3 ms·
I suppose it isn't too surprising they don't have any clip longer than 10 seconds in that video. Lets guess that it is going 1.5m/s (a bit more than 5km/hr or
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I suppose it isn't too surprising they don't have any clip longer than 10 seconds in that video.
Lets guess that it is going 1.5m/s (a bit more than 5km/hr or 3.3 mph which is a brisk walking speed). And lets assume the typical rider is 75kg (about 165 lbs). that takes about a kW to get up to speed but you only need it once you get to speed and it looks like it gets there quickly so over 3 seconds or so, figure a 3k watt-seconds. Then driving along you're probably at 1/4 (really efficient) to 1/2 (more typical) power covering rolling friction. (more if you are going up hill [sin(grade) * mass]) so in that size "plate" you can get maybe 10Wh of battery? That puts run times in the 60 - 70 seconds range. Followed by a 30 - 90 minute charge cycle (depending on how aggressive you can be)
I love the form factor and the concept, but we just don't have energy density in our batteries yet AFAICT.
- nothrabannosir 11y agoFrom the article: Even though it looks tiny and so lightweight (it’s made of aluminum), it can easily carry 120kg and you can travel at max speed of 10 kmph for at least 12 km. After that you’ll probably need a re-charge, and apparently it’ll take 3 hours for that. Essentially, you're saying they are flat-out lying. Could be, of course. But that's quite a claim.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI was just working backwards from the physics, one of the things I've done in the past if build battlebots, and one of the interesting thing about those machines, typically ~100kg weight limit, is figuring out how long you can run them so they will last 5 minutes in the ring but you aren't carrying any extra weight in batteries. So from the article you have two things, you have 10mph for 12km (that is 1.2 hours of driving) and a recharge time of 90 minutes (1.5hrs) Batteries charge at a rate called 'C' (their capacity) so a battery that charges at 2C means that it can charge (accept current) twice as fast as its rated capacity. They need at least 500W (2/3hp approximately) to move a vertical human at 10kph. And they do that for 1.2 hours? so 600Watt-hours. Assuming your battery is driving brushless motors with a 48V working voltage that is 12.5 Amp hours net, so at 85% efficiency (good batteries) that is a 15 amp-hour, 48V battery. (or four 12V 15Ah batteries wired in series). So yeah, the physics doesn't work for me on their specs. I would love to learn how the do that differently and get that much energy into such a small and light package. That would help me make a more competitive battle bot (lots of energy left over for weapons like spinners and what not.)
- Jedd 11y ago> So from the article you have two things, you have 10mph for 12km > (that is 1.2 hours of driving) and a recharge time of 90 minutes Were we reading the same article? 10 km/hr for at least 12 km. Recharge time of around 3 hours.
- Dylan16807 11y agoMy little laptop battery is 80Wh, and they could fit ten into that thing. Edit: watching the video it's a bit thinner than I thought but I see no problems with battery mass. Edit 2: http://www.greencarcongress.com/2009/12/panasonic-20091225.html http://www.greencarcongress.com/2009/12/panasonic-20091225.h... Look at these for example, they go in tesla packs and would provide enough power by your calculations at about 1 liter and 5 pounds, and that thing can definitely fit a liter.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoExcellent, that is a pretty energy dense battery! I stand corrected, if they are using something like this, it could work.