4 ms·
The negotiation angle has long been missing from economic discussions. The classic line is that you get circa what your marginal productivity is, but that's und
by lordnacho 11y ago
The negotiation angle has long been missing from economic discussions. The classic line is that you get circa what your marginal productivity is, but that's under some rather stringent assumptions. Also it sidesteps how exactly you calculate marginal productivity. There's very little talk about the dynamics of wage settings, ie how do you actually reach a number?
From what I can see, as a guy who's been in a few businesses, the salary amount starts off with just a simple assumption: we'll pay roughly whatever everyone else is paying for a certain job. You then go and find a bunch of likely-sounding candidates and bring them in to interview. (OT: This is a complete mess, because you're not as good at this as you think, even taking into account lordnacho's law.) You will fall in love with one or two of these people, probably not more. You'll then throw out a lowball number on the game theoretical rationale that they'll either ask for more or be happy with it. If there are special circumstances like the guy being a recent grad, we can say a bunch of stuff like "you're learning a lot from us, you need us more than we need you" (yeah, it's a shitty thing to say) and count on other bosses thinking similarly. The candidate can then take it or leave it, or if they have another offer, use that to get a bit more. But it's really a silly dance around a fairly static anchor, silly because people can get pissed off over small amounts of money. I've worked with more than one guy who thought he was a great negotiator because he managed to talk some guy down by a few grand, even though a $700M hedge fund makes that amount in about three hours.
Now why would wages ever change, if this is roughly what happens? I never came across a situation where there wasn't a huge queue of people wanting whatever jobs we put up. In fact, there was no real rationale for setting any particular salary, other than "that's the market". My thinking is that salaries really only go up when companies find zero suitable people for a given job, or when they get a particularly large number of offerees coming back to them saying they took some other job.
And what would create a situation where there were very few candidates for a job?
1) Collective action. Apart from the London Tube, this seems to be out of fashion. It also seems to be hard to organise something like software devs, given they live in very different cost areas scattered around the world.
2) Growth. When things are booming, companies get desperate. They can see the demand, customers are telling them they want product, but they can't get the staff they need to build the product. But since they can see the demand, offering a bit more to grab those staff is a bit easier on the executive mind.
- jazzyk 11y agoSpot on. I would like to add that the name "labor market" is a misnomer. It is not a market. On the one hand you have rich capital providers who DO NOT HAVE to invest money - they can live off their capital without doing anything. On the other, you have labor providers, who HAVE to work to feed themselves. The solution is to reach the "fuck-you-money" savings level. Not that simple, but not impossible.