10 ms·
> But if you know of any stories like those reported, I want you to escalate to HR. You can also email me directly at jeff@amazon.com. Even if it’s rare or isol
by rdtsc 11y ago
> But if you know of any stories like those reported, I want you to escalate to HR. You can also email me directly at jeff@amazon.com. Even if it’s rare or isolated, our tolerance for any such lack of empathy needs to be zero.
I say don't escalate to HR but leave to work at another place. HR is not your advocate, it is not there to help you. You are just a "resource" just like it says in the name.
There have been many cases I've heard (personally and from HN comments) where someone would go to HR, complain about harassment by their manager, get assurance of confidentiality, and the next thing you know the manager is told right away. Or the person who complained gets punished instead.
Now you can try to go public and force its hand to basically realign HR's interest (protect the company) with yours (you get heard and the problem is fixed). But that won't be forgotten in the long term.
- arethuza 11y agoWhen I worked at a multinational with hundreds of locations, HR turning up at site was sign that somebody was going to get it in the neck - HR didn't bother with small stuff so if they were about you knew it was serious for someone. [Edit: Made me think about how ghastly it must be to work in HR for a large company]
- kabdib 11y agoWhen your immediate managers have canceled all meetings and have been unreachable for three days ... ... when there is a mandatory "all hands" meeting called with two hour's notice ... ... and when you show up, there is HR present, plus people from the management stratosphere (who you've really only ever seen in TV) ... Well, you know things are not going to go very well.
- degradas 11y agoThere is book a called Corporate Confidential [1], written by a former HR person. One of most significant ideas there is that HR is (from the perspective of an employee) not your friend, but rather an enemy. They exist to protect the company, not you. Basically, going to HR is a quick way to get fired (for legal reasons, mind you) or kill your career. Whole book is highly depressing, but very useful if you want to try to climb up the ladder. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Corporate-Confidential-Secrets-Company-Know/dp/0312337361 http://www.amazon.com/Corporate-Confidential-Secrets-Company...
- notNow 11y agoI guess that this is just applicable to Corporate America context and the outlook is not as dire as you portray it for other corporate cultures around the world.
- Yhippa 11y agoIf this is true then that's real bad for Bezos to come out and say that. It's almost as if he's doubling-down on Amazon's evilness.
- vonmoltke 11y agoIt's basically the standard corporatespeak reaction to this kind of negative publicity.
- k__ 11y agoI worked in HR a few times and this is right. Not because the people there are assholes. They are really nice and want to employ everybody forever. But they just can't. Often the leadership of HR is the problem. In civil service, the HR bosses were all about getting their friends and family a job. In the free marked, they wanted to minimize costs and legal obligations to the employees. The rest of the HR-workforce just has to suck it up and they often don't like it...
- deciplex 11y ago> Not because the people there are assholes. They are really nice and want to employ everybody forever. Some. Maybe. But there is also something to be said for being really cut out for a particular line of work. Those types definitely exist as well.
- DannyBee 11y agoThey exist in every profession, HR is no better or worse. Witness the number of startups which end up in PR disasters, etc.
- 11y ago
- anotherangrydev 11y agoHR is never your friend. Aside from the job they're required to do, HR usually attracts people with despicable morals and class. They wont hesitate on lying to you, set you up on to something, threaten you, whatever it takes to get what they (personally) want. Stay clear of HR, that is true for 99% of jobs.
- GnomeChomsky 11y agoAren't people with "despicable morals and class" in every profession? Some of us are actually in HR because we like thinking critically & creatively behind the scenes to make others successful. I totally get why that might not describe the HR teams you've encountered, but I don't think we can all be characterized with such a broad brush.
- anotherangrydev 11y agoYou're the 1%, then. Honestly, I haven't met one decent guy in HR in a loooong time. Quite the contrary, I have plenty of bad experiences with HR that made me believe those things. I'll give you my favorite examples: I once got fired because I told some bitch (she was really a bitch, and that's not just my opinion, the whole workplace thought of that) to mind her own business. I was on a break and reading a magazine when she came in and started lecturing me on to "why I'm not doing other stuff? why do I read those kinds of magazines? (It was a gossip magazine, but who cares it was what it was nearby) I'm a little old for that." Politely but firmly told her something like "This is my break. Fuck off, you can't tell me what to do on my break and I read whatever I want to". She left. Three months later got called to get fired, turns out she was secretly raising reports about me that were small stuff (and completely fake) like "... was asked to do X and refused", "... yelled at a client", "... reads magazines while at work (of course)". When I had like 10 or so of them she fired me because of a "bad overall attitude" and those were her (fake) proofs. That's the kind of shit HR LOVES to do man. Another one. I once knew (but not as in "a friend told me", I saw it) of a place where all the candidates that got hired were because they were laying down with the girl that ran the interviews. Later when they got the job, they started to get fired when that girl found them not sexually appealing anymore. Yup. I think there has to be something psychological behind that, because other while other teammates may be assholes your job does not depend direclty on them or you are pretty much at the same level. Since HR is above you and can fire you at will there is a lot of power bestowed to only one side of the parts involved. I think it may be some kind of Stanford Prison stuff right there. Sorry to call it mate but your field is a rotten one.
- notNow 11y agoHR functions like the lowest level of police forces within a polity, they're there just to snitch on you to their superiors (next level up law enforcement within the corporation) or deal with you directly whether in fines, suspension or exile. So, yeah I wouldn't trust HR with these matters and it seems to me that Bezos is only interested in cover-ups when he recommended this course of action out of fear that employees may seek friends in the press to expose those practices from now on undermining his plans of non stop exploitation at his sweatshop.
- jaegerpicker 11y agoOnly if you work in a very poor workplace. If your workplace HR has this attitude you should have not joined the company in the first place. You should escalate to the next higher up if the manager in question is not being correctly handled by HR.
- masklinn 11y ago> Only if you work in a very poor workplace. Or a standard workplace with shit legal protection of employees (which applies to pretty much every non-union US shop). The purpose of HR is to minimise company liability, when the best and simplest way to minimise company liability is to fire employees making waves stat, that's what they do, because that what they're employed to do.
- Pxtl 11y agohttp://dilbert.com/strip/2011-02-20 http://dilbert.com/strip/2011-02-20
- FilterSweep 11y agoNotice how the devs weren't mentioned ;)
- marcosdumay 11y agoThey are the only technical department. They do dev.
- gnurag 11y agoIts amazing how Dilbert has a comic strip about almost every corporate quirkiness.
- hga 11y agoWhat he didn't learn first hand at Crocker National Bank and Pacific Bell was forwarded to him by others. As Wikipedia puts it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_Adams#Office_worker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_Adams#Office_worker): "Adams attributes his success to his idea of including his e-mail address in the panels, thus facilitating feedback from readers."
- fweespeech 11y agoYeah, the moment he said that, everyone with a brain realized he was being disingenuous. He would need to make public clear, explicit instructions stating HR would take a zero tolerance for a lack of empathy and that confidentiality would be guaranteed as well as providing a copy of a memo to the entire HR department to that effect. A single line in a PR puff piece isn't a shield you can rely on.
- pinaceae 11y agoseems like people in the US mistake the Human Resources department with Workers Councils. in Europe, you go to the Council, never to HR. the Council is job protected, guaranteed pay - hence no way to apply pressure from the company. HR is not a bad department, they are very important, but they serve the CEO, their role is to keep the whole thing going, avoid waves of any kind and keep a good hiring pipeline. surprised no union is trying this to break into amazon.
- computer 11y agoYou speak about "Europe" like it's a country with a single set of regulations. It's not-- it's a continent. Even for the European Union, the rules are actually extremely varied: http://www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relations/Across-Europe/Workplace-Representation2 http://www.worker-participation.eu/National-Industrial-Relat... And even those countries with councils have (as the link also mentions) very varying rules on exactly what the councils do. Please don't say "Europe" when you mean "some European country".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pinaceae 11y agoso Germany has not taken over all of Europia? color me surprised. oder aber du checker überlegst mal, für wen die simplifizierung 'Europa' gedacht war.
- binxbolling 11y agoLet's not delude ourselves: in the US, in public non-union orgs, everyone is there to serve the CEO. Some people in this thread make it sound like every department is actively thwarting senior management and working counter to the company's business—except HR, who are in on the game or something. So, fuck HR, right? They couldn't possibly be one cog, along with every other cog, in a larger machine designed to extract value from workers for owners/shareholders.
- xornor 11y agoNever trust HR in big companies. They are there to do human resource management easy for directors. Their task is to do everything for the company.
- OnleMeMeMe 11y agoAll the HR people I've met in large companies are nice people who care, but when push comes to shove they side with the company/CEO as HR is a CEO support function - sadly.
- adultSwim 11y agoIf only there was a structure to represent workers where we could take such issues...
- NoGravitas 11y agoMaybe workers could come together to build such a structure...somewhere they could come together to negotiate their conditions of employment...
- rdtsc 11y agoNot that crazy some movie and animation studio developers in Hollywood are in a union.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoWho other than Dreamworks?
- asgard1024 11y agoWhat a revolutionary idea! Seriously though, I wonder why humans tolerate the hierarchical structures so much. I am proponent of direct democracy and worker cooperatives but curiously enough, to many people the idea seems wrong.
- Karunamon 11y agoJust about every human endeavor out there tends toward hierarchal structures - ones that do not are statistical outliers, and even then it's questioned whether all that's happened is that the hierarchy is implicit rather than explicit.
- asgard1024 11y ago> Just about every human endeavor out there tends toward hierarchal structures I agree, but why? It doesn't make much sense to me. Although I should have said "authoritarian" rather than "hierarchical". > it's questioned whether all that's happened is that the hierarchy is implicit rather than explicit In democracy, you can have hierarchy but it's not a big deal, because you have a formal rule that everybody has the same power (one vote). It is certainly different (although for some reason many people do not feel that way) than when there is no such rule.
- JoshuaEddy 11y agoI want to realign HR under a "Chief Productivity Officer" who is also responsible for IT. The CPO's goal and metric is maximization of workforce productivity by getting employees working smart, working hard, retaining good people and getting rid of the bad, improving management skills, and leveraging technology.
- bananasNfucku 11y agoYou want to increase productivity by adding layers of complexity. OK.
- kabdib 11y ago+1. The few times I've seen HR involved in a workplace kerfuffle, it's never been an improvement. More like the Spanish Inquisition, where they don't care if you're guilty and they're just arguing over what tools to use. Never piss off a co-worker who happens to be the girlfriend of someone in the management chain above you. That . . . did not go well.
- frobozz 11y agoAlways take it to your union rep first. Your union is your advocate, and is there to help you. They can advise you on the most appropriate next step for your particular workplace. They can take it to HR, anonymously (depending on context), for you. They can ask their members if anyone else has similar issues, in order to add weight to your complaint and ensure that HR take corrective action to fix the source of the problem, rather than sweeping individual complaints under the carpet. They can advise you on presenting appropriate evidence so that HR see your complaint as valid, rather than as a whinge.
- cylinder 11y agoAre you American? White collar unions are basically non-existent in the US private sector.
- branchless 11y agoHere is what I've learned in my time on earth: > you can't change the system but you can change the system you are in Just leave.
- bdavisx 11y agoI've heard it put: "If you can't change your company, then change your company."
- happywolf 11y agoAgree with all the other folks on the importance not to seek help from HR. Am working in an MNC in Singapore. HR's chief objective is to protect the company. The only time it helps the employees is when something will hinder productivity or/and morale. Period. Whether you are happy, achieving work-life balance, fulfilled, etc. It doesn't give a fuck on all those. If an Amazonian approaches HR now to report an issue covered by NYT, that person very likely will be grilled and interrogated to see if he/she spoke to NYT. So Jeff is right. If you are not happy, dust off books and study on your own on skills needed for interviews, shut up and move out.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- balls187 11y agoThis whole notion of "HR isn't your friend" is nonsensical. No department at the company is your friend. You stop performing at your job, you will probably be fired--or promoted. Even your real friends won't be your friends for very long if their own self-interests are always in contention against your own. HR is fulfills a specific sets of roles for the company and they exist to look out for the best interest of the company, the same way pretty much any other department operates. Even executives have to operate in such a manner or be in breach of their fiduciary duties. If your work environment is toxic, find a better environment---if you have that luxury as some do not. If you think the problem isn't pervasive, try to change it with the help of HR--clearly it's in the companies best interest not to have toxic work environments.
- rdtsc 11y ago> No department at the company is your friend. Of course not, except not many disguise themselves as your friend, that was the point. Nobody thinks the finance department is there to make your life easy as a developer or to somehow take your side vis-a-vis an argument with the higher-ups. But somehow the image of "HR" working for the employees and advocating for them persists. Just read Jeff's email as an example. "Take it up with HR". In other words, don't worry, we'll fix it for ya.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> But somehow the image of "HR" working for the employees and advocating for them persists. One of the most important techniques HR departments have in maximizing the extracted value to extraction cost ratio for the company's "human resources" is to convince those resources that the HR department is their advocate within the company rather than the company's office responsible for the aforementioned cost/benefit optimization. (OTOH, there are good reasons for a well-run HR department to be an employee advocate within the company on issues in many cases, since often the cost effective way to keep employees productive is to address their needs and desires; but its important to understand why that may sometimes be the case, and why it is not universally the case.)
- rrss1122 11y agoFrom all that's come out over the weekend, it sounds like former Amazon employees are quite welcome over at Facebook. Plus, like Bezos says in his all-hands e-mail, these people are recruited every day. If they are in a situation like that, escalating to HR won't make it better, changing jobs will.