4 ms·
The problem with this is mostly spotting people doing it, and then taking action against them. When you have N cops, versus a thousand plus times as many driver
by adventured 11y ago
The problem with this is mostly spotting people doing it, and then taking action against them. When you have N cops, versus a thousand plus times as many drivers, spotting and pulling over the people doing it becomes an extremely laborious process.
There are three options that can be used alone or together.
1) Technology solution. Put digital eyes around the area of the steering wheel or otherwise pointing at the driver. Report drivers that frequently use a phone while driving. We can trivially build a phone identifier for a car today, given the drastic improvements in recognition technology. We could also easily judge drivers by their poor attentiveness to the road. This approach will freak people out in regards to being nanny state invasive.
2) Community shaming, education programs. This was half the battle with getting people to use seat belts regularly.
3) Traditional police enforcement. Cops start pulling people over for it more frequently, and hitting them with on the spot $100, $200, $500 fines. Perhaps it increases with each offense within a certain amount of time. The problem here is, the radical majority of people will simply slip through the enforcement cracks and not be caught. It would also be open to easy abuse, cops stuffing the budget with lots of fines. People see seat belts as a life saving device for the most part, so voluntary compliance mostly worked, but I'd wager most people do not see their phone habits as potentially life threatening. That requires greater disincentives to reach the same compliance, or a vastly larger shaming & education project.
- mentat 11y agoThe current law enforcement milieu is simply revenue generation for the state and a lottery ticket for an addition road tax on violators. It just doesn't work. Until we decide what laws we really want and that we are ok with 90% enforcement of those laws, it will be a dangerous joke. A lot of the current scheme of law enforcement is based on most people being law abiding citizens. When you look at the road now, that's clearly not the case.
- politician 11y agoOn the spot fines seem like a great way to encourage graft and corruption among the police. Let's leave Judge Dredd-style policing in the comic books.