11 ms·
Apes may be closer to speaking than many scientists think
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- juliann 11y agoWow, really impressed when watching those videos, wasn't expecting such human looking movements and gestures when blowing his nose.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoJust assuming for a moment that this capability increases enough for an ape to say something that humans would find "profound", I wonder if humans would give more weight to what an Ape had to say than a fellow human.
- omouse 11y ago"He's a gorilla, of course he knows what he's doing! Just sell off all our assets, I'm sure nothing will go wrong!"
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoYou joke but people took this seriously: http://www.ibtimes.com/octopus-made-better-world-cup-predictions-goldman-sachs-photos-1613882 http://www.ibtimes.com/octopus-made-better-world-cup-predict...
- vectorpush 11y agoThe Daniel Quinn novel Ishmael comes to mind.
- smtddr 11y agoWe already have problems taking each other seriously just based on gender, race and other such things. The movie, the planet of the apes, is pretty much what I think would happen if apes started talking to us.
- sandworm101 11y agoSomeone thought that apes couldn't control their breathing well enough to vocalize? Really? All mammals have pretty advanced control over their airways, otherwise we would be constantly inhaling nasty things. Carnivores need control to sniff (see wolves) and herbivores need to hold their breath to be quiet enough to hear the wolves (see deer). I'm about ready to say that all animal and human science from the 30s through the 50s should be tossed. From all birds mating for life, belly-dragging dinos, to apes that cannot hold their breath ... were they just making stuff up?
- rndn 11y agoHolding breath and avoiding inhaling dust and flies possibly doesn't require as fine motor control as necessary for speech. In that light, the first paragraph of your comment can't refute the hypothesis without referencing some empirical results, so the second paragraph is absurdly confident.
- sandworm101 11y agoI would argue that keeping things out of our airways is a little more advanced than just holding one's breath. Coughing up junk or dealing with water/swimming are common to mammals. Even swallowing requires coordination of the various parts beyond simply not breathing. I read a few years ago about a machine to allow paralyzed/comatose people to cough properly as this hugely reduces throat infections.
- jschwartzi 11y agoYeah, people tend to underestimate how complex the respiratory tract is. Cough assist is basically just a machine that holds an insufflation pressure and an exsufflation pressure for specific times to emulate a cough. Independently of the servo programming they're less complicated than speech.
- joeyo 11y agoDead on. There is very likely some very specialized neural motor control circuitry that humans use for speech that is missing from other primates. If you consider, for example, dexterous finger movements, there is a strong correlation between the number of direct corticospinal [1] projections and degree of finger dexterity that the species exhibits. Rodents and many other mammals have no projections at all. Monkeys have some; humans have many [2, see fig 1]. So which primates have corticospinal projections for their vocal cords? Okay, that's actually a trick question because the vocal cords are innervated via cranial nerves emanating from the medulla [3], rather than via spinal cord. However, in humans, there are direct monosynaptic projections from cortex to these medullary motor neurons. These projections do not exist in macaques (and presumably not in other monkeys) or in chimpanzees [4, see fig 2]. I'm not sure if it's known whether gorillas or orangutans have them. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyramidal_tracts#Corticospinal_tract 2. http://www.nature.com/nm/journal/v13/n5/full/nm1595.html 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nucleus_ambiguus 4. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095943881400107X
- rickdale 11y agoThere was a monkey experiment called Project Nim with a documentary about. The footage in that movie is amazing. They used to sit in smoke circles and pass the joint to the chimpanzee. Ultimately the story turned sad when the funding for the research was pulled and I know this is about apes, but I am just saying animals are capable of much more than we think. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1814836/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1814836/
- ggreer 11y agoI found that movie fascinating, but not for the science value (of which there was none). Above all else, two things amazed me: 1. That people thought chimps could use complex language. If they have the capability, why don't they use it in the wild? It'd be a huge advantage. 2. That no human was killed by Nim. Everyone managed to emerge alive (though not unscathed). Gwern's review of Project Nim echoes my sentiments: http://www.gwern.net/newsletter/2015/03#filmtv http://www.gwern.net/newsletter/2015/03#filmtv
- Someone 11y agoThey may not have used it because being taught something is easier than inventing it. A famous example: the knowledge of opening milk bottles wasn't independently discovered by all blue tits, but it spread in the population (http://www.britishbirdlovers.co.uk/articles/blue-tits-and-milk-bottle-tops http://www.britishbirdlovers.co.uk/articles/blue-tits-and-mi..., http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/037663579400051H http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/03766357940...), presumably because one smart bird invented it, and others copied him. Also, even if a single smart chimp discovered complex language on its own, what good would it do? (S)he would also have to know another smarter-than-average chimp who was smart enough to pick it up, and then, the knowledge would have to spread to a larger group fairly soon in order to survive. Chimps could be relatively close to the brink of learning complex language, needing only a relatively small push to get over it.
- mef 11y agoYour point actually reinforces ggreer's -- if a species is capable of an advantageous behaviour like complex language, eventually one of the species will figure out how to use it to gain an advantage, like the birds you refer to. The idea that apes have this ability but none ever figured out how to use it in order to gain an advantage is akin to the idea that mice could fly to escape predators but just never got the "small push" to figure it out.
- mortenjorck 11y ago"She doesn't produce a pretty, periodic sound when she performs these behaviors, like we do when we speak," Perlman says. "But she can control her larynx enough to produce a controlled grunting sound." If the innumerable worlds within the billions of galaxies in our universe are indeed sprinkled with life, I can't help but feel my hypothesis reinforced that we must be within the top 0.01% of evolutionarily-developed planets. Gorillas themselves would have to be in the top 1%, maybe fish in the top 10%. Of course, this doesn't discount the vaguely terrifying idea of a top 0.001%.
- jaibot 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter
- bweitzman 11y agoHow are you coming up with these numbers? Humans, apes, and fish are all equally evolutionarily developed considering that our species have been evolving for the same amount of time (assuming we have a common ancestor).
- mc808 11y agoI don't think the concept of "more" and "less" evolved is really valid in general. Drop a human into the middle of the ocean and suddenly it will seem "less evolved" than nearly every living thing for thousands of miles. We could go with a purely information theoretic notion of genetic complexity, but that's not ideal because genomes with a lot of random accumulated cruft would seem more complex than they really are. Maybe with the benefit of hindsight, we could say an organism was more evolved if its lineage remained relatively stable over long periods of time or across different environments. By that measure, it's still too soon to say whether humans are more evolved than cyanobacteria or the crocodile, but at least we have a chance.
- bweitzman 11y agoComplexity, evolved-ness, and adaptability are three different things. Evolved-ness refers to amount of time that something has been evolving. Adaptability refers to the ability of an organism or a species to survive in a new environment. Complexity, like you said, more or less corresponds to genome size. Rice is actually genetically more complex than humans are, so assuming humans and rice have a common ancestor, we are equally evolved but not equally complex. It is debatable whether or not rice is more adaptable than humans.
- jonnybgood 11y agoThis Slate article is worth a read, concerning the science involving Koko. "Critics also allege that the abilities of apes like Koko and Kanzi are overstated by their loving caregivers. Readers with pets may recognize this temptation; we can’t help but attribute intelligence to creatures we know so well." http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/2014/08/koko_kanzi_and_ape_language_research_criticism_of_working_conditions_and.html http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/science/201...
- nerfhammer 11y agoRobert Sapolsky's lecture, mentioned in the article, wherein he discusses ape language projects, is a good watch: https://youtu.be/SIOQgY1tqrU?t=1h28m1s https://youtu.be/SIOQgY1tqrU?t=1h28m1s He completely dismisses Koko but considers Kanzi to be more credible.
- rancur 11y ago(off topic) I have to say I'm very thankful to have found HN. I grew up in a decent, moderately sized city (300k) going to a private religious school with children whose parents were similarly strongly interested in the intellectual development of their children. I had access to all the sports teams. I played soccer through Varsity, played with the golf team [but note I was not on the golf team, hehe], and basketball in middle school. I played piano for 8 years. I attended one of the top 5 schools of my field in the nation, and graduated into a small company with other graduates from my school, MIT, etc. From 'good places'. Because of this, education was always something I always took for granted. I always valued it, but always took it for granted. My education, however, took humans for granted. Your value to society was sometimes considered limited by what you could produce. Additionally, many of those I highschooled and undergraduated with held little reservation filtering people out of their life based on, I'll call it, 'being dumb'. This always bothered me. I believed in the intrinsic value of the human, so I always sought to correct for it. Because I always tried my hardest, it never occurred to me how people could willfully and knowingly not aspire themselves to something greater than what required minimal effort. Everyone I grew up with did, I did, and my parents did, so naturally I assumed everyone else did, too. As such, I was regularly perplexed at the value judgements certain colleagues would place on other members of humanity. So I left that company, and struck out on my own. I have since discovered what a rare breed my background nurtured, and now understand the wisdom in filtering those you spend time with. Instead of a prideful superiority [which I certainly observed], I exercise with a cautious respect for, and in protection of, talent and time. I exercise without placing value judgements on the people I come in contact with, but I do judge the values of the people I spend time with. In this way I safely continue to respect their humanity, and avoid pride. It's only since I moved and became aware of my need to protect that I became aware of how hard it is to find knowledge seekers. And so, when I come across someone from a different field but similar excellence, who carries with them persuasive content helpful for advancement, I am thankful. And so I am thankful to have found HackerNews, and specifically this lecture material that I can't wait to watch. It's very important to surround yourself with excellence. You'll become the ones you're around, and believe their idiocy, if you're not careful. Be careful.
- ohsnap 11y agoA lot of skepticism is in order with anything Koko. No skeptical scientists have been allowed to 'communicate' with Koko. Thus only believers, people who are willing to provide very generous interpretations of the ape's behavior are allowed to work with her.
- sandworm101 11y agoI think only a believer would get so physically close to such an animal. She isn't a person, nor a pet. I can understand her keepers not wanting unfamiliar people around if they might upset her. Or she, like humans, may not display the same behavior around strangers.
- ohsnap 11y agoThe Gorilla Foundation has no problem granting access to celebrities (e.g. Robin Williams) or the media. Critical behaviorists or linguists have had no such luck in access. In the videos I have seen the trainer acts like a tarot reader: Koko will make a bunch of signs/movements and then the trainer will interpret for you what it means. So long as you want to believe it all makes sense.
- csours 11y agoHave Great Apes ever been domesticated?
- nogridbag 11y agoInteresting... I was just browsing Koko's wikipedia page and assumed someone had vandalized the "Life" section [1]. "Koko enjoys seeing human nipples and will request her female caregivers to show them to her on occasion." But after some googling it appears to be true.. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla)#Life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla)#Life
- sergimansilla 11y agoI read this first as "Apples". I was very confused.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- freyr 11y agoSome apes have already learned to speak. We call them humans.
- jonah 11y agoThe embedded videos show some good mimicry but not much understanding. Handler: How about coughing? Ape: Sneezes. Handler: That was good! Handler: Koko, can you sneeze? Ape: Blows Nose. Handler: ... Not impressed. Just because something (ape breath control) looks like something else (speech prerequisites), doesn't mean theyre the same thing...
- known 11y agoAnimals talk/communicate to each other; Is this news?
- maehwasu 11y agorelated: http://www.theonion.com/article/scientists-teach-sign-language-to-gorilla-suit-wea-34329 http://www.theonion.com/article/scientists-teach-sign-langua...