4 ms·
So what caused the bump in crime? Boredom? Perhaps fun-loving kids just looking to have a good time? Or, I dunno, maybe............ drugs?
by peterwwillis 11y ago
So what caused the bump in crime? Boredom? Perhaps fun-loving kids just looking to have a good time? Or, I dunno, maybe............ drugs?
- tptacek 11y agoThe prison population isn't a function of a bump in crime. The prison population shot up as the crime rate fell through the 90s. The paper concludes by asking a series of questions about why prosecutors got harsher even as the crime rate dropped.
- peterwwillis 11y agoWell that's a nonsensical question to pose. First of all, harsh is subjective. Prosecutors don't dole out "harsh" sentences, they dole out longer or more restrictive sentences. To them, the sentence is not harsh because they're keeping innocent civilians safer by keeping criminals behind bars longer, or by making it easier to send potentially harmful people back to prison. Prison is no longer seen as a way to be penitent about one's actions: prison is now seen as a way to keep the bad away from the good. The rate of crime may have dropped, but the kind of crime did not, and prison gangs certainly haven't diminished in size or scope. People seem to forget that going to prison is a way of life to many people. Keeping those people 'off the streets' is basically the prosecutor's primary role.
- tptacek 11y agoHuh? Harsh is not only objective but trivially easy to measure. As crime rates fell, the likelihood than an arrest would convert to a felony conviction rose. That's the opposite of the causality you'd want or expect: as the community gets safer, the criminal justice system should become less intrusive, not more.
- Natsu 11y agoThere's an alternate explanation for that: that the harsher sentences made that population unable to commit further crimes by leaving them in prison. This could also be correlated with the rise in prison violence. That would tend to make sense given that prison is not a deterrent, in the sense that studies have shown doesn't seem to make people less willing to commit crimes, whereas the state of being in prison certainly does restrict their ability to do so.
- tptacek 11y agoHow does that square with the evidence that the overwhelming majority of prison inmates serve (a) short sentences (b) only 1-2 times in their life?
- Natsu 11y agoThat would seem to make sense if the three strikes laws are as significant a factor in causing the increase in felony convictions as I've been lead to believe.
- tptacek 11y agoAccording to this research, those laws are not a significant factor in the prison population. (of course, that doesn't make them a good idea!)
- dllthomas 11y agoWouldn't a less intrusive justice system only involve itself where guilt is more severe and more certain, and thus see a higher rate of felony conviction per arrest (with a much lower arrest rate)?
- tsotha 11y ago>Prosecutors don't dole out "harsh" sentences, they dole out longer or more restrictive sentences. Prosecutors "don't dole" out sentences at all. Sentencing is one of the Judge's duties. The input prosecutors have in sentencing is less direct; aside from their actual performance in the trial, they also decide which and how many charges to file for indictment.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoAt least one plausible explanation for this is that crime went down because the criminals were put in jail and this ended their criminal careers (either because they stayed in jail, or because jail scared them away from crime). Prosecutors and police saw this was successful and continued it, possibly (likely) past the point of optimality. I don't know exactly how to prove/disprove this, or what data to look for, but it's at least a plausible narrative.
- tptacek 11y agoIt also seems plausible to me that during a decades-long national freakout about crime, we overstaffed prosecutors offices, which then proceeded to find more work for themselves.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThat is plausible. These two narratives are not even inconsistent with each other. In fact, we might not even have (initially) overstaffed prosecutors offices; we might have had the right # to clean up the 80's, and simply maintained staffing levels when we should have reduced it. (Shrinking leviathon is hard.) Though are you intending to suggest that crime wasn't as big a deal as it was perceived during our "decades-long national freakout"? I haven't investigated this and have no real opinion, I'm just curious.
- tptacek 11y agoCrime is definitely less of a big deal now than it was during the freakout. The money question is, were deliberate criminal justice intervention the reason why crime dropped, or were extrinsic factors (like lead toxicity or family planning services or improved education)? If it's the latter, we need to reevaluate the resources we allocate to the criminal justice system. Maybe: fewer prosecutors, more judges.
- stvswn 11y agoIs that you, Fox Butterfield?
- rayiner 11y agoThe problem it that theory is that the timing doesn't work out. Nixon first allocated money for the drug war in 1971 (as well as coining the term). The rise in crime started about a decade before that, and homicide rates had already doubled by 1970. To figure out what caused the jump in crime you gotta look at what was happening in the 1950's and 1960's. Lots of things were. E.g. most U.S. cities saw their population peak in 1950, and saw an exodus of middle class people in the 1950's and 1960's.
- peterwwillis 11y agoWell sure, from a period starting just after WWII and culminating with the MLK riots, the whole country had been set up to both create and disenfranchise a new class of people: those connected to both the trade of illegal drugs and organized crime in general. Before, organized crime didn't necessarily involve the drug trade, but since then it has been synonymous. Drugs are the economic engine that powers the size and scope of the American prison population, and shapes the culture of people who are born to go to prison.
- rayiner 11y agoI don't think the timeline of that narrative makes sense. There were two major sets of milestones in the drug war: most drugs were heavily regulated or made illegal in the 1920's and 1930's. And modern drug law and the drug war was put into place in the 1970's. But crime started going up in 1960, decades after drugs were made illegal and a decade before the drug war. So how does "drugs" explain the rise in crime rates at that time? Much has been written on the subject, but I don't think the drug war is a cause so much as it is a symptom of what happened. There was so much else happening that better fits the timeline. Steve Pinker, for example, blames rock & roll and young people: http://quod.lib.umich.edu/h/humfig/11217607.0002.206/--decivilization-in-the-1960s?rgn=main;view=fulltext http://quod.lib.umich.edu/h/humfig/11217607.0002.206/--deciv....
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoLeaded gasoline
- njharman 11y agoLeaded gas. Seriously. Google it.
- Kluny 11y agoAlso linked to the fall of the Roman Empire (lead-lined aqueducts leading to a lot of people making bad decisions).
- jcranmer 11y agoActually, the theory that lead pipes were a measure instigator of the fall of Rome is generally considered discredited by most historians. The Romans were even aware of lead poisoning (cf., Vitruvius who specifically mentioned lead pipes as "unwholesome").
- encoderer 11y agoAlso, the empire in the east stood for 1000 years longer than the west. #ItsComplicated
- dragonwriter 11y ago> So what caused the bump in crime? Baby Boomers. More than anything, over the long term, the crime rate correlates with the proportion of the population that is males between, IIRC, the ages of about 15 and 25. The "crime wave" of the 1960s through 1980s was just the demographic bulge of the Post-WWII Baby Boom moving through that age bracket.
- peterwwillis 11y agoSo, you're saying that baby boomers caused a disproportionate increase in the rate of crime that no other generation before or since has caused, for no reason at all.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> So, you're saying that baby boomers caused a disproportionate increase in the rate of crime that no other generation before or since has caused, for no reason at all. No, I'm saying that historically, variations in the proportion of the male population in the 15-25 age range produce variations in the crime rate that are bigger than the changes in those proportions (essentially, the concentration of people in that age range appears to affect the propensity to criminality; its not just that that age range is itself more prone to crime -- which it also is. One explanation is that the bigger that demographics influence is on the overall society, the more criminality is produced; fairly similar trends, at least as regards violence, are seen across societies, not just in the US.) (And its not unique among generations in producting a crime spike like that; the Post WWI baby boom hitting that age range also corresponds to a peak crime period, though the peak was sharper and shorter, even compared to the shorter WWI baby boom period, than that of the Post WWII Baby Boom.)
- InclinedPlane 11y agoIf you plot the homicide rate among people aged 18-24 you see that it spikes up to twice the normal level from the late '80s through the mid '90s. It nearly triples for teenagers over that time period.