6 ms·
Someone thought that apes couldn't control their breathing well enough to vocalize? Really? All mammals have pretty advanced control over their airways, other
by sandworm101 11y ago
Someone thought that apes couldn't control their breathing well enough to vocalize? Really? All mammals have pretty advanced control over their airways, otherwise we would be constantly inhaling nasty things. Carnivores need control to sniff (see wolves) and herbivores need to hold their breath to be quiet enough to hear the wolves (see deer).
I'm about ready to say that all animal and human science from the 30s through the 50s should be tossed. From all birds mating for life, belly-dragging dinos, to apes that cannot hold their breath ... were they just making stuff up?
- rndn 11y agoHolding breath and avoiding inhaling dust and flies possibly doesn't require as fine motor control as necessary for speech. In that light, the first paragraph of your comment can't refute the hypothesis without referencing some empirical results, so the second paragraph is absurdly confident.
- sandworm101 11y agoI would argue that keeping things out of our airways is a little more advanced than just holding one's breath. Coughing up junk or dealing with water/swimming are common to mammals. Even swallowing requires coordination of the various parts beyond simply not breathing. I read a few years ago about a machine to allow paralyzed/comatose people to cough properly as this hugely reduces throat infections.
- jschwartzi 11y agoYeah, people tend to underestimate how complex the respiratory tract is. Cough assist is basically just a machine that holds an insufflation pressure and an exsufflation pressure for specific times to emulate a cough. Independently of the servo programming they're less complicated than speech.
- joeyo 11y agoDead on. There is very likely some very specialized neural motor control circuitry that humans use for speech that is missing from other primates. If you consider, for example, dexterous finger movements, there is a strong correlation between the number of direct corticospinal [1] projections and degree of finger dexterity that the species exhibits. Rodents and many other mammals have no projections at all. Monkeys have some; humans have many [2, see fig 1]. So which primates have corticospinal projections for their vocal cords? Okay, that's actually a trick question because the vocal cords are innervated via cranial nerves emanating from the medulla [3], rather than via spinal cord. However, in humans, there are direct monosynaptic projections from cortex to these medullary motor neurons. These projections do not exist in macaques (and presumably not in other monkeys) or in chimpanzees [4, see fig 2]. I'm not sure if it's known whether gorillas or orangutans have them. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyramidal_tracts#Corticospinal_tract 2. http://www.nature.com/nm/journal/v13/n5/full/nm1595.html 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nucleus_ambiguus 4. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095943881400107X
- trhway 11y ago>All mammals have pretty advanced control over their airways once, to decide the issue for myself, i started Audacity and loaded in various animal recordings as well as human. The animal phrases (at least in the recordings what i had) were generally shorter, yet they pretty much consisted of the same modulations. The animals do have the tools of speech and they do have speech: http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/running-ponies/catch-the-wave-decoding-the-prairie-doge28099s-contagious-jump-yips/ http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/running-ponies/catch-the... "He discovered that this species' communication system is so advanced, not only do they have different warning calls depending on the type of predator - coyote, domestic dog, human, hawk - they also construct sentences describing what a particular predator looks like. So, "a medium, rectangle-shaped dog with yellow fur (we call them German shepherds) is approaching”, or “Here comes a tall human being wearing a green t-shirt who is also fat.” (I’m teasing, prairie dogs, I’m sure your sentences sound much more elegant.) By showing captive prairie dogs a number of simple silhouetted shapes such as triangles, circles and squares, Slobodchikoff also determined that they can come up with new calls to communicate to each other about things they’ve never seen before."
- agumonkey 11y agoI feel the same about all the intelligence-language ideas which I find pretentious most of the time. 'Look at how incredible we are'. Most of the time these kind of ideas are plain ignorance turned into flattery. Computers history taught me that high resolution is not needed to achieve complex forms of communications (for instance ascii had 3 level deep structure separator, pretty much ignored). I feel like an 4K version of a fish, sure I may have finer and more complex communication scheme, but that doesn't mean they don't communicate the same idea between each others through different and simpler means. About voice control, most people don't even understand what they do with it. Ask someone to modulate vowels to match a foreign accent. Or sing. The variations between airflow, tone, timbre, etc... Then you start to understand a bit more about what your vocal apparatus can do.
- WalterBright 11y ago> I feel the same about all the intelligence-language ideas which I find pretentious most of the time. When a dog is leashed to a tree, and runs around it until there's no more slack, I have yet to see one that figures out it needs to run around the other way.
- ergothus 11y agoWhen it comes to animal intelligence discussions, I find any form of domesticated animal to be a terrible model: They've been bred (and often inbred) for traits that are NOT indicative of intelligence. That said, your central (and valid) point actually agrees with the above poster: To use criteria to determine "intelligence" is good science; to declare animals can't have intelligence or anything related to intelligence because they aren't humans is empty.
- agumonkey 11y agoThen you have crows www.youtube.com/watch?v=bXQAgzfwuNQ Nature is weird.
- tfb 11y agoMy dog can do this. Sadly he was tied to a tree for years before I got him, which is probably how he figured it out. I'll walk him and on extremely rare occasions he will accidentally wrap around a pole or something, and when he realizes he doesn't have any slack, he immediately unwraps himself. I also say "on extremely rare occasions" because somehow he figured out that if there's a tree/pole ahead, he should stay between myself and the tree/pole to avoid ever wrapping around it to begin with. The only times he will go on the wrong side is if he's preoccupied with a smell or something, and even then, he never actually fully wraps around it, as he almost always realizes he should immediately go the other way. He was never formally trained to do this. :)
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoHow about a dog that barks on command?
- grecy 11y agoScience from the 30s through the 50s should be tossed... ... were they just making stuff up? I've come to realize that science is always wrong, when viewed with a long enough lens. It does the best it can at the time - i.e. let's spray everyone with DDT, or let's put lead into paint and gasoline, or let's introduce species x to control species y then x becomes a problem, etc. Then years later science figures out those were terrible ideas, but shockingly everyone just says "NOW we know better, forget about before, trust us THIS time". Does anyone else not realize it's exactly the same thing, and ~50 years from now science will know that lots of what we're doing today is a really bad thing to be doing? In 2050 someone will say "Science from the 1990's - 2020s should be tossed, they were just making stuff up"
- brazzledazzle 11y agoI agree 100%. I think lots of people realize it, but what can you do? Like you said, it's the best we can do now. In 50 years they'll probably think we were complete barbarians for how we medicate psychological disorders but right now the patients need to live the best lives they can live and brute force is all that we have to work with.
- iamcurious 11y agoWhat alternative do we have?
- grecy 11y agoI think we should start making decisions based around the understanding that we probably don't understand the full implications of what we're doing. i.e. We don't really know for certain what will happen if we seed clouds with nitrogen to alter the weather - so let's not (in reality we are doing this) and We don't know for sure if these hormones we're injecting into livestock have down-the-line health consequences for the people eating them, so we shouldn't do that. We should stop messing with stuff we really don't understand, and actually don't even need to be messing with - leave well enough alone.
- 11y ago
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt's at least an interesting idea. Here's why; apes are ridiculously stronger than humans. A lot of that has to do with muscle attachment. Ape muscles are attached further from the joint, increasing leverage. Human muscles are attached closer to the joint. That makes us weaker- but it also gives us much better dexterity than apes of similar size. Same system, different trade-offs. So there's precedent, after a fashion.