10 ms·
Quantum weirdness is everywhere in life
- mastazi 11y agoThis is and incredibly fascinating read! Thanks for posting.
- ild 11y agoThat claim about DNA, mutations and quantum effects - well it makes the paper less credible. DNA and its replication and mutations are largely non-quantum and it is also not true at all that in DNA every matters; minor alterations of the do not produce invalid code.
- sklogic 11y agoProtein folding is a quantum thing indeed. And folding matters no less than the amino acids sequence.
- ild 11y agoFolding has nothing to do with DNA.
- sklogic 11y agoDNA encodes the amino acid sequence. Quantum mechanics defines the folding. These two things combined determine the colour of your eyes, etc., etc. Encoding per se is meaningless without the folding. Also, the way how RNA polymerase work (i.e., transcription) is of quite a quantum nature too.
- ild 11y agoDNA needs to be _unfolded_ during transcription. Anyway, the information stored in DNA in a very much non-quantum nature. > Also, the way how RNA polymerase work (i.e., transcription) is of quite a quantum nature too. Proof?
- sklogic 11y agoYes, the DNA encoded information is classic (please do not consider my comments as any kind of an endorsment of the OP article). But, as I said, this is only a half of the information you need to get any sensible predictions of the results. The rest is defined by folding, and it is very much quantum (heuristics aside). > Proof? I never heard of any polymerase simulation which did not involve computational quantum chemistry methods. Cannot even think of any possible classic approximation (again, heuristics aside - they're just masking the quantum nature of the underlying physics). EDIT: as for transcription, do not forget about the operons. Theirs molecular mechanics is also very quantum.
- dekhn 11y agoDNA and RNA both also fold. This is an approximation: http://mfold.rna.albany.edu/?q=mfold/dna-folding-form http://mfold.rna.albany.edu/?q=mfold/dna-folding-form The underlying quantum chemistry (which doesn't need to specifically invoke coherence or tunneling) is required to get truly accurate results. Classical approximations aren't sufficient to measure really subtle energy differences between folded forms.
- ild 11y agoI am not talking about RNA. I am talking strictly about. The way DNA stores information has nothing to do with the way it is folded. Proteins and some types of RNA require proper folding to function, DNA does not.
- dekhn 11y agoThis is incorrect: DNA in the folded form of chromatin stores information. In particular, chromatin state is epigenetic and is used to deactivate many genes during the development process. Further, even a duplex is a "fold" (coiled coils are a structural motif). You're fixating on the A T G C base form of encoding; DNA contains a lot more information than just that, encoded in its quatenary structure.
- deepnet 11y agoThe pull quote from the article is indeed misleading. McFadden's work is an attempt to provide a foundation for adaptive mutation. Adaptive mutation is where only well adapted mutations occur at odds with a random explantion. From (the OP's author) McFadden's and Khalili's 1999 paper: A quantum mechanical model of adaptive mutation "The principle that mutations occur randomly with respect to the direction of evolutionary change has been challenged by the phenomenon of adaptive mutations. There is currently no entirely satisfactory theory to account for how a cell can selectively mutate certain genes in response to environmental signals. However, spontaneous mutations are initiated by quantum events such as the shift of a single proton (hydrogen atom) from one site to an adjacent one. We consider here the wave function describing the quantum state of the genome as being in a coherent linear superposition of states describing both the shifted and unshifted protons. Quantum coherence will be destroyed by the process of decoherence in which the quantum state of the genome becomes correlated (entangled) with its surroundings." http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publication/12899582_A_quantum_mechanical_model_of_adaptive_mutation/links/09e4150fa9e345efc4000000.pdf http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publica...
- titzer 11y ago"The colour of your eyes, the shape of your nose, your intelligence or propensity for disease are encoded at the quantum level." Uh, nope.
- Drakim 11y agoThat quote instantly makes me lose any credibility in the author. Is he/she really that ignorant of basic biology, or am I misunderstanding something?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ewzimm 11y agoThe author is a molecular biologist with several published books and over 100 peer-reviewed articles, so he definitely has a grasp on basic biology. I think that what you are missing is the assertion that each atom plays an individual role in the process. That is, there are low-level processes that take place on a small enough scale to depend on quantum effects that make direct contributions to DNA. The point is that quantum physics contributes a lot more than we usually think to macroscopic processes like biology.
- deepnet 11y agoThe author's 1999 paper proposes a quantum mechanic to explain adaptive mutation. They assert that E. Coli mutates to develop lactase in a lactose enviroment, it does this quickly and seemingly without adverse mutations - randomness fails to explain this. McFadden and Khalili propose that adaptive DNA mutation is a quantum computation. The many possible mutations are explored simultaneously and the quantum state collapses to one highly correlated to the enviroment. Their 1999 paper A quantum mechanical explanation for adaptive mutation goes in depth. http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publication/12899582_A_quantum_mechanical_model_of_adaptive_mutation/links/09e4150fa9e345efc4000000.pdf http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publica... This has led to a new scientific discipline Quantum Biology http://www.ias.surrey.ac.uk/workshops/quantumbiology/ http://www.ias.surrey.ac.uk/workshops/quantumbiology/
- gfodor 11y agoEach of the main points of the article has the feel that the conclusions are speculative wrt quantum mechanics -- any experts able to comment on them? Feels like an article over-selling inconclusive results.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoIt's the difference between quantum and quantum[tm] "as used in publishing[tm] to sell content[tm]".
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWell, being surprised that "quantum physics is everywhere" is like being surprised every computer program runs on machine code. Surely you didn't think transistors run JavaScript natively? Quantum physics isn't a weird part of reality, it's the reality (or, to be precise, a low-level model of it).
- nota_bene 11y agoAnd quantum physics will stop being weird once we get its rule set (lightning and thunder had God status, once).
- TeMPOraL 11y agoExactly. It's not quantum physics that is weird, it's our intuitions that are wrong (since we never had to explicitly deal with nanoscale before XX century).
- sklogic 11y agoOur intuition is so poor that it even gets many classical mechanics problems wrong. Most hilariously the various resonance-related things (my favourite practical example is a pendulum swinging upwards, which looks like pure magic). Intuition is also very poor in dealing with nonlinear things (think soliton waves and all that stuff). So, trusting an intuition is always wrong and intuition got no place in science anyway, not just in nanoscale.
- 4Data 11y agoCan you give an example of a pendulum swinging upwards? Is that an inverted pendulum? [1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5oGYCxkgnHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5oGYCxkgnHQ
- sklogic 11y agoYes, that's a good example. The recipe I used for such demos was based on an old Soviet electric shaver and a standard bicycle wheel spoke, it's a known combination to get an inverted pendulum (even at funny angles, not necessarily entirely upward).
- ape4 11y agoI suppose its like using some inline assembler. Most of the time C/C++ can do it but sometimes you need a dash of asm.
- rogerbraun 11y agoIt's always a shame when the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics is presented as how reality works. Most of the perceived weirdness of QM comes from the leaps of faith required to make the Copenhagen interpretation work.
- n4r9 11y agoThere's a lot of truth in that, and the orthodox interpretation is indeed riddled with incoherence. But what fascinates me is that after so much effort, the quantum community seems to be further away than ever from coming to a consensus on interpreting the theory. Every proposed interpretation does away with some foundational issue, yet introduces another in the process.
- ikeboy 11y agoThey may not have a consensus, but why do you think they're further away from consensus than they were in the past?
- n4r9 11y agoIf you mean "what has led you to think they're further away from consensus": mostly just gut feeling, as a (younger) member of that community. I've not seen any rigorous and comprehensive studies of which interpretations garner the most support, but it does seem like popularity is currently divided between the orthodox and several other interpretations that have evolved from "niche" to "significant minority" in recent years. If instead you mean "by what process are they further away from consensus": I would suggest that the recent surge of research in quantum information theory has stimulated a greater interest in foundational issues, which in turn has led to an invigoration of the interpretations debate.
- gfodor 11y agohttp://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2013/01/17/the-most-embarrassing-graph-in-modern-physics/ http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2013/01/17/the-most... In short Copenhagen still (sadly) rules the day, followed by many worlds and QIT.
- tempodox 11y ago“Abandon all hope, ye who enter here.” If the brain-splitting weirdness of human life has a basis in physics, all we can do is give up and succumb to the utter illogic of it all. Somehow that perspective makes me uncomfortable.
- deepnet 11y agoThe articles author, Johnjo Mcfadden and his collaborator, Jim Al Khalili, are proposing a new scientific discipline, Quantum Biology. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_theories_of_quantum_evolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_theories_of_quantu... Here is McFaddens and Khalili's 1999 paper A quantum mechanical model of adaptive behaviour http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publication/12899582_A_quantum_mechanical_model_of_adaptive_mutation/links/09e4150fa9e345efc4000000.pdf http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Johnjoe_Mcfadden/publica... It is an interesting new field and much more scholarly than the OP article allows. They have a book which goes in depth and Jim has an excellent BBC tv show presenting the key ideas. Here are Khalili's Royal Institution lecture, the book and tv show, which cover the same material in depth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwgQVZju1ZM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwgQVZju1ZM http://www.amazon.co.uk/Life-Edge-Coming-Quantum-Biology/dp/0593069315 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Life-Edge-Coming-Quantum-Biology/dp/... http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04v85cj http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04v85cj The IAS 2012 workshop on Quantum Biology has a number of presentations: http://www.ias.surrey.ac.uk/workshops/quantumbiology/report.php http://www.ias.surrey.ac.uk/workshops/quantumbiology/report.... Here is Jim's 2012 presentation on the role of Quantum tunneling in Adaptive Genetic mutation. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iujZr42Aho4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iujZr42Aho4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iujZr42Aho4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iujZr42Aho4
- ikeboy 11y ago>Yet nobody really believes that a cat can be simultaneously dead and alive. Except, of course, all those physicists that do. http://www.hedweb.com/everett/everett.htm#believes http://www.hedweb.com/everett/everett.htm#believes
- nilkn 11y agoNot quite. They believe there are two separate universes, one in which the cat is alive and one in which the cat is dead. This is very different from thinking the cat is alive and dead simultaneously in the same universe.
- sorokod 11y agoThere is also the quantum mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mind
- kordless 11y agoThose that disagree with the quantum mind argument happen to be firm believers in the downvote button. :)
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoIt's not so much a matter of disagreeing. It's that the quantum mind is off-topic. Bringing it up here looks like an attempt to publicize the idea by riding on the coat-tails of a completely unrelated article. That's worthy of downvotes, whatever one thinks of the idea itself.
- ZoFreX 11y agoQuantum: Check Crystals: Check Using established scientific terminology mashed together in a way that sounds rigorous on the surface but is really gibberish: Check!
- Sven7 11y agoWe need to believe all men are created equal but everyone knows it isn't true. So goes for particles probably. Would explain all the weirdness.
- dekhn 11y agoto me, the strongest argument for quantum weirdness (which isn't actually that weird once you appreicate that quantum laws don't actually allow you to break causality) in biology is photosynthesis. There is some pretty strong evidence- not completely agreed upon but still pretty strong- that coherence plays a role.
- deepnet 11y agoQuantum coherence in biological energy transfer, Scholes - U Toronto http://www.chem.utoronto.ca/staff/SCHOLES/scholes_home.html http://www.chem.utoronto.ca/staff/SCHOLES/scholes_home.html
- dekhn 11y agoI was gonna cite this work from their experimental collaborator: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v446/n7137/full/nature05678.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v446/n7137/full/nature0... It's one of the most exquisite bits of biophysics I've ever seen.
- daxfohl 11y agoI'm surprised there's no mention of the van der Walls attraction used by geckos feet. http://mappingignorance.org/2013/07/04/quantum-mechanics-in-biological-systems-ii-gecko%C2%B4s-adhesion/ http://mappingignorance.org/2013/07/04/quantum-mechanics-in-...
- jacquesm 11y agoIt's 'van der Waals'.