5 ms·
What could be great about basic income is that you can safely fire a lot of bureaucrats without harming them. Some of them might even welcome the change from be
by scotty79 11y ago
What could be great about basic income is that you can safely fire a lot of bureaucrats without harming them. Some of them might even welcome the change from being paid to do meaningless job to being paid for literally nothing.
- bmir-alum-007 11y agoPurpose, or keeping busy at a minimum, is a tentpole of avoiding depression... even if it were seemingly "busywork."
- Sammi 11y agoThat's the thing. Meaningless busywork is making people stressed and depressed. Basic Income on the other hand would free people to pursue whatever purpose they themselves desire. You can make up your own meaningful job, cause you're already getting paid.
- bmir-alum-007 11y agoThat's a sweeping generalization which presumes far too much. It depends on the person. Some people enjoy monotonous factory work because it removes the burden of thinking. Other people need a manager because they don't want to, or can't, plan the next logical thing. Others need constant variety or don't like being told what to do. The other issue is that getting paid for a "meaningful job" which doesn't turn a profit is not going to scale. Millions of people suddenly wouldn't work in fast food, farm fields, industrial tanneries or meat processing plants because they're really shitty/dangerous/disgusting jobs. (But I'm sure some scary/crazy people enjoy them.) And, when people have infinite choices and opportunities, the Paradox of Choice comes in to play and people become even more dissatisfied. See also: Zillions of wealthy housewives in perpetual existential boredom (depression) filling psychology & psychiatry offices.
- scotty79 11y agoI don't think that paradox of choice results in more suffering than not having the choice at all when it comes to having a job. With basic income you have a bit more choice when it comes to picking a job. You no longer have to restrict yourself to sufficiently paid ones.
- bmir-alum-007 11y agoI don't think you understand the Paradox of Choice or why people love In-n-Out and 2-tiered pricing plans. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paradox_of_Choice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Paradox_of_Choice Also, there are lots of people whom already do things they love. My stepsister is a special ed TA and loves it, but makes peanuts. Would this help her family, absolutely. With wide-scale deployment, a common issue will be too many people doing all sorts of terrible# crafty work without making something people would actually want to buy like bric-à-brac kitsch shops that wealthy spouses subsidize while having zero foot traffic. # Terrible because it's far too common for people to make the novice mistake of asking opinion of friends and family whom will say only nice things, and those people to base their perception on those lies.
- Sammi 11y ago> "That's a sweeping generalization which presumes far too much. It depends on the person. Some people enjoy monotonous factory work because it removes the burden of thinking. Other people need a manager because they don't want to, or can't, plan the next logical thing. Others need constant variety or don't like being told what to do." If you like monotonous factory work, then you are free to choose to do it. There's no problem here. Again, you get to choose what you do yourself. > "The other issue is that getting paid for a "meaningful job" which doesn't turn a profit is not going to scale. Millions of people suddenly wouldn't work in fast food, farm fields, industrial tanneries or meat processing plants because they're really shitty/dangerous/disgusting jobs. (But I'm sure some scary/crazy people enjoy them.)" If a job isn't turn a profit and can't pay a decent wage, it means that that job is being out-competed by something else. And risky jobs should pay for the risk involved. If the pay is high enough, then someone will choose it over basic income. > "And, when people have infinite choices and opportunities, the Paradox of Choice comes in to play and people become even more dissatisfied. See also: Zillions of wealthy housewives in perpetual existential boredom (depression) filling psychology & psychiatry offices." You don't have infinite choices. You are only good at a few things. Only able to do meaningful work in a few ways. With Basic Income the culture would change. People would start learning about meaningful work. Wealthy housewives would learn to do meaningful work. The culture right now is not helping wealthy housewives, because it says that they should already be happy without meaningful work.
- gpvos 11y agoI don't think keeping busy helps people avoid depression, it's just that they at least have some human contact through the day.
- scotty79 11y agoIt depends on quality of the human contact. Often people feel most lonely when they are in company of people who don't behave friendly towards them. That often happens at bs job.
- Hytosys 11y agoPeople tend to want to work, really. But to your point, many people can't find work that pays the money they need to survive, so they become depressed. Also, people often lose their jobs. There have been several studies/deployments that convince me that your worries are unsubstantial in practice. Really great resource: https://www.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index#wiki_that.27s_all_very_well.2C_but_where.27s_the_evidence.3F https://www.reddit.com/r/basicincome/wiki/index#wiki_that.27...
- bmir-alum-007 11y agoDisclaimer: I'm stupid broke, live in a van and take a highly-effective antidepressant, so I might have a little authority on this subject. ;) Depression is terrible (anti-social, self-destructive, painful, etc.) but useful when it's grounded in an existential crisis... it makes people reflect on themselves and think about what else they can do or change. They're not worries, they're concerns. Also, that resource doesn't list a single successful, large-scale deployment. Finland is considering it. (The US will never, ever have such a fanciful thing because the plutocracy prevents it, even with Bernie 2016.) And another concern: if people don't earn money themselves, the tendency is to waste, in all regards. This tends to reinforce learned helplessness, even farther away from the brutal reality of life/business/nature.
- Hytosys 11y agoSorry, I didn't mean to trample over your experience. I tend to focus on aggregate data which leads to ignoring nuances of the human condition. You're right about deployment size, but it's exciting to see those numbers growing with this experiment's consideration. I am hopeful of USA's growth in the area of social security, indeed starting with Bernie 2016. ;)
- RobertoG 11y ago"And another concern: if people don't earn money themselves, the tendency is to waste, in all regards." I have not observed the same. My impression is that the trend is we, people, like to waste when we don't have to pay, but if the money come from our accounts, we start to get careful, independently how the money arrived to our account. People would not like to waste their money even it's from a basic income.
- jzzskijj 11y agoThe problem with combining smaller towns in Finland has been, that the now redundant workforce in each town has been given a long period of dismissal protection. Five years has been quite common. And in Kuopio some people gained even 15 years of dismissal protection! We Finns may occasionally have great ideas, but then we manage to execute the great plan in a bad way. How can the combined towns save a single dime, if they don't do the work with smaller workforce. So far those new bigger cities have been just losing money, because everything from health care to education has to be renewed.
- scotty79 11y agoOne way basic income could potentially backfire is that rent could, and will go higher and swallow all the free money distributed to average people. In effect robbing the ones that rely on just basic income of opportunities to get a roof over their head and transferring most of the distributed wealth to property owners. I think introduction of basic income must be accompanied by laws that highly penalize owning unoccupied apartments to prevent that scenario.
- chongli 11y agoJust pay for basic income by levying progressive property taxes. Right now, most societies have very regressive property taxes. The wealthy (who own vast amounts of property) pay very, very little tax on all of it while small homeowners pay very large property taxes. You could even pin the basic income to a % of revenues. If landlords started raising the rent to try and capture the basic income, their property values would skyrocket and then they'd pay a higher tax rate which would bring in more revenue to support basic income. This would effectively create a feedback loop until the landlord class would no longer be able to afford to raise the rent.
- ptaipale 11y agoI would contradict you by saying that in my opinion, the performance (execution) of plans is in fact reasonably good, and I think is a lot better than in many other countries. But: even if municipalities are allowed to dismiss workforce, they won't. It appears that no public servant wants to have his/role and power diminished. In fact, it seems that the larger a municipality is absolutely, the higher proportion of its workforce will be in public administration. The highest cost of public administration and municipal services per head is in Utsjoki (a remote and poor area in the North with extremely disadvantageous geography), and Helsinki (the largest municipality with lots of well-to-do people and very high income). The lowest cost of public administration and most efficient organisation of services is in municipalities whose size is somewhere in between; record lows are in small communities where each and every inhabitant is committed to what they see is a common good. Another factor for people not wanting to have their municipality merged into a larger one is the track record of previous mergers, where local services of the old, smaller municipalities where wiped out simply out of pure spite (I'm looking at you, Hämeenlinna, and how you managed Lammi and others.).
- 1123581321 11y agoYou would harm the bureaucrats by firing them, though. Most people would take a pay cut going down to a basic level of income. You can see this for yourself by examining public pay tables (common salaries for individual contributors are $30-$50,000 in the US.) This is much more than any feasible BI number.
- scotty79 11y agoI suppose this depends on country. In Poland bulk of low level gov bureaucrats earns barely above minimum wage. Mostly young (or old) women are hired for that positions.