6 ms·
How is ad blocking an ethical issue? I get to control my computer, at least until some legislation passes that says I don't. Even if I don't control my compute
by bediger4000 11y ago
How is ad blocking an ethical issue? I get to control my computer, at least until some legislation passes that says I don't.
Even if I don't control my computer entirely, how about my DNS? I have a lot of the more intrusive domains (tynt, doubleclick, etc) set up as 127.0.0.1 in my dnsmasq config.
The "whose computer is it anyway" question seems key here. In order to make advertising possible, we have to take control away from owners. That seems like a generally bad outcome.
- ghshephard 11y agoThe ethical issue is with regards to people reading all the content supported by advertising, but then blanking out all the ads. Marco's taking the position that, given the risk, and the general intrusiveness and privacy violations associated with advertising, that it's entirely ethical to do so.
- WorldWideWayne 11y agoDon't you think the bigger ethical issue here is how content providers keep using ad networks that commonly serve as a delivery mechanism for malware? Reading someone's content without looking at their ads seems like a relatively minor infraction in comparison.
- ghshephard 11y agoI agree with Marco - I think the pendulum regarding security and privacy has swung too far, and it's entirely ethical to block such code from running on your system. I think a form of ads that are entirely reasonable (though hard to scale), are the ones that Gruber sticks himself into his DF feed. and, ironically, they are extraordinarily effective - I can probably name, by heart, about 20 of his sponsors. And I've visited, and purchased products from many of them.
- minimaxir 11y ago> How is ad blocking an ethical issue? Many people rely on ads for a livelihood without charging for content; ad-blocking would deprive of their livelihood. This was a contentious issue for niche video content creators (e.g. the nostalgic review craze that happened a few years ago) Most of these content creators have switched to Patreon/Kickstarter.
- reasonishy 11y agoOK, so the equivalent would be this: I buy magazines from the wholesaler. I rip out all the adverts. I then sell them to the public. I'm acting as a lovely "ad-blocker" for magazines. Is what I'm doing legal or ethical? Another argument would be is it ethical to block people who have adblock installed. In such an arms race, who will win?
- markbnj 11y agoI don't think that analogy holds up, since the viewer of a web page is not reselling the content (which would be the unethical part). It would be more accurate to ask whether removing the ad pages in magazines you keep for your own use was ethical. The obvious answer would be: of course.
- Retra 11y agoIt's even ok to hire someone to rip the ads out for you beforehand.
- nightmiles 11y ago> I buy magazines from the wholesaler. I rip out all the adverts. I then sell them to the public. Why wouldn't this be legal or ethical? What you choose to do with the mass of paper you just purchased is totally fine.
- reasonishy 11y agoAt the very least the magazine producer may get angry, and make it hard for you to buy the magazines.
- nightmiles 11y agoAnd there's nothing wrong with either of those things happening, either.
- jgrowl 11y agoAs someone who uses ad-blockers, I am totally fine with sites blocking me for it. I will disable adblock for that site if I really value the content. Otherwise it makes it really easy for me to decide to never go back to a site again.
- stdbrouw 11y agoDo you really believe that the only reason "it's my car and I can run over whoever I like" is ethically wrong is because there's a law that says you can't run over people?
- Spivak 11y agoNo, but it's my car so I can take off all the manufacturer and dealer badges.
- netrus 11y agoEven if you got the car for free, because the manufacturer wants people to see you driving it? Sounds unethical to me.
- bediger4000 11y agoThat's quite a bit different - there's probably a contractual (legal) obligation there. I use my bandwidth to retrieve the web page, and my CPU/GPU time to render it. Arguably, my computer is doing some of the work for the "content creator" in any case. If we're going the Car Analogy Route, then I think the situation is more like you've bought some blueprints and chunks of metal. You machined the chunks of metal into parts, and then assembled a car. Does Ford or VW or GM get to demand that you put their badges/plates/etc on it? This is to point out that physical analogies are slippery at best.
- h3st 11y agoThe assembly / bandwidth / cpu / etc argument really shines for limited platforms. E.g. if you're on metered internet, loading ads costs you money. If you're on a small device, playing ads costs you power, meaning you have to find a charger sooner. Computer ads aren't free for the people subjected to them, since we're the ones that have to do the work of displaying them. Compare that to paper / magazine ads add a few grams of weight and a bit of volume, but rarely in noticeable amounts, and billboard ads that don't cost the recipient any resources by being there (except maybe having to step around them).
- eli 11y agoHow is downloading cracked software or stolen movies an ethical issue?
- drdaeman 11y agoPrimarily, it's a legal issue. Although I genuinely wonder what came first - the discussion of ethics of "stealing" books or discussion of ethics of passed copyright laws.
- eli 11y agoSo blocking ads is ethical because it's legal? That doesn't sound right.
- drdaeman 11y agoAs for ads - I suppose if there is an ongoing ethics discussion already (and I believe there is), then it's ethical issue. Not sure, though. It's comparison that's didn't sound right to me. I'm just not sure it's well-comparable, because I suppose the major ethical debate about copyright infringement came from the existence of copyright laws. Which is not the case for ad-blocking.
- danielweber 11y ago"It can't be unethical because it's not illegal" is question-begging.
- bediger4000 11y agoBut we see the "You have to do this (possibly) unethical thing because it's the law" (capital punishment, imprisonment for victimless crimes, etc) all the time. Why not the opposite of "it's ethical because it's the law"?
- philh 11y agoYou get to control your computer, but there are some things which it's unethical to control your computer to do. It would be unethical to prevent people from blocking ads, but that doesn't mean it's ethical for people to block ads. (I'm not saying it's not ethical for people to block ads, just that I don't think your argument works.)
- ksk 11y agoThat is not a good argument to make. The corollary is that the telecom companies "own" their infrastructure. They can modify any packets sent from your computer to theirs, insert tracking, or peek at it or whatever. After all, YOU sent the packet to them.
- codezero 11y agoThey actually do this. Adding unique identifiers to headers. The U.S. Government also use the fact that telco owns the lines to justify mass surveillance since you are communicating on lines you don't own.
- marcosdumay 11y agoNot to them, but through them. I'm paying them to take that data, and deliver it verbatim to some other party. They are reasonably free to refuse to take my money (they may have traded that freedom for some other gain, but then it's a different story), what they can't do is claim they are providing that service, while adulterating my data.
- ksk 11y ago>Not to them, but through them. To send it through them, you have to send it TO them. You know what I meant, lets not waste time on this. > what they can't do is claim they are providing that service, while adulterating my data. They can do anything they want, unless its against the law. (Or to be more specific, unless its proven in a court to be against the law). The point is that we are relying on COMMONLY AGREED terms of what a service must provide. There is no explicit legal definition of what a routing service must do. The legal case, is not the same as the technical case. I was replying to the person whose argument was - my computer, my rules. My point is the telecom can go - My router/infrastructure, my rules.
- njharman 11y agoYou're making the wrong argument. You get to control what you are subjected to. If you don't want to be bombarded by psychologically manipulative propaganda, it is just, correct, ethical, and legal(for now) not to be. If you produce ad burdened content hoping that I will allow myself to be advertised to. I'm glad to crush that hope. You can charge for your content, stop producing it, etc. What you can't do is demand I endure you're fucking advertising.
- bediger4000 11y agoThank you. I was indeed making the wrong argument. Your argument is much better, and takes the ethical high ground.
- zzalpha 11y agoHow is ad blocking an ethical issue? I get to control my computer, at least until some legislation passes that says I don't. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tragedy_of_the_commons No one said it's a black-and-white ethical issue. It's unquestionably a dilemma. And as a user of ad blocking software, one I myself wrestle with.
- hsod 11y agoThe ethical argument, which is briefly considered in this article, is that by blocking ads you are violating an implied agreement with the site owners. Legality and technology are irrelevant, it's simply a question of whether or not such an implied agreement exists and whether or not it is ethical to break it. My opinion is that such an agreement does exist, and that it is a (very minor) unethical act to break it, and that it is a much larger unethical act to brag gleefully about breaking it as many are doing in this thread. The virtuous way to respond to an untenable agreement is to avoid it altogether, not to take the parts that benefit you and violate the parts that don't.
- flavor8 11y agoAre there any analagous "implied agreements" that lend weight to your opinion, or are we breaking new ground with this? And as a counterpoint, I would suggest that the "implied agreement" respects the user to whom ads are being served. Sites like gawker, huffington, techcrunch who attempt to sell my behavior to 6-10 ad networks are stepping over that line.