm use to getting a full meal from Sam. Maybe a quick update with some links is all it needs? Good read otherwise.
- pitt1980 11y agoyeah, this seems like some YC would be well positioned to either provide as reference, or give a pointer to an appropriate reference
- skilbjo 11y agoI agree. I'm a CPA and some of these terms (GMV) I've never heard before (must be because I'm in a different industry - payments, and we use TPV - total payment volume), and others (burn) are ambiguous to my accounting brain. Is that cash flow used to fund operations? Is that the accrual based operating expenses? Is that the difference in cash between this month and last month?
- atom-morgan 11y agoIsn't it also surprising that investors aren't taking the time to define and clarify these terms as well? I feel this shouldn't fall entirely on a founder's shoulders unless they're intentionally lying.
- adevine 11y agoI think the more important thing is to make sure that a company clearly defines exactly what it means by certain financial terms. Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but IIRC during the original .com boom Priceline counted the entire sales price of an airline ticket as "revenue", which should clearly be considered GMV. More recently, I've seen terms like "gross revenue" and "net revenue" used by the financial press to describe total booking volume vs the cut a company takes.
- davidw 11y agoBrad Feld had something similar to say recently: http://feld.com/archives/2015/07/dont-try-fake-language.html http://feld.com/archives/2015/07/dont-try-fake-language.html
- jdoliner 11y agoFrom the TC article about Uber today: > This year, the firm expects to clock $10.84 billion in revenue which — calculating the 20 percent commission that it takes — should bring in around $2 billion in revenue for the year.
- DrNuke 11y agoIt's a learning process. A lot of times the Bay Area (like some other places in the world, for different endeavours) is the first real-life encounter with excellence and some times with geniality. Experiencing failure will make felons better, if they survive rejections, mature and learn from mistakes.
- Havoc 11y ago>misunderstanding or misusing basic financial terms Well if you stick the average finance guy in front of a python JIT compiler anyone looking over his shoulder will conclude he's an idiot. Yet somehow the average IT guy thinks it just takes a bit of terminology to "get" the finance side.
- snake117 11y agoAfter reading this and going through some of the comments, it may be worth while for YC to hold a small online course, or at least make a small business wiki, that discusses these terms and other concepts specifically in the start-up domain. I mean especially if misusing these terms, unintentional or not, can be considered as a felony, then it would really be worth while to at least give them some information to read up. Even though the ideal team of founders is one CompSci and one business, it seems that some of the business gurus posting here have a hard time defining a few of these terms, like GMV. That's just my two cents.
- logn 11y ago> One particularly bad one is misunderstanding or misusing basic financial terms. I started noticing this in Y Combinator applicants a couple of years ago [...] I’ve seen people use GMV for revenue or refer to an LOI as a contract many times in the past year when talking to investors. This is a felony. Not sure who the target audience is. If a business person is willfully deceiving people, let's call that out. But if a programmer is using financial jargon they don't understand, then let's educate them. It's not hard to read this blog post and come away believing that if you use the wrong acronym accidentally the author thinks you're a felon. I'm sure that's an overstatement, but overall this could have been an article that was educational yet had a serious warning. Instead it kind of stirs drama and fear. That's fine but I can't help but compare PG's essays which are a delight to read and get lost in.
- krallja 11y agoLook what A16Z just posted: http://a16z.com/2015/08/21/16-metrics/ http://a16z.com/2015/08/21/16-metrics/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- fredgrott 11y agoNote that the freelancer startups do this emphatically... UpWork Toptal Gun.io all list Revenue as total amount via gigs posted not as total amount actually awarded via finished gigs..ie project revenue on system which means that they are over or understating their actual earhed revenue from project fees Easy to catch as in accounting terms you would list the full project revenue listed on system times the percent project fees as unearned revenue and the booked earned project fee revenue as earned revenue.
- bbeneschott 11y agoBackground: I am the COO of Toptal This is simply not true for Toptal. Our publicly stated $80,000,000 ARR is top line. http://www.toptal.com/press-center/top-3-percent http://www.toptal.com/press-center/top-3-percent For additional clarification: You don't post "projects" on Toptal. Everything we do is time & materials, so the concept of misrepresenting financials based on posted projects simply isn't possible. ARR is calculated by actual sales right now multiplied out for a year of time.