4 ms·
I use primarily bike and public transit ... but given that, if you were to measure flow, that is to say, how many people traverse a given unit distance per unit
by kristopolous 11y ago
I use primarily bike and public transit ... but given that, if you were to measure flow, that is to say, how many people traverse a given unit distance per unit time, how would the numbers change?
I think cars may be given a more favorable score in a metric of transport as opposed to what amounts to a metric of occupancy.
But then there's parking ... and that's why I'm usually on the bike; with casual non-crazy, follow-all-the-laws riding, in the inner city, I'll beat my motorist friends by 5-10 minute margins. I often start to worry that they got in an accident or got lost because it takes them so long. It's really remarkable.
- Symbiote 11y agoTrains might well win in that case, especially metro trains in cities. You can move at least 500 people every 3-4 minutes, less if you try especially hard. Cars in London average 19mph (30km/h) on "major roads" and 9mph (14km/h) in Central London.
- kristopolous 11y ago9mph? Might as well lace up a decent pair of shoes and get the heart rate up; you'd get a pace better than that down in a couple of months without worry.
- DanBC 11y agoExercising in London pollution is probably a bad idea. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-33536989 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-33536989 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32233922 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32233922
- ciaranm 11y agoWhat nonsense. You expect all the health improvements of exercise to be negated by poor air quality? It should be noted that both of your links were not average days. There's a reason that made the news.
- DanBC 11y agoPollution in London is consistently poor. That's why the UK gov loses court cases over air quality. > The supreme court has ordered the government to make plans for tackling the UK’s air pollution problem, which has been in breach of EU limits for years and is linked to thousands of premature deaths each year. http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/apr/29/supreme-court-orders-uk-to-draw-up-air-pollution-cleanup-plan http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/apr/29/supreme-c... > You expect all the health improvements of exercise to be negated by poor air quality? Yes, in this level of pollution there are considerable risks that need to be balanced against benefits of exercise.
- ciaranm 11y ago>Exercising in London pollution is probably a bad idea Is not the same as: >Yes, in this level of pollution there are considerable risks that need to be balanced against benefits of exercise. I dispute the former, not the latter. Unless you show me some evidence that exercising in a polluted city is somehow worse than living-but-not-exercising in said city, I'm going to continue to dispute that. Encouraging people to avoid exercise is incredibly reckless.
- DanBC 11y agoI'm not encouraging people to avoid exercise. I'm encouraging people to avoid exercise as part of their commute (when pollution is going to be high), in London streets (where, again, pollution is highest). Nothing about "Don't jog to work at times when pollution is highest in places where pollution is highest" says "avoid exercise" and it's a perverse interpretation to suggest otherwise.
- ciaranm 11y agoAgain - if you'd made these points, I probably wouldn't have commented. You didn't; you flat out suggested exercising in London was a Bad Idea. I think you'll find that the benefits outweigh the negatives[1] Also, how does one commute to work in central London without exposure to air pollution? I'm curious what your alternative suggestion is. [1] https://intranet2.bham.ac.uk/collaboration/cycling/documents/public/C-Health2.pdf https://intranet2.bham.ac.uk/collaboration/cycling/documents...
- Litost 11y agoIt turns out that driving in london or using public transport (bus at least) is noticeably less healthy than walking [1]. I imagine if you could fit in a run through some less busy and/or green spaces you might be overall better off?? [1] http://www.theguardian.com/environment/video/2014/aug/12/london-air-pollution-public-transport-video http://www.theguardian.com/environment/video/2014/aug/12/lon...
- antimagic 11y agoHardly. Average speed for the Paris marathon is about 6mins/km or 10kph. And that's people fit enough to be able to actually run a marathon, most of whom have substantially trained for the event, so not the average joker off the street that prepped for "a couple of months". The fastest female runners are running at 18kph. That's Olympic standard. The average female marathon runner runs at about 9.3kph. Only competitive male runners would be capable of beating that pace. Edit: Disclosure - female, and I run a half marathon in two hours That's 10 minutes faster than the average woman and around about average for the entire field. To achieve that time I play an active sport, and train for longer running events (I'm the fastest long distance runner in my sports club). In kph I manage a bit less than 11, which is a long way off 14kph.
- kristopolous 11y agoah, well then, make sure that decent pair of shoes have some inline wheels attached to them.
- revelation 11y agoYet all those people can easily do 20kph+ on a bike.
- antimagic 11y agoAbsolutely! With an electric bike, even the unfittest person can roll along at 25kph. And you don't even have to break a sweat if you don't want to!
- antimagic 11y agoAbsolutely! With an electric bike, even the unfittest person can roll along at 25kph. And you don't even have to break a sweat if you don't want to!
- pouetpouet 11y agoIn european center cities, car mean speeds are usually <= 12mph (<20 km/h). You can get faster on a bike if you are made confortable enough to do this (it boils down to bike infrastructure).
- dspillett 11y agoFor some locations and travel distances I'd not disagree with you, but there is more to factor in here. What distance is that 9mph over? My running ability has jumped from "can't even face 2km" to "5km in less than 23 minutes most of the time" (PB:21m53s) in about six months due to a new found attitude to health+fitness, but that is still less than 9mph so that sort of rate is going to be a short distance sprint. My 10Km pace (PB:46m21s though minutes or two more than that us more usual) is below 8mph. While I'm sure most average people could match or better my achievements here, I doubt most would want to bother! What about recovery afterwards? When I run into the office there is a cool down period (basically walking about or lounging until I stop actively sweating) followed by a shower and getting dressed. They don't want me in the office caked in sweat and smelling as you'd expect from that! If I take the 10KM-ish route that makes the whole affair more like 75 minutes than then the less-than-50 I'm running and for my 5KM-ish route the recovery and shower time is longer than the running time so effectively halving my pace without even considering any warm-up time before I hit the pavement with a vengeance. Also running every day is not recommended unless you are only doing a short distance, unless you are trying to wreck your joints, no matter how good your shoes are. Of course you could switch "run+recover+shower" for just walking the distance both ways every day and use up about the same amount of time, and for many people that might beat the car or public transport based commute if they gave it a try. Cycling (including the public cycles that exist in London, depending how the hire costs compare to the op-front and running costs of your own kit) are probably a better idea than running though some of the above would count for many people there too.
- unfamiliar 11y agoYou can move at least 500 people every 3-4 minutes from A to B, but nowhere in between A and B.
- PopeOfNope 11y agoThat solves it, then! Everybody should be required to ride motorcycles and lane splitting should be legal everywhere. Best of both worlds!