6 ms·
Here is Smart City's response. http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/view?id=60001011936 http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/view?id=60001011936 Among other interes
by notacoward 11y ago
Here is Smart City's response.
http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/view?id=60001011936 http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/document/view?id=60001011936
Among other interesting points is that they seem to have been using the same "de-authentication" trick that Marriott had used in a similar case a while ago. Also, they make an argument about density and interference that IMO shouldn't be dismissed out of hand. I still think they were wrong and deserved the fine, but it's worth keeping in mind that mobile hotspots can fall afoul of the very same principle and law behind that fine.
- mikeash 11y agoHow would mobile hotspots fall afoul of the same thing? If you get enough of them active in the same area you might get degraded or even nonexistent service, but that's not at all the same thing as sending fake deauthentication packets in a deliberate act to prevent other devices from working.
- notacoward 11y agoNo, it's not the same as sending de-auth packets, but it's still interference with their signal on their property and that's an issue quite worthy of concern. That's why we have laws about jamming devices or radiated-power limits. I think their reaction was inappropriate, but the basic principle of not interfering with others' communications still cuts both ways. We need a better way to deal with such conflicts, which are only going to become more and more frequent and severe.
- mikeash 11y agoThe whole idea of these unlicensed bands is that there are limits on power and such, and otherwise you can more or less do what you want as long as you're not deliberately interfering with other people. If your legitimate use happens to step on other people's legitimate use, well, so it goes. If you want to make sure nobody else can interfere with you, use a licensed frequency and obtain a license for your use. I think this raises an interesting point. There ought to be some frequency bands accessible by common WiFi hardware which require a license to use. Then big venues like this could set up their networks on licensed bands, after obtaining a license, and be free from interference by people's mobile hotspots and such. Although I have a feeling that approximately nobody would actually go through the process of getting a license, because the whole "interference" thing is just a cover, and their actual motivation is a cash grab by attempting to force people to use their spectacularly overpriced service.
- notacoward 11y ago> There ought to be some frequency bands accessible by common WiFi hardware which require a license to use. Thank you for keeping this constructive. That's exactly the kind of discussion we need to have. Certainly there are likely to be all of the problems we've seen in every other aspect of spectrum allocation and licensing, but at least exploring the possibilities might lead to a better solution. Certain others' insistence on denial and bluster won't get us anywhere.
- xenadu02 11y agoWe have a system to address the public airwaves, which include all the airwaves on all property since the electromagnetic spectrum conveniently ignores our artificial property boundaries. That system is called "licensing" and SmartCity is completely free to apply for a license to own their own slice of spectrum. When you are talking about single-building uses or point-to-point links they aren't even that expensive (unlike regional or national cellular frequencies for example). Good luck getting hardware makers to adopt your special snowflake system! WiFi operates on unlicensed bands. By using such bands you are bound by various rules (like power transmit limits) designed to ensure everyone has shared access. WiFi itself is designed to scale down power and share transmit time to keep the noise low. In fact using a personal hotspot isn't likely to cause much interference since the devices are likely right next to each other and transmitting at very low power levels. What you can't do is take the spectrum, protocols, and devices designed to allow everyone to share and hijack it to stop other people from using it. You might make the case that officially certified WiFi devices should include some frequency bands that are license-only so that large venues could apply for exclusive use of certain frequencies* but unless and until that happens you are legally required to abide by the same rules as everyone else, even on your property. * As radio chips get better it becomes more and more feasible to include the hardware for a multitude of frequencies (chips, amps, filters, etc); eventually SDR will make it possible to support a huge range.
- nickodell 11y ago>That system is called "licensing" and SmartCity is completely free to apply for a license to own their own slice of spectrum. In this context, (hotel internet) it doesn't seem reasonable to ask them to start manufacturing their own wireless cards that support a wider spectrum, since everybody staying at the hotel would need one.
- mikeash 11y agoWe're not asking them to do this, just saying that this is what they'd have to do if they want to have a frequency that's protected from other users. Right now, hotels have two choices. They can support cheap commodity equipment that uses unlicensed spectrum, but they have to accept that everyone is allowed to use that spectrum as they wish (within the rules) and this might impact the hotel's use. Or they can use expensive specialized equipment that nobody owns, and have guaranteed exclusivity to their bit of spectrum in that area. I think a third choice would be great, to have commodity hardware that can access licensed spectrum so that venues who want to guarantee exclusivity can obtain a license while allowing their users to use standard hardware. But that third choice isn't available, so the reality of the situation is the two choices above. Naturally, venues pick the option with commodity equipment and no exclusivity. And that's totally fine. But they can't then try to force exclusivity into the situation afterwards.
- jellicle 11y ago> interference with their signal on their property The local physical property owner has no more right (and no less right) to use the unlicensed bands than anyone else does.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- urda 11y ago> but it's worth keeping in mind that mobile hotspots can fall afoul of the very same principle and law behind that fine. Absolutely wrong. Mobile hotspots do not actively transmit deauth packets into their surrounding environment.
- notacoward 11y agoTry being a bit less myopic, and less rude while you're at it. Yes, the mechanism is different, but the basic problem of interfering with others' communication is the same.
- urda 11y agoAlso absolutely wrong. There is a complete difference between a noisy environment (lots of mobile hotspots / access points) and an environment with an active attacker (device sending out deliberate deauth signals). Try to understand the difference, it's the key to the case.
- notacoward 11y agoYou keep on using those words. They do not mean what you think they mean. "Absolutely" is not a synonym for IMO. "Complete" is not a synonym for "slight". Keys to the case? You clearly didn't even read the response. Probably couldn't even have found it without my help, and apparently you don't know the law either. The difference here is that jamming and interference are regulated by statute. De-auth packets aren't. There is precedent (the Marriott case) for treating them as equivalent to jamming, but so far no actual law. Does that seem wrong to you? It does to me too, but if you want to get all hyper-aggressive about "key to the case" then you have to understand what the law actually says. Try to understand the difference between what the law is and what we think it should be. It's key to every case.
- kps 11y ago> 47 U.S. Code § 333 - Willful or malicious interference > > No person shall willfully or maliciously interfere with > or cause interference to any radio communications of any > station licensed or authorized by or under this chapter > or operated by the United States Government. The method of interference (‘jamming’ or sending deauth packets) is irrelevant.
- forgottenpass 11y agoAlso, they make an argument about density and interference that IMO shouldn't be dismissed out of hand. The point isn't worthless in general, but it's worthless in the context of the text and principle of 44 US Code 333. In that case, I will dismiss it out of hand. it's worth keeping in mind that mobile hotspots can fall afoul of the very same principle and law behind that fine What mobile hotspots maliciously interfere with eachother's operation?
- Someone1234 11y ago> For instance, in those cases in which Smart City has used de-authentication in the past, it targeted only access points and wireless devices that are located within the confined and proprietary space of the exhibit hall -- areas of a convention center that are licensed for private event and to which access is limited -- and that pose a threat to secure, reliable, WiFi availability within that confined space. That's not how WiFi works. They cannot know for a fact that these WiFi hotspots are within the convention space, they could and likely are, blocking WiFi located outside of that space. Additionally they're claiming that they literally own the radio spectrum within a "proprietary space" which is a dangerous line. What is stopping them from blocking all cellular signals or worse charging cellphone companies for the signal travelling through their space? Their point about security is nonsense. The technology they're employing is DESIGNED to secure WiFi networks by disconnecting actually rogue APs (i.e. devices squawking the same SSID as their network), that is still legal, the problem they and the Hilten ran into is that they took tech' designed for security and mis-used it for monopolising the WiFi spectrum within their convention centers. So, sorry, no. If your WiFi network is called SmartCityWiFi and you disconnect MyHotSpot then you're breaking the law and have zero security arguments to make. Good on the FCC for giving these guys a fine. Too bad it wasn't more. I read their arguments and it has only made me side with the FCC more. What they're asking for would make the world a worse place in general and only helps their bottom line.
- notacoward 11y ago> They cannot know for a fact that these WiFi hotspots are within the convention space You don't think triangulation can be that accurate? > they could and likely are, blocking WiFi located outside of that space. You have even less basis for that statement than they had for theirs. > They're claiming that they literally own the radio spectrum within a "proprietary space" which is a dangerous line. Absolutely agree. That's why we need to have those conversations, instead of just oversimplifying into "bad guys" trying to meet their SLAs and "good guys" bringing whatever gadgets they want to the party. > If your WiFi network is called SmartCityWiFi and you disconnect MyHotSpot then you're breaking the law [citation needed] > Good on the FCC for giving these guys a fine I agree. In my opinion spoofing de-auth packets should be legally equivalent to jamming (currently it's not) and should be severely punished. The fine was deserved. On the other hand, let's not rush to throw the baby out with the bathwater. There is a serious issue here, which won't go away until we face it.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Here is Smart City's response. No, its not. This is quite obvious from the time of the documents (The January 15 document you point to could not, even without looking at its content, be a response to the settlement the FCC just announced with Smart City.) If you actually read the content of the thing you say is "Smart City's response", its Smart City's response comments in support of a petition filed by Marriot [0]seeking to have the FCC repudiate the principle that formed part of the basis for the judgement against Marriot and Smart City. But note that even in that response, Smart City does not take the position that the actions for which it was being investigated, which it admitted to in the Consent Decree and claims to have discontinued when it learned of the investigation in 2014, should be permitted, instead taking a position that de-authentication should be allowed when based on specific objective measures indicating a threat to networks, whereas what they were doing (by their own admission) before, and were fined for, was indiscriminating sending de-authentication packets shut down WiFi access points that they did not control. [0] which Marriott withdrew later the same month as the Smart City response was filed; the FCC file on that petition is http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/proceeding/view?name=RM-11737 http://apps.fcc.gov/ecfs/proceeding/view?name=RM-11737
- notacoward 11y ago> This is quite obvious from the time of the document What, time didn't exist before today's decision? It was a response - just to an earlier round of the same debate. Thanks for letting me know who one of my stalkers is, though.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> What, time didn't exist before today's decision? Time did, and part of time is that responses don't occur before the thing they respond to. > It was a response - just to an earlier round of the same debate Its not even that; its a response in a parallel but tangentially related proceeding that started after the complaint on which the current Consent Decree was filed, addressed a different issue, and was never resolved because the party that filed it (Marriott) later withdrew it. And Smart City's response in that proceeding essentially argues that the FCC can and should prohibit the conduct which Smart City admitted to in the consent decree, though it argues that the prohibition should be based on a different legal foundation than the one cited in the Marriott and now Smart City consent decrees. (It also argues that the FCC should not prohibit a different, more targeted practice of de-authing that is actually based on more specific objective indicia of a threat to an existing network, which no FCC enforcement action as yet has targeted.)
- FireBeyond 11y ago"Also, they make an argument about density and interference that IMO shouldn't be dismissed out of hand" Absolutely it should. It might make for a shitty experience, but the whole (un) license of the Wifi spectrum is "it's a free-for-all, suck it up". However many users are there, microwaves, you name it. "May not produce interference to other users, must accept any and all interference".
- Animats 11y agoAnd they lost, just as Marriott did. Key point here: there is no real estate "private property right" to RF spectrum under US law. This is well established.