4 ms·
"The colour of your eyes, the shape of your nose, your intelligence or propensity for disease are encoded at the quantum level." Uh, nope.
by titzer 11y ago
"The colour of your eyes, the shape of your nose, your intelligence or propensity for disease are encoded at the quantum level."
Uh, nope.
- Drakim 11y agoThat quote instantly makes me lose any credibility in the author. Is he/she really that ignorant of basic biology, or am I misunderstanding something?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ewzimm 11y agoThe author is a molecular biologist with several published books and over 100 peer-reviewed articles, so he definitely has a grasp on basic biology. I think that what you are missing is the assertion that each atom plays an individual role in the process. That is, there are low-level processes that take place on a small enough scale to depend on quantum effects that make direct contributions to DNA. The point is that quantum physics contributes a lot more than we usually think to macroscopic processes like biology.
- deepnet 11y agoThe author's 1999 paper proposes a quantum mechanic to explain adaptive mutation. They assert that E. Coli mutates to develop lactase in a lactose enviroment, it does this quickly and seemingly without adverse mutations - randomness fails to explain this. McFadden and Khalili propose that adaptive DNA mutation is a quantum computation. The many possible mutations are explored simultaneously and the quantum state collapses to one highly correlated to the enviroment. Their 1999 paper A quantum mechanical explanation for adaptive mutation goes in depth. http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publication/12899582_A_quantum_mechanical_model_of_adaptive_mutation/links/09e4150fa9e345efc4000000.pdf http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publica... This has led to a new scientific discipline Quantum Biology http://www.ias.surrey.ac.uk/workshops/quantumbiology/ http://www.ias.surrey.ac.uk/workshops/quantumbiology/
- titzer 11y agoReading their abstract makes me cringe. "The principle that mutations occur randomly with respect to the direction of evolutionary change has been challenged by the phenomenon of adaptive mutations. There is currently no entirely satisfactory theory to account for how a cell can selectively mutate certain genes in response to environmental signals. However, spontaneous mutations are initiated by quantum events such as the shift of a single proton (hydrogen atom) from one site to an adjacent one. We consider here the wave function describing the quantum state of the genome as being in a coherent linear superposition of states describing both the shifted and unshifted protons. Quantum coherence will be destroyed by the process of decoherence in which the quantum state of the genome becomes correlated (entangled) with its surroundings. Using a very simple model we estimate the decoherence times for protons within DNA and demonstrate that quantum coherence may be maintained for biological time-scales. Interaction of the coherent genome wave function with environments containing utilisable substrate will induce rapid decoherence and thereby destroy the superposition of mutant and non-mutant states. We show that this accelerated rate of decoherence may significantly increase the rate of production of the mutated state." I'm no physicist but this smacks of total BS. We know that DNA codes for proteins chemically and no sort of "entangled wave function" is going to spontaneously change an A to a G, split or recombine a DNA molecule along a particular gene boundary, or cause a duplication. The fact that some cells might generate more mutations in response to environment changes doesn't demand quantum weirdness. Did the authors ever think _maybe_ there is a good old enzyme inside cells that intentionally alters the DNA at particular locations, thereby generating mutations? WTF...
- dekhn 11y agoNote that Jackie Barton has already shown that conjugated pi bonds formed along DNA chains can be used to transmit information; the theory of molecular orbitals is a quantum one. Also, spontaneous mutations occur, and they're caused by interactions between bases and photons; again, these can only be explained by using quantum molecular orbital theory. I'm not going to the argue the author of your quoted statement is likely to be correct.
- 11y ago
- techbio 11y agoIt seems like a science writer's scheme to tie theoretical physics to what "the informed reader" may have familiarity or interest in, ie. DNA, putting Schrodinger and Crick in the same orbit. Technically speaking, molecular interactions must rely on quantum effects, therefor the encoding does exist at the quantum level, as opposed to the applesauce level. But this article is not really about genetics or applesauce.
- bdg 11y agoTo me the "quantum level" distinction is the issue. This is like saying you need to use Newtonian calculations for one set of speeds and Einstein's for another as if reality "switched gears" like a race car. The quantum level is the only level, all distinctions are purely in the mind. http://lesswrong.com/lw/pc/quantum_explanations/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/pc/quantum_explanations/
- feelix 11y agoIt is Schroedinger who said that, who, considering his time in history, had a very broad view of what quantum mechanics and DNA are. Given his high level viewpoint he was correct, considering that he was making a reference to interactions at the level of the universe. Although it is actually your DNA which codes the colour of your eyes, it is also true that quantum mechanics plays a part in the DNA encoding itself, which is what makes his statement true. And the fact that furthermore an exact process was discovered actually makes his statement a remarkably good prediction, as shown here: "And, just as Schrödinger predicted, ‘every group of atoms’ does indeed play ‘an individual role’, with the position of even individual protons – a quantum property – determining each genetic letter".
- duaneb 11y agoSo, everything on the nanometer level is quantum mechanics? Seems like a cop-out answer. Quantum mechanics as opposed to what? This is hardly new.
- dvanduzer 11y agoThat's the exact phrase that I found so suspect. That makes it sound like the distinction between nucleotides is atomic, rather than molecular. Is that true / nuanced in some particular way I don't know about?
- dekhn 11y agoI'm a biophysicist. Almost most of my work uses entirely classical approximations to quantum (which themselves are parameterized using quantum chemistry and physics), I can assure you, that by definition, all biology is inherently quantum. The physics of hydrogen bonds practically guarantee it (to the extent we can make positive factual statements). The biophysics of DNA mutation repair -- DNA mutations are a major contribution to genetic changes that lead to observable phenotypes -- are ultimately and firmly quantum. It's unclear at this point whether the quantum phenomena such as coherence or tunneling play any role, but the definition of "quantum" is much larger than just those phenomena. My intuition is that quantum tunnelling of electrons probably plays a role in the kinetics of DNA mutation repair, although this is purely speculative. Further, some very interesting and mostly ignored experiments by Jackie Barton have demonstrated that the DNA backbone can be used to transmit information; the conjugated pi orbitals of the bases form a long-range, possibly coherent electron path(!) but it's not clear that these phenomena are relevant to evolution.
- _rpd 11y agoBut isn't the reason that the classical approximations work so well that quantum effects are drowned out by the thermal noise floor at room temperature? And reliable processes like DNA replication have to depend on 'classical' chemical bond energies that are at least a couple of orders of magnitude above the noise floor, right?
- dekhn 11y agoNo. I think part of the reason people are having so much trouble on this thread is they are confusing the field of quantum physics with quantum chemistry. The processes of DNA replication actually involve hydrogen bonds, and comparing the relative energies of different forms of hydrogen bond groups, at or near the thermal limit (1-2 kcal/mol).
- Florin_Andrei 11y ago> that by definition, all biology is inherently quantum All chemistry is quantum already.