8 ms·
Why is Bitcoin forking?
- datashovel 11y agoIt's somewhat ironic that one of the big selling points of Bitcoin was decentralization. The thing that they failed to realize is the team also needs to be decentralized. For something like this to take off it needs to be a specification for a federated network with zero single points of failure, and not an actual codebase with a dedicated team.
- mahouse 11y agoIt was just naïve to think that a decentralised monetary system could work. Some people think that regulation is evil.
- bad_user 11y agoFunny, a successful decentralized monetary system has existed for quite some time, being the oldest monetary system in existence and probably the one that will still be relevant in 1000 years from now ... Gold ;-) In my mind the only useful trait of Bitcoin has been its decentralized nature. Take that away and I'd rather deal with USD, EUR and my local banking system, thank you very much.
- mahouse 11y agoImplying gold would not be regulated if people turned to it. And for me, the only dangerous thing of Bitcoin is its decentralised nature.
- hga 11y agoGood point, e.g. from 1933 through 1974 it was illegal for Americans to own gold: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Order_6102
- kalleboo 11y agoAnd in a world with only physical gold and no electronic payments, credit cards, wires, how quickly would business move?
- hga 11y agoThat old problem has of course been addressed, e.g. by using things like gold certificates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_certificate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_certificate Which add their own set of problems, but at least you get a clear signal when they get repudiated. Or you use banks, letters of credit from them (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_of_credit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_of_credit), etc.
- dragontamer 11y agoExcept Gold Certificates are fake money. Many crashes in the 1800s were about Banks issuing too many certificates for the amount of Gold that was actually stored in their vaults. Gold Certificates are no different than credit cards or fractional reserve banking. The bank makes a promise without proving anything, and people are expected to trust the banks for things to work out. And when the poop hits the fan, people look into the vaults and realize they've been fooled. Maybe the gold really was there, but has been loaned out to another bank (and the banks have gold certificates to another bank). And maybe _THAT_ other bank has been lying this whole time. Its your standard economic issues, too big to fail and all that. Besides, leaving the Gold Standard was how the world recovered from the Great Depression. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression#Gold_standard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Depression#Gold_standard
- hga 11y agoExcept Gold Certificates are fake money. Which might be why I said: but at least you get a clear signal when they get repudiated. When, not if. I think this may be better than how fiat money "works", but obviously opinions vary.
- 11y ago
- gus_massa 11y ago> specification for a federated network with zero single points of failure The problem is that some people want to change the specification (bigger blocks) and some want to keep the current specification. The block size is part of the specification or that it's only an implementation detail? For me, it's not clear what a "specification for a federated networks" means * One interpretation is that the specification is written in assembler and is the current official Bitcoin client, and any other client has to be 100% bug compatible with it. Nobody can change it ever. * Another interpretation is that anyone can add a new version inside a general framework, and somehow the people decide which version to use. You need some kind of number identifier for each version, or to make it user friendly you can use a nickname. If the network is too general, you can include Bitcoin and Litecoin (and all the Altcoins) in it. The network is just Internet. Both alternatives have "zero single points of failure". The problem is that people want something in between.
- datashovel 11y agoI imagine it would be closer to the 2nd of the two. When I've thought about it, I come to the conclusion that the base specification needs to be so simple (with clear path for extensibility) that no one will disagree, and everyone can see that it's critical for an electronic currency to exist. Namely the ability to own it, and to exchange it. Another thing is, I believe that in order for something like a global electronic currency to become universally accepted, without support from / cooperation with governments, there can be no center of power, and unfortunately structurally I can't imagine something like that could happen with a blockchain-based currency. Don't get me wrong. I see the beauty / elegance of the blockchain, but I can't get my mind wrapped around the idea that everyone (or even a significant percentage of people) around the world will accept the idea that their currency is at the mercy of decisions being made by some relatively small group of people who basically answer to no one except in the sense that they'll always attempt to do popular things in order to prevent people from leaving their currency for another.
- facepalm 11y agoThere are several different implementations of the protocol, nobody controls "THE" codebase.
- datashovel 11y agoBut all of the different implementations require the same centralization.
- facepalm 11y agoWhat do you mean? The only thing that matter is what application the users employ. The people who convince the most people to use their protocol/implementation "win" (or they have the strongest fork or whatever). I don't see where centralization enters into the equation?
- datashovel 11y agoYes, your point is valid.
- lawn 11y agoFor more context, here's a list of posts by Mike giving some background and some more thoughts: The capacity cliff: https://medium.com/@octskyward/the-capacity-cliff-586d1bf7715e https://medium.com/@octskyward/the-capacity-cliff-586d1bf771... Crash landing: https://medium.com/@octskyward/crash-landing-f5cc19908e32 https://medium.com/@octskyward/crash-landing-f5cc19908e32 On consensus and forks: https://medium.com/@octskyward/on-consensus-and-forks-c6a050c792e7 https://medium.com/@octskyward/on-consensus-and-forks-c6a050... They were quite useful for someone not familiar with the topic.
- Taek 11y agoLet's balance the discussion out a bit: Greg Maxwell's thoughts (small blocks): http://sourceforge.net/p/bitcoin/mailman/message/34090559/ http://sourceforge.net/p/bitcoin/mailman/message/34090559/ About internet bandwidth growth (~neutral): http://rusty.ozlabs.org/?p=493 http://rusty.ozlabs.org/?p=493 An attempt at a well-rounded overview (~neutral): http://rusty.ozlabs.org/?p=535 http://rusty.ozlabs.org/?p=535 some thoughts by bittorrent creator Bram Cohen (small blocks): https://medium.com/@bramcohen/bitcoin-s-ironic-crisis-32226a85e39f https://medium.com/@bramcohen/bitcoin-s-ironic-crisis-32226a... Some thoughts by gavin andresen (large blocks): http://gavinandresen.ninja/ http://gavinandresen.ninja/
- bhouston 11y agoSort of interesting that Mr. BitTorrent is involved: > some thoughts by bittorrent creator Bram Cohen (small blocks): https://medium.com/@bramcohen/bitcoin-s-ironic-crisis-32226a85e39f https://medium.com/@bramcohen/bitcoin-s-ironic-crisis-32226a... I give him a fair bit of credit and he really portrays this quite differently than in the main article here. Has anyone responded to Bram Cohen's writeup on the pro side of things?
- lawn 11y agoThank you! I was sorely missing the other side of the discussion.
- im3w1l 11y agoThis was bound to happen sooner or later. Good that is "only" about something relatively minor like this, so that the community can practice handling it. Maybe later there will be a conflict where serious money is on the line and it would be bad if that was the first one. I mean this change will affect miner revenue, but transactions fees are still completely insignificant compared to block rewards.
- ctz 11y agoI thought that if the split does happen all existing coins will be spendable on both sides of the split. Does that not count as 'serious money' on the line?!
- im3w1l 11y agoThat is just like a stock spinoff, it doesn't favour one group of users over another. And the actual forking of the chain (so far only the software has been forked) is some time in the future so everyone will have time to prepare. For an example of something that would favour one group of users over another, we can take a change of block reward decay schedule. If it decays faster, old users are favoured. If it decays slower, new users and miners are favoured. An increase in blocksize later on, when fees are majority of mining revenue would favour users over miners.
- tomp 11y agoAre they also doing anything about the centralization of mining pools? AFAIK, the main problem is that right now it's possible for miners to prove that they were mining "for the pool" and not for themselves. If this proof was impossible, each miner would be a selfish miner and any collaboration would be impossible.
- ProblemFactory 11y agoWould that reduce the centralisation though? An independent miner with an average affordable rig might find somewhere on the order of one block per year on average. This means that due to variability, a good proportion of miners would not find any blocks at all within the lifetime of their hardware, and give up forever. If low-income-variability pooled mining becomes impossible, then my guess is that mining will be centralised to people who run purpose-built datacentres full of miners, not the casual users.
- tomp 11y ago> If low-income-variability pooled mining becomes impossible, then my guess is that mining will be centralised to people who run purpose-built datacentres full of miners, not the casual users. AFAIK, that's already happened. The difference is only that mining pools owned by independent entities wouldn't be able to collaborate. So you'd be more likely to have e.g. 5-10 big pools, as opposed to 2.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wslh 11y agoSecurity is my concern, even simple changes open big bugs. Bitcoin is not a blog engine where you are just exposing your content, it is one of the most delicate protocols found on Internet and most transactions are irreversible (indeed all transactions are irreversible but sometimes you can recover your money). Forking code sounds great but we are talking here about money and assets, I would prefer agreement even when distributed systems are exciting.
- FatalLogic 11y agoYes, but Bitcoin really is just an experiment. If something in it is fundamentally not going to work, (including the consensus development concept), then isn't it best to blow up and fail now when there's only $4 billion at stake, instead coddling it until it stagnates and dies, or until there are trillions of dollars at risk? "...bitcoin is an experiment. It's getting to be a scarier and scarier experiment as it gets larger and larger, because if it fails there will be a lot of people who will lose the money they've invested..." Gavin Andresen, Bitcoin Developer, 2014 - http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/05/gavin_andresen.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/05/gavin_andresen.html
- Taek 11y agoFor people who have not been following along, the Bitcoin block size debate has been very intense and pulled out a lot of interesting psychology from the Bitcoin community. Most of the core devs of Bitcoin are strongly opposed to increasing the blocksize to 8mb. 2 people in particular, Mike Hearn and Gavin Andresen, have been making very strong political pushes to get the majority of Bitcoin users to favor their block size limit increase proposals, and it appears that they have largely been successful. Everyone has an opinion on the block size debate, and it has become clear that politics are very important to Bitcoin. Bitcoin is a complicated and delicate protocol, and having a qualified opinion on something like the blocksize debate likely requires around a year of studying the academic properties of Bitcoin. Most people don't realize this, and hold their own opinion in high esteem. In many ways, this would be similar to non-cryptographers engaging in debates about key scheduling in AES - it takes a lot of education before you are really qualified to make an opinion. Unlike AES however, with Bitcoin most people believe that they have a qualified opinion, and actively engage in debate, religiously clinging to certain ideas without properly grasping their full implications. Perhaps even more interesting is all of the drama and chaos on /r/bitcoin. Right now there are posts with 93% upvotes requesting that the moderators be replaced. The comment threads have lots of brigading, trolling, loudmouthing, and occasional spurts of academic discussion. There are many accusations of the moderators censoring discussion that opposes their viewpoint on the subject. The moderators have been very active in deleting posts. Certainly many of the deletions were of garbage comments, but there also seems to be abuse-of-power happening. Certainly there are many people trying to be as disruptive as possible, and deleting their comments only results in more assertions of censorship. One big controvertial decision by the moderator team was to censor all posts relating to Bitcoin-XT, a client that runs code which will hard-fork Bitcoin after reaching 75% miner-usage. The two biggest proponents of the block size increase are responsible for XT, and censoring posts about XT seems synonymous to censoring topics about the block size. 'Off-topic' really doesn't seem like an appropriate label. The behavior of proponents of both sides of the debate has been abysmal. Something in Bitcoin is broken, and it's not just related to the block size limit. The decision making process, and 'social consensus' process as a whole, needs improvement.
- bhouston 11y ago> having a qualified opinion on something like the blocksize debate likely requires around a year of studying the academic properties of Bitcoin. I do not like statements like that -- it basically says unless you know as much as me (and if you knew as much as me you'd agree with me), you can not have an opinion. It is pretty exclusionary. Most people can get up to speed fairly fast than that if they have access to good information on both pros and cons.
- bhouston 11y agoIs this also sort of a coup attempt? The way this is being done sort of feels like that to me. If there is a fork and it is because of this advocacy of Mike Hearn and friends, do they become more prominent as the defacto leaders of bitcoin?
- bakhy 11y agowhat exactly happens to the value of the currency after the fork? the number of Bitcoins in circulation effectively doubles?
- bhouston 11y agoNormally one side of the fork is considered to be official and the other is deprecated (made worthless.)
- ISL 11y agoSomething complicated will happen for an indeterminate but probably fairly short period of time, and then one fork will emerge as a winner. Nobody wants to buy unspendable BTC, so it's in almost everyone's interest to find consensus, even if it's tragedy-of-the-commons consensus, very quickly.
- paulhauggis 11y agoThis is common with many things now. The people in the know are treated like gods that cant be wrong. The global warming debate comes to mind.
- nathanm412 11y agoThe global warming debate is long settled by pretty much everyone doing research in that area. If that is an example to your case, you didn't make it very well.
- paulhauggis 11y agoThis guy picks apart many of the global warming 'studies' as non-scientific and has some really good counter-examples, which is actual science: http://www.climate-skeptic.com/ http://www.climate-skeptic.com/ There was a study about butterflies migration and everyone just took it as fact that it was due to climate change. When another study came out proving that it was wrong (with more science), the original study was never withdrawn and is still used to this day as an example of climate change. It's not even a debate that CO2 is causing warming. It's that CO2 isn't causing it at anything near a catastrophic rate. It's used by the likes of Al Gore to make billions from things like carbon credits and the politicians to attack their political opponents. It's not the first time the scientific community was used as pawns in someone else's game. So much of the data is either: changed, doctored, or even hidden (climate gate brought out many issues with some of the leading climate scientists and showed that much of the data isn't actually being peer reviewed. I thought this would bring about a discussion about real science...but it was covered up and scoffed at by the scientific community because it made them look bad. We are spending so much money on global climate change, while ignoring many other pollutants that might actually save some of the environmental disasters that we have created(which cost much less to fix). You don't have to be a climate scientist to see bullshit science. I was part of the academic world for many years and it's unbelievable how much politics plays into the research that is published. It's why I left it forever. This post will probably be modded down. Mostly because when something against the narrative is posted here on HN, it's not even discussed. The person who posted it is bullied into submission or silenced because you not only can't see something you disagree with, you can't bear to have someone else see it either. I see it as the tactics of the intellectually inferior. Those insecure people that can't have ideas discussed freely and without prejudice because it goes against their core beliefs. Even the name 'climate skeptic' is a pejorative used to make the other person look like they are an idiot that knows nothing about the climate or science. This has no place in science. Science should not be about personal and ad hominem attacks. That's the funny thing: I'm demanding more science and the climate change zealots are basically saying that the science is 'settled'. The science is never 'settled'. When it is, it's called religion. I'm sick and tired of politics ruling over science and you should be too.
- zekevermillion 11y agoThere is no law against publishing software that would introduce a blockchain hard fork if run. Yes, XT infuriates those who hope to make money based on the appreciation of their pre-fork bitcoins. Publishing XT introduces economic uncertainty in the short term, and long-term undermines confidence that we can rely on the mathematical promises of bitcoin at all. If XT is successful, why wouldn't Hearn (or Coinbase, or another person with interests divergent from large bitcoin holders) publish XT 2.0 removing the coin max? Or introduce any number of other inflationary changes? If it can be done, eventually it will be done. It's inevitable that people will eventually propose all manner of changes to bitcoin, some good, some stupid. Real bitcoin (or original bitcoin) could still continue to run as its own fork, in the background, waiting for the market to decide on a winner. Just as it is inevitable that developers will propose a small infinity of bitcoin-derived altcoins, trying to capture the windfall of a self-published bootstrapped currency. But very few altcoins will become successful networks in the long term, a smaller and smaller percentage of new coins as time goes on. Either Hearn and Andresen are correct, in which case their success will speak for itself -- even if they totally screw over the large bitcoin bag-holders in the process. Or, XT will become an insecure, centralized network and will die off on its own. No need for politics, in this case mathematically dictated incentive structures will decide who wins.
- hollerith 11y ago>Yes, XT infuriates those who hope to make money based on the appreciation of their pre-fork bitcoins. Could someone explain how the XT fork might affect the future value of currently-existing Bitcoins? I expected it to have a neutral effect, since one fork will eventually die out (and since the fork does not try to change the rate at which Bitcoin are created). Even if both forks persists somehow, every holder of a current Bitcoin will essentially have 2 Bitcoin -- one spendable on one fork, another spendable on the other.
- olalonde 11y agoThere is also one possible scenario where both forks survive and become two distinct currencies.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- davidgerard 11y agoAll of this is noise. The opinion that counts is the miners: if the four largest mining pools go for it, it happens; if they don't, it fails.
- lambda 11y agoMmm, no. If the four largest mining pools go for it, but the various exchanges and online wallets do not, then you get a very dangerous fork where you now have two separate currencies, and have the possibility of double spends. The nodes that are not updated to allow these larger block will keep on going along with their chain, just rejecting the other chain as invalid; and the ones that do accept the larger blocks will probably see their chain as longer and so only accept that one. That fork means that until all of the online wallets, exchanges, and anyone accepting Bitcoin directly realize that there are now two different currencies, all kinds of fun can be had with double spending.
- AJ007 11y agoShould we assume any update that "fixes" the mining pool problem will be rejected by the pools? If so is a dangerous fork of Bitcoin certain?
- jamiesonbecker 11y ago> Why is Bitcoin forking? "Why are we forking Bitcoin?"
- compcoin 11y agoBitcoin is Forking on it’s principals There is great debate and concern about Bitcoin trying to change its core software. Network tests have found the credit card processor can process many more transaction per second than Bitcoin can. Some influential leaders want to make changes that will make the protocol more competitive with VISA/MASTERCARD. They want to change increase amount of transaction processed in each block (the block in blockchain technology). The important issue is not about changing Blockchain size it is about changing the hard coded rules that are the foundations for trust in Blockchain based systems. What is there to stop future forks that change other rules that users relied upon in their choice to participate in this financial system. Lets say some economic interests in the future lobby the influential core developers and miners to change the amount of coins mined in the future to let say 100 million. If the users rely on the software to enforce it rules any important changes to the rules that are significant can effect the end users in unpredictable ways. The users of Bitcoin have no say. Once again a small group is making choices and if they are wrong they can destroy the entire system. A system that relies on influential few promoting there own economic interest is no better than a public company issuing out more shares when they see the need or the government printing more currency. Those who want to take Bitcoin into direct competition with VISA/MasterCard should simply create a new coin designed to do this. There is so much more to the potential of the protocol than just a cheaper way to spend money. The principal of hard coded rules they can not be changed and are enforced by the software is one of the true revolutionary idea’s of Bitcoin. There is more at stake than creating competition for banks. Its about staying true to a financial system rules that users chose to participate in.
- harryh 11y agoBitcoin originally did not have this 1MB limit. It was only added when there were concerns about spam transactions or blocks that could clog the network. Why do you think it was OK to make a change to add a limit but not make a change on the size of the limit?
- corv 11y agoAs can be seen on http://xtnodes.com/ http://xtnodes.com/ there is significant growth in full nodes running code for larger blocks.
- ryanmarsh 11y agoWith so much money at stake (and potentially large concentrations of it) why isn't there much of a governance model for Bitcoin? I see many articles touting the so called democratic governance model of Bitcoin and if that is indeed the model then what other "popular delusions and madness of crowds" will my money be subject to in the future?