3 ms·
You're focused on science learning what science previously got wrong, but I think there is a deeper conflict at work when it comes to animal capabilities. Befo
by snowwrestler 11y ago
You're focused on science learning what science previously got wrong, but I think there is a deeper conflict at work when it comes to animal capabilities.
Before science started correcting itself, it was correcting perceptions based on religion and culture. For example, the germ theory of disease ran headlong into the older idea (not based on science) that doctors couldn't have dirty hands because they were gentlemen.
The belief that animals do not share capabilities with man arises from culture, specifically Western Christian culture. God made man in his own image and gave man dominion over the dumb beasts of the world. Man ate the fruit of the tree of knowledge, which set him apart from animals.
This still dominates theoretical thinking of animal behavior. If scientists went purely off of observations, most questions would have this answer: we don't know yet. Instead observations are climbing uphill against preconceived notions.
Studies of consciousness run into the same thing. The distinction between brain and mind goes back to the body/soul distinction from thousands of years of religion and culture. There is no evidence at all to suggest that minds exist apart from brains. Yet the question of "where consciousness comes from" is still asked seriously by people who think of themselves as serious scientists.
- pessimizer 11y agoReligion also affects the study of climate change. There are many evangelical Protestants who believe that is blasphemous to imply that anything that humans could do could change the weather in any way, because God created the weather and runs it as He sees fit.
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>evangelical Protestants who believe that is blasphemous to imply that anything that humans could do could change the weather in any way // As someone who you might fit in to the category "evangelical Protestant" I find it hard to believe there are "many" relative to the whole set. Any sources? Cloud seeding is pretty widely known; most people seem to be convinced that there is a human element to current climate change. The concept of "stewardship of creation" is pretty widespread amongst evangelical Christians, that God handed over the world in to our care and that we've largely screwed it up. One of the largest Protestant communities, the Church of England, for example have altered their investment policy to avoid companies who are involved in activities that they see as contributing to unwanted climate change. (eg https://www.churchofengland.org/media-centre/news/2015/07/urgent-action-needed-on-climate-change-urges-synod.aspx https://www.churchofengland.org/media-centre/news/2015/07/ur...) Often I hear that it's "loony USA evangelicals" but at least the USA National Association of Evangelicals [which seems to be a large and influential body] accepts some climate change has human origins and that we should act to reduce our negative impact whilst simultaneously acting to aid the poor who are disproportionally affected by current changes in climate (eg http://nae.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Loving-the-Least-of-These.pdf http://nae.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Loving-the-Least-o...).