12 ms·
How Cheap Can Solar Get?
- 1971genocide 11y agoDoes anyone know methods for hackers to help and learn more about solar ? It it possible for the mathematically trained to easily immerse and innovate in the industry ? It it possible to manufacture solar cells "in your garage" so to speak ?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoGenerally you can't grow silicon crystals in your garage, although you can create the photovoltaic effect with amorphous materials (see CIGS solar cells). A good start is to apprentice with a solar installation company to get a feel for what is the "current" situation.
- chm 11y agoMy MSc is concerned with a model for simulating molecular photovoltaics. The work I do is a blend of physics, chemistry, maths and programming, in different proportions. I wouldn't say it was "easy to immerse", but complement your skills with physics/chemistry and you could be useful, yes. A Grätzel or dye sensitized solar cell can be easily created in your garage. Look them up on Youtube.
- selimthegrim 11y agoBetter models for molecular photovoltaics are sorely needed. Math skills are not unwanted. Source: I work in the field.
- Gravityloss 11y agoProduction-demand balancing / forecasting will be a huge business. It can include a lot of software.
- silverthorn 11y agoAs the article notes, module technology and module costs are no longer the most significant barrier to solar adoption---so if you're in software, the greatest opportunities to have significant impact are probably in tearing down the numerous _other_ barriers to widespread adoption. To use the situation I'm most familiar with: there are hundreds of millions of people in emerging economies who live off-grid and spend tens of billions of dollars annually on expensive fuel-based energy. They'll switch to solar tomorrow if we [1] can solve the problem of upfront financing [2]. It's the same problem that SolarCity, Sunrun, et al. are tackling in the US. This problem is the kind that gets solved by, among other things, developing the same kind of enterprise-targeted mobile/web/backend/data systems familiar to any developer at a modern SaaS company (but targeting a different, unusually interesting and important market, with some unique challenges). [1] https://careers.stackoverflow.com/company/angaza/ https://careers.stackoverflow.com/company/angaza/ [2] http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/selling-energy-service-meeting-needs-of-poor http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/selling-ener...
- prostoalex 11y agoThere's a solar energy course on edX, where they walk you through designing a photovoltaic system https://www.edx.org/course/solar-energy-delftx-et3034x https://www.edx.org/course/solar-energy-delftx-et3034x Although most of the current innovation seems to be focused on the panel efficiency, and that area requires some understanding of Materials Science http://www.rdmag.com/news/2014/01/understanding-perovskite-based-solar-cells http://www.rdmag.com/news/2014/01/understanding-perovskite-b...
- jl6 11y agoDoes this make solar a great industry to invest in because of the growth potential, or a terrible industry to invest in because the prices are racing to the bottom?
- RamezNaam 11y agoHi. I'm the author of the original post. The amount of solar installed in the world is going to scale by more than 10x in the coming decades. There will be more than a trillion spent. If you pick the winners, investment will have huge return. Most solar companies, however, will be casualties in the fierce competition to come. The other area to look at is energy storage. More renewables will increase the demand for energy storage. And it's early days in that field. Again: Huge returns for the winners. But most companies will be shaken out of the field.
- draugadrotten 11y agoDo you have any suggestions about good solar startups with good patents/tech/people?
- eigenvalue 11y agoThe race to the bottom is more applicable to the panel manufacturers. The lowest cost producers are mostly Chinese companies, and the financial performance for these companies (ReneSola, Yingli Green Energy, Trina Solar, etc.) has been pretty terrible so far. Probably the best way to invest in solar through the stock market is to invest in a developer of solar projects. The best of these in my opinion in terms of scale and expertise is SunEdison (ticker: SUNE), and incidentally, the stock has been in free fall for various reasons over the past couple weeks, so this is probably a reasonable entry point.
- pjc50 11y agoIt's a commodity manufacturing industry. It's going to have big turnover and thin margins. There's scope for innovation-driven cost reduction, but not for SV-style "unicorns".
- 11y ago
- RamezNaam 11y agoHi. I'm the author of this blog post. Happy to answer questions people have, as time allows, on Wednesday. Upcoming posts will look at the future of wind power, the future of energy storage, and what the missing pieces are. If you don't want to wait, you can read my thoughts on energy storage here: http://rameznaam.com/2015/04/14/energy-storage-about-to-get-big-and-cheap/ http://rameznaam.com/2015/04/14/energy-storage-about-to-get-...
- newman314 11y agoSo given the Fed 30% solar subsidy is set to expire at the end of 2016, have you modeled (or know of a model) that shows when the price of solar will crossover the loss of subsidy? I.e. I'm trying to figure out if going solar now is better (in California) or just waiting a few more years. I'm in no particular hurry since my electric bill vs. sq/ft is already pretty good.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- furyg3 11y agoIt appears that all his calculations in the article are done without subsidies factored in.
- RamezNaam 11y agoUBS has done some modeling on this for their clients. They believe utility-based solar will take a hit for a 2-3 years and then rebound. The Fed ITC will drop from 30% to 10%. Making up that 20% cost change will take a little over one doubling of solar scale. Rooftop solar will probably also take 2-3 years to make up for the cost lost to the subsidy reduction. It may even be 4. So after 2016, I'd expect rooftop prices to rise before slowly dropping, and getting back to 2016 levels around 2019 or 2020.
- Jedd 11y agoYour post focuses on PVC's - what's the impact of / where does thermal solar fit in with these projections?
- fpgaminer 11y agoIf I could install solar today I would, regardless of cost (apartment living prevents it). That may sound crazy, but I theorize that when you consider externalities the cost of grid electricity already far exceeds the cost of solar. It's going to cost humanity a whole lot of money to both survive and fix the damage we're dealing to the environment today. I'd rather pay more now for solar, than pay through the nose later for the environmental equivalent of a triple bypass surgery. I doubt others see it that way, so I guess I'll pay the cleanup cost later like everyone else regardless. Such is the human condition.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- leni536 11y ago> I'd rather pay more now for solar, than pay through the nose later for the environmental equivalent of a triple bypass surgery. That's really generous, however I think it would be the government's duty to compensate for these externalities so you don't have to pay more for solar (or not much more) than for the grid. Otherwise the environment will just stay a huge "tragedy of the commons".
- mtgx 11y agoThe very least the governments can do is eliminate all subsidies to coal, oil and natural gas. They've had them for decades. I don't think it's healthy for a society to prop up an industry that long with subsidies, especially when it's one of the most profitable.
- Gravityloss 11y agoAustralia had a carbon tax. Unfortunately it has been reverted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_pricing_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_pricing_in_Australia
- 7952 11y agoA politician can make any kind of spending seem bad by just calling it a subsidy regardless of the social benefit. But when it benefits people they like it can just be quietly ignored. The real test should be if it ensures that people pay a "fair price" for a product. Paying a little more for clean energy is perfectly reasonable.
- leni536 11y agoWhat is the environmental impact of making solar cells?
- chm 11y agoSorry for the non-answer: The term "solar cell" refers to a wide variety of technologies[1]. Anything from common semiconductors, rare-earths or even fruit juice can be used to make solar cells. The impact will be highly dependent on the type of cell in question. [1]:http://www.nrel.gov/ncpv/images/efficiency_chart.jpg http://www.nrel.gov/ncpv/images/efficiency_chart.jpg The above graph isn't all-encompassing.
- leni536 11y agoFair enough. I think the most satisfying answer would be the released chemicals and other environmental effects normalized to kWh for various cell types, taking the designed lifetime and recycling into account maybe with some emphasis on cell types that are currently sold for households, or planned to be sold in the not too far future. I'm interested in these questions: - What cell types are currently bought, will be bought in large quantities? - How it affects / will affect the environment?
- pjc50 11y agoThe first of these links gives an overview of the risks, pointing out that it depends very much on the particular factory's safety record. I don't think normalising is even possible across so many different possibilities. All the risky chemicals can be recycled and non-CO2 emissions neutralised, but this is not always done. It also says the majority type sold is polycrystalline, so CdTe are rare. (Both cadmium and tellurium are quite nasty, but also bound in by the manufacturing process and not prone to leaking) http://spectrum.ieee.org/green-tech/solar/solar-energy-isnt-always-as-green-as-you-think http://spectrum.ieee.org/green-tech/solar/solar-energy-isnt-... The second addresses the carbon cost specifically. http://info.cat.org.uk/questions/pv/what-energy-and-carbon-payback-time-pv-panels-uk http://info.cat.org.uk/questions/pv/what-energy-and-carbon-p...
- 11y ago
- erikb 11y agoI'm not happy with the diagrams. Example: the first one compares time to costs. That's really what we want. But why not add some lines for traditional ways to make electricity? That's what we want to compare to, or don't we?
- justaaron 11y agoi live off grid inside of a 500w/h peak footprint. i paid around $1000 for proper German (Schutten) panels, a charge controller suitable for them, 2 110ah "solar batteries" (lead acid usual cheapo old school stuff), and a Xantrex inverter. After nearly 1 year running a fridge, lights, computer, router, & studio monitors, I'm ready to add more battery capacity before the winter (cloudy days) and a small wind turbine. grid-tie systems are another story and a bigger investment. (need a proper electrician to wire it etc...) feeding ignorant "city ways" in terms of people's silly habits fed by years of cluelessness (no a hairdryer will never ever be possible, as that's 2kw right there...) that's where the biggest expenses come in... if you don't try to keep up with the usual clueless electrical consumption, a well organized person can begin cutting their footprint down... for example my alleged 85w macbook pro power supply consumes less than 20w typically... my inverter says so...
- aembleton 11y agoThat 85W rating on your Macbook Pro power supply is it's peak power output. Typically it will be much less.
- jacquesm 11y agoIf you're up for it I still have my 2500 W windmill here and can't use it so you can have it, the base is damaged (slip rings, tower shaft and tower mount) and you'll need to put up a pretty solid tower. It's a 2.5 meter diameter machine. See: http://jacquesmattheij.com/how-to-build-a-windmill http://jacquesmattheij.com/how-to-build-a-windmill It weighs about 100 Kg and it's currently in storage near the town of Beverwijk in NL. It cost a small fortune to make it and I'd rather see it being used than slowly rust away in storage.
- snsr 11y agoWhat a fantastic project - thanks for documenting and sharing!
- watchdogtimer 11y agoDo you always use your MBP connected to a power outlet? If so, try running it until its battery is drained about 50%, then plug it into your inverter and see how much power it draws. My guess is it will draw about 50-60 W. I've been using a pedal-powered generator to power my computer, phone, tablet, and LED lights for the last 5 years and have tested several laptops and other devices using it. I've found that most laptops draw from 12 W (11" Chromebook) to 25 W (older 15" Dell) when their battery is charged, but 40-60 W when charging. The power supplies of most devices seem to have about a 50% safety factor, so a device that has a normal max power consumption of 50 W will use a 75 W power supply.
- arkem 11y agoOff topic but Ramez's novels are excellent, have a look at Nexus!
- europestup 11y agoWe all know that PV panels have a limited lifetime, and that building them has environmental cost. But I was wondering about recycling: does anybody know how much energy can be saved by creating new panels using materials from old ones?
- andyjohnson0 11y agoNot really answering your question, but as far as I know panel lifetime is largely determined by cumulative damage from the environment. Scratches from trees, etc. reduce effectiveness, as does rain leaking into the panel through gaps created by the daily thermal cycle. There may be a lot of scope for extending their lifetime by improving packing, which would defer the environmental impact of recycling. There is some info on these factors in [1]. Also, panels may be declared end-of-life because they are not as effective as newer ones, even though they are still generating to original specification. [1] http://energyinformative.org/lifespan-solar-panels/ http://energyinformative.org/lifespan-solar-panels/
- nell 11y agoIf solar is really that viable of an option, India should be investing a lot in this research. Power is a huge problem there. 24 hours of power supply is a luxury even in top cities. Small industries in rural parts operate around availability of power. There are a lot of wins here. And guess what, there is a lot of sunlight in major parts of the country throughout the year.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoThere's a lot going on (note that wind is currently cheaper) http://cleantechnica.com/tag/india/ http://cleantechnica.com/tag/india/
- hwstar 11y agoI have a 1kW solar panel battery storage system which I use to power my computers and servers. I installed it a couple of years ago to help mitigate the $0.37 kWh top tier rate that SDG&E charges. In California, a minimum charge was introduced and will be $10.00 starting in 2016. I suspect that this charge will be jacked up in increments till it is a significant fraction of the monthly bill. If this does indeed play out, then the only option will be solar with localized energy storage, and disconnect completely from the grid. California also will be flattening the rate curve at the Utility companies request to combat solar installations in the next 1-2 years. Users in the first tier will be paying more, the other tiers will be combined into one and be at a lower rate than the current top tier. In 2019 there is a plan to move everyone to time of use pricing. Once time of use is mandated, it may be too expensive to remain connected to the grid.
- RealityVoid 11y agoWhat you're saying does not make sense from the utilities point of view. Why, if they have superior competition, would they make themselves more uncompetitive? Besides, centralized energy systems have certain advantages that household operations do not have. Maybe even better ones will arrive once solar becomes more accessible. SO it makes sense that they will stay at least as competitive as off-grid systems.
- tired_man 11y agoCan't keep customers? Then charge the ones you do have even more to make up for that shortfall. Businesses trying to keep their outdated business models alive do that sort of thing all the time. Just look at the music and movie industry's continued flailing as they try to keep CDs/DVDs profitable while their customer base wants files that they can play on _any_ device they own, not a physical copy or some DRM-laden crap that forces them to use it on one system.
- tired_man 11y agoThat's San Diego Graft and Extortion you're talking about, right? This movement is going to put the skids under the home solar company's pitch that you'll be able to feed electricity back and sell it to the power companies.
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI installed solar a few years ago. I didn't do it for economic reasons, rather because I wanted to. There is now push back by the dominant power company in my area against solar. When I got solar they gave me a small grant. Solar is the future I think. Too much potential danger from nuclear and coal polutes too much.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoPower-company solar may matter more than rooftops, in the end. They have the economies of scale, choice of location and orientation, grid connection expertise.