5 ms·
How so? I take a pretty dim view of most organized religion, and found this to be one of the more rational sermons I have read or heard. He suggests that in a
by nkurz 17y ago
How so? I take a pretty dim view of most organized religion, and found this to be one of the more rational sermons I have read or heard.
He suggests that in a dire situation, stealing from the shelves of a major chain store is a less evil alternative than violent crime or prostitution.
The obvious flaw in his argument would pointing out that this is a false dilemma, that there are many other alternatives. But for the example of the recently released prisoner he cites, I'm not sure which obvious ones he's failing to consider. I'm not pro-shoplifting, but given his scenario it seems better than robbery.
- pmorici 17y ago"I'm not sure which obvious ones he's failing to consider." Soup kitchen?
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoI've camped out in sub-zero temperatures and been unfortunate enough to only afford one meal a day (but a good sized one). Surely being homeless and living on a bowl of soup most days, in winter, is going to leave one close to starving.
- pmorici 17y ago"Soup Kitchen" is just a name given to a place that feeds the poor. They usually serve more than soup.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThe only ones I've visited served bread and a bowl of something like curry or stew. Shorthand "soup". The point is it's a simple meal unlikely to provide a complete days _nutrition_ and enough energy for warmth in Winter; but probably enough for medium term survival.
- hugh_ 17y agoBut for the example of the recently released prisoner he cites, I'm not sure which obvious ones he's failing to consider. Begging and dying would seem to both be more morally acceptable than stealing.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoAs someone else pointed out the Church holds that the right to live is greater than the right to [individual?] ownership of property. This has some interesting consequences which I'll enjoy meating out with friends in the Church in the next few weeks - very apposite. Begging, agreed. Though when I look at it hard and consider that begging demands the poor to give up their dignity then it reinforces in me that we should endeavour not to leave people in a position where it is ever necessary. I think just the fact that so many are now considering the position of the poor facing moral choices of theft or starvation makes this an excellent sermon.
- hugh_ 17y agoI think just the fact that so many are now considering the position of the poor facing moral choices of theft or starvation makes this an excellent sermon. When was the last time anybody actually managed to starve to death in Great Britain? Great Britain is already a welfare state. It's easy to get paid for not working. If you fall through the cracks of that system there are dozens of charities devoted to helping those in genuine need. In addition, there's a beggar on every street corner. Oh, and there's always the Church, which really should be working on feeding the hungry itself (perhaps by reducing its own gold-plated candelabra budget) instead of sending 'em to knock over Tesco's. Finally, if you somehow manage to be completely unable to find food anywhere, and you haven't eaten for days and you're actually in danger of dying of starvation, all you need to do is go to hospital, where they'll say "hey, this guy is dying of starvation" and give you free food and medical treatment. In conclusion, dying for lack of food in modern Britain is very, very difficult.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoWhen I said "not to leave people in a position ..." I wasn't really thinking of people in the UK. If you can walk into hospital then you're not going to be treated for hunger, if you can't then you'll possibly die where you sleep. I'll agree, in winter in the UK you'll die from exposure before you die technically from starvation. Yes, in my city the best (in fact only) street work is paid for by the local Church - they do a rolling program of food/shelter moving between a few of the city centre church buildings. "Finally, if you somehow manage to be completely unable to find food anywhere" Isn't the point kinda that you can walk into this huge building, nearby and full of food, 20% of which will probably just be binned, and help yourself?? [I'm really not a strong advocate of theft!]
- javert 17y agoThanks for the thoughtful response. (1) No argumnet based on religion (that is, faith) can also be based on reason. Most of his sermon is about religion. It revolves around religion. Thus, it cannot be considered (as a whole) to be rational. (2) I think it would be rational to say stealing from a major chain store is less evil than violent crime, and possibly prostitution. But it's not rational to encourage people to steal. As you point out, most of the time, there are more choices than those presented--it's a false dilemma. There may be some cases in which steadling is the best option. However, the theif would certainly have a moral obligation to repay the store when he could, and that is not mentioned here. (Really, we need a basis for both 'rationality' and 'morality' to have this discussion, which can be had, but not in the space of a comment.)
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoNo argumnet based on religion (that is, faith) can also be based on reason. Something like faith that the universes speed limit is the speed of light - this makes GR completely devoid of reason? Or that our arithmetic can't be shown to be complete and consistent with and of itself - this makes all of maths (based in this common arithmetic, cf Godel's I.T.) devoid of reason? The Bible says, James 1 http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=james%201&version=NIV http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=james%201&ve... : "Religion that God our Father accepts as pure and faultless is this: to look after orphans and widows in their distress and to keep oneself from being polluted by the world."
- astine 17y agoAssumptions are prerequisite for reason. Faith is a prerequisite for assumptions,. Therefore, faith is a prerequisite for reason. Put more simply: absolute proof of anything being impossible, some degree of faith is a universal requirement of human beings wanting to live a productive life. Thus to conclude that faith precludes reason is to conclude that every human on earth is incapable of reason. Which is quite a pretentious claim, I think.
- javert 17y ago