6 ms·
This is not a bug it is a feature. The rich are a lot smarter today than when they were the descendants of feudal landlords - 100 years of meritocracy combined
by danieltillett 11y ago
This is not a bug it is a feature.
The rich are a lot smarter today than when they were the descendants of feudal landlords - 100 years of meritocracy combined with assortative mating makes for a very clever ruling class.
Edit. Spelling.
- withdavidli 11y agoNot exactly true, back in feudal times just being able to read was quite a privilege. They also had a lock on information. We're much more on equal footing in terms of ability to gain information. Whether we act on the information is another issue.
- daveloyall 11y agoAre you kidding? What does a family line which has had uninterrupted, exclusive access to a personal library know? I mean think about it--what is that family like? That family which has held on to the same chunk of physical space, with books and notebooks, for several generations. "Equal footing in terms of ability to gain information", my ass! My own toddler gets confused when he tries to describe his home--probably because he's moved three times in as many years. I remember the encyclopedias I read as a child. But, I don't have them. I can't review them. I can't consult my notes, nor smell them and get connected to the concrete memory of the day I learned about phases of matter or dry cell batteries. Those things are important. They change the slope of the playing field.
- withdavidli 11y agoi don't understand the argument you are trying to make. you cut off the the "more" to make it sound like my statement meant we are equal instead of relatively better than we once were in comparison to the upper class. then proceeded to provide examples of your toddler being able to retain information and yourself retaining information. both are about memory and ability to recall those memories with accuracy.
- daveloyall 11y agoI had to go looking for that 'more'. I guess I cut it off (didn't notice it to begin with) because it's a meaningless modifier when attached to an absolute-sounding phrase like "equal footing". I don't know the name of this writing style pitfall, but here is another example: "The boot hardly annihilated the flower." ...That's a terrible example? Oh, in the first post, my examples are about "ability to gain information [learn]" but you were talking about "ability to gain information [access]". Okay, yes the internet and the public library system are truly wonderful. I do presume that the ruling class (and/or the rich) have some information that is not publicly available, and it's probably very important information, but yes, a poor man can walk into a library today and find treasure laying around. That has improved our footing. :)
- danieltillett 11y agoIn order to have an effective meritocracy you have to have universal education. You then pick the top 0.1% and invite them to join you and marry your son or daughter. The whole economic system is designed to identify the very clever no matter their background and bring them into the ruling class.
- khuey 11y agoIf you banish any of the smart/clever/etc to the underclass they might just start a revolution. Much easier to invite them to join the party.
- danieltillett 11y agoExactly right. The rich found this out early last century with the rise of communism. What they did was very clever; they basically introduced socialism in the 1930s by shifting the majority share of production to the masses to keep them quiet, introduced mass higher education with an emphasis on identifying the very smart (troublemakers if excluded) and brought them into the ruling class. Once this "decapitation of the masses” was in place (1970) they slowly took back their share of production. We are now back to the level the rich had in the 19th C. Impressive if somewhat depressing.
- MaysonL 11y agoDemocracy is the insurance premium the rich pay against the threat of pitchforks and guillotines.
- danieltillett 11y agoDemocracy only works if you have leaders. The non-rich no longer have leaders. We do at least have better bread and circus than the past.
- cinquemb 11y agoIf we build upon your assertion ("to have an effective meritocracy you have to have universal education"), if some of those in power define universal education differently (which would seem to make any concept of universality in education void of such in practice), then it wouldn't be surprising to see a decline in the effectiveness of an economic system, which is what I would suggest is what we are seeing today.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoMy social networks include a fair number of wealthy people. Some of their kids are dumb as rocks, and they don't have to improve themselves, ever. Those are the real welfare queens. Sometimes a fool can be made a leader by other people in power. Believe me, I'm American.
- danieltillett 11y agoYou might have noticed that I said the rich are smarter than in the past, but the ruling class are very clever. As you rightly point out there are plenty of dumb rich, but relatively few of these dumb rich are ruling. As for leaders who the figurehead is does not matter - ask yourself what do the rulers care more about; who is the POTUS or who is the head of the federal reserve.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoAre the ruling classes more clever, or has technology and globalization allowed average cleverness to be more impactful than in the past?
- danieltillett 11y agoThis is not an either or question :) The ruling class is both much clever than the past and technology and globalization has allowed their cleverness to result in more control. In regards the level of control I am most impressed at how subtly it is used. To be able to shift the the share of production from 75% masses / 25% rich to 50% masses / 50% rich in 40 years with barely a peep is truly breathtaking. They have even been able to convince a large section of the population that this is all the fault of people with brown skin.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThis split is why I am not sold on why the rich or ruling classes are more clever than any other point in time, and not simply enabled by technology. I would like to see evidence of increased cleverness over time divorced from technological enabling.
- habitue 11y agoHoly shit. I hope this is sarcastic
- danieltillett 11y agoI am curious to know why you think this?
- api 11y agoYou must be new here. There's a sizable cadre of IQ score worshipping neo-eugenicists around here. More people need to actually study evolutionary biology. Like I mean the real kind with math and combinatorics and stuff. Or maybe I'm just a stupid head.
- danieltillett 11y agoI think you might mean population genetics, not evolutionary biology. If you study population genetics you might discover what results from assortative mating.
- elektromekatron 11y agoHow on earth would you study evolutionary biology without studying population genetics? Is a bit like saying not to study mathematics because you actually need calculus.
- danieltillett 11y agoEvolutionary biology is a real big field. Typically population genetics is its own separate subject at the university level. I was not suggesting to not study evolutionary biology (we should just call it biology as there is no such thing as non-evolutionary biology), just explaining what is the area you need to study if you want to understand the question being discussed.
- elektromekatron 11y ago
- enraged_camel 11y agoCounter-data: Paris Hilton.
- danieltillett 11y agoActually Paris is quite smart, she just plays an idiot for the masses. Even if she was an idiot, it proves nothing. There are plenty of dumb rich as even with assortative mating your children will be normally distributed, just from a higher mean.
- enraged_camel 11y ago>>Actually Paris is quite smart, she just plays an idiot for the masses. People said the same thing about George W. Bush. We have yet to see any evidence for that assertion, both for him and Hilton. >>There are plenty of dumb rich as even with assortative mating your children will be normally distributed, just from a higher mean. Quite a bold claim. I'd like to see a citation.
- danieltillett 11y ago>People said the same thing about George W. Bush. We have yet to see any evidence for that assertion, both for him and Hilton. GWB got a SAT mark that implies a IQ over 130. While he certainly liked to play the fool for his audience, I saw no evidence that he was stupid, just totally corrupt. >Quite a bold claim. I'd like to see a citation. Any trait that has more than a few hundred genes influencing it will be normally distributed with the mean of the offspring the mean of the parents. The genetic component of intelligence is influenced by a few thousand genes so it is not surprising to find that intelligence is normally distributed with the offspring mean the mean of the parents. This is population genetics 101. One of the more interesting observations about human intelligence is the variation in high intelligence is almost all genetics while low intelligence has a quite large environmental component [1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heritability_of_IQ
- 11y ago
- eyed 11y agoThere haven't been hundreds of years of meritocracy. For one, women have only even been allowed to attend university since the mid 1800s, and only got the right to degrees much later. You can't have a so-called meritocracy when half te population isn't even allowed to particpate. At best, we've maybe had 35 years of meritocracy. Secondly, where's your evidence? Your statement seems to be total conjecture.