3 ms·
Do they spell out what assumptions they're working under? Because, for example, I'm pretty sure that the odds of a civilization-ending asteroid or comet strike
by mikeash 11y ago
Do they spell out what assumptions they're working under? Because, for example, I'm pretty sure that the odds of a civilization-ending asteroid or comet strike in the next year, while quite low, are higher than what's implied by 99.999999999% durability on trillions of objects."
- mehrdada 11y agoWell, the guarantee needs to be reasonable only as far as you and the courts are alive to sue them. (Corollary: you only need to sustain DDOS attacks when the rest of the internet infrastructure can sustain the traffic).
- Dylan16807 11y agoWhy do you specify trillions of objects? They practically promise data loss at that scale. Also, the typical civilization-ending comet or asteroid is going to destroy 0 or 1 geographically-diverse data centers. Remember that this is a retention promise, not an uptime promise.
- mikeash 11y agoJust because it's how many objects they store. But now that you mention it, it has no relevance to the probability of data loss due to global catastrophe, since it cancels out. If you're proposed reliability is data loss of one in 100 billion per year, that assumes the risk of e.g. global thermonuclear war is no more than that amount, or you're ignoring it for the purposes of the calculation. Which is why I wonder about their assumptions. As for a comet destroying at most one data center, if it really ends civilization then the data will probably be lost before too much longer even if the facility physically survives.