4 ms·
St. Louis Fed official: No evidence QE boosted economy
- afarrell 11y agoThis sounds like it leads into an argument for trying to find ways to broadly increase wages in order to deliberately spur inflation.
- animefan 11y agoOne of the main mechanisms by which inflation stimulates the economy, is that it lowers wages (because of sticky wages) hence decreasing unemployment. So intentionally raising wages as a form of stimulus seems counterproductive. Could you explain your argument more?
- badsock 11y agoOne of the ideas floating around is that the economy is currently limited on the demand side, and that increased wages will result in more disposable income and higher consumption.
- animefan 11y agoIncreasing wages will make employers less inclined to hire people, and thus potentially less total disposable income. Giving ordinary people more money directly seems like a more reasonable sort of stimulus. Where are these ideas floating around? The idea of sticky wages dates back to Keynes.
- badsock 11y agoI tend to side with the argument that employers ultimately hire not because people are cheap, but because they need them to meet demand. If there's no demand, there's no wage low enough to justify a hire. I don't want to speak for Thomas Piketty, but my reading of his data is that generally economic growth is the product of higher wages, not the other way around.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Animats 11y agoBut it sure helped out banks, who get to borrow from the Fed at near zero rates and lend at much higher rates. The US tends to inject Government money into the economy through banks. In comparison, Japan tends to inject Government money through infrastructure projects. Some of the infrastructure projects are expensive for what they accomplish, but at least they're real things.
- animefan 11y agoOpen market operations can't really be characterized as lending to banks. Instead, the Fed buys various kinds of debt, especially US govt bonds, thus injecting money into the economy. The fed funds rate is really the rate at which banks lend to each other. Banks are privileged in that they have a special legal mandate to act as banks, but they are not privileged in terms of access to credit (they can borrow at the "discount window" but this is less important than the Fed's open market operations). But more importantly, QE is more like injecting money into "real things" since it is buying corporate debt that presumably funds real projects. So the (alleged) failure of QE is not very good evidence for your claim that standard monetary policy is bad. EDIT: and they main reason I and most economists prefer US style monetary policy is that it's very neutral: you have a lever, and that lever is how much bonds you buy. You can choose various flavors of bonds, and various maturities, but they are all fundamentally the same. In contrast, the government directly funding real projects lends itself to corruption and favoritism.
- pjmorris 11y ago> You can choose various flavors of bonds, and various maturities, but they are all fundamentally the same. It appears to me that you've just equated a US Treasury bond with a private label subprime RMBS. How strongly do you feel about that equivalence?
- pjmorris 11y ago> You can choose various flavors of bonds, and various maturities, but they are all fundamentally the same. It appears to me that you've just equated a US Treasury bond with a private label subprime RMBS. Is that a fair assessment? If so, how strongly do you feel about that equivalence? I see the private label RMBS's as less of a 'real thing'.
- pdkl95 11y agoTo paraphrase Mark Blyth (Prof. Econ. at Brown), QE is the absolute worst way to deal with our banking mess, except doing nothing. It kept the US from crashing into the mess that Europe is in. That was probably good, but it was effectively a class-specific put option. "Not crashing" does not necessarily mean "positive boost".
- sjg007 11y agoBanks are broken, they will only issue mortgages, high interest credit cards and charge fees.
- adventured 11y agoThey're not issuing nearly as many mortgages. Non bank mortgage lending is nearly 40% of the market at present, up from 13% in 2012. http://www.cnbc.com/2015/04/01/guess-whos-issuing-slews-of-mortgages-not-your-bank.html http://www.cnbc.com/2015/04/01/guess-whos-issuing-slews-of-m...
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoHard to judge what would have happened had the policy not been in effect. Only 1 sample in the experiment.