3 ms·
I'm a biophysicist. Almost most of my work uses entirely classical approximations to quantum (which themselves are parameterized using quantum chemistry and ph
by dekhn 11y ago
I'm a biophysicist. Almost most of my work uses entirely classical approximations to quantum (which themselves are parameterized using quantum chemistry and physics), I can assure you, that by definition, all biology is inherently quantum. The physics of hydrogen bonds practically guarantee it (to the extent we can make positive factual statements).
The biophysics of DNA mutation repair -- DNA mutations are a major contribution to genetic changes that lead to observable phenotypes -- are ultimately and firmly quantum. It's unclear at this point whether the quantum phenomena such as coherence or tunneling play any role, but the definition of "quantum" is much larger than just those phenomena. My intuition is that quantum tunnelling of electrons probably plays a role in the kinetics of DNA mutation repair, although this is purely speculative.
Further, some very interesting and mostly ignored experiments by Jackie Barton have demonstrated that the DNA backbone can be used to transmit information; the conjugated pi orbitals of the bases form a long-range, possibly coherent electron path(!) but it's not clear that these phenomena are relevant to evolution.
- _rpd 11y agoBut isn't the reason that the classical approximations work so well that quantum effects are drowned out by the thermal noise floor at room temperature? And reliable processes like DNA replication have to depend on 'classical' chemical bond energies that are at least a couple of orders of magnitude above the noise floor, right?
- dekhn 11y agoNo. I think part of the reason people are having so much trouble on this thread is they are confusing the field of quantum physics with quantum chemistry. The processes of DNA replication actually involve hydrogen bonds, and comparing the relative energies of different forms of hydrogen bond groups, at or near the thermal limit (1-2 kcal/mol).
- Florin_Andrei 11y ago> that by definition, all biology is inherently quantum All chemistry is quantum already.