7 ms·
Warning after security experts hack Tesla car
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 11y agoThe Wired article notes that they could install a remote backdoor so they could later effect the car over the network. There was also this problem: > But they also found that the car’s infotainment system was using an out-of-date browser, which contained a four-year-old Apple WebKit vulnerability that could potentially let an attacker conduct a fully remote hack to start the car or cut the motor. Theoretically, an attacker could make a malicious web page, and if someone in a Tesla car visited the site, could gain access to the infotainment system. But you're right it's not like FCA, because this happened: > The company also engineered the car to handle sudden power loss in a graceful way. If power to the car were cut while the vehicle was in motion, the hand brake would kick in, and the car would lurch to a stop if it was traveling 5 miles per hour or less. It would go into neutral if traveling faster than this. But the driver would still retain control of the steering and brakes and be able to pull the car over. The airbags also would still be fully functional. Tesla put thought into it. They designed their system with failsafes to minimize risk (to a degree) if the system got hacked. It's not perfect but it's a hell of a lot better than nothing.
- joosters 11y agoShame they didn't put in enough thought to update a four year old WebKit... or enough thought to isolate a web browser from engine control systems...
- tlb 11y agoIt is isolated on a separate CPU for the infotainment system. However, that same system hosts the UI to configure the drive system (suspension height, range/power tradeoffs, traction control) so if you pwn the infotainment system you can attack the drive system over the car's internal Ethernet.
- tlb 11y agoI wish they'd drop the browser in the dashboard. It's not a very good browser (sluggish, doesn't play audio or video), so despite the large screen it's better to just use my phone. And it's a huge attack surface. Parenthetically, it's a sad state of affairs, certainly not what early web folks expected, that making a browser is so difficult that only 2 huge companies can make even sort-of-acceptable ones that still require constant bugfixes.
- elihu 11y agoIt's interesting that the Mozilla foundation, as part of a project to create a new rendering engine for Firefox (servo), determined that they needed a new programming language in order to do it right and produced rust.
- rasz_pl 11y ago>Tesla put thought into it. They designed their system with failsafes Yes, they even build CTRL-ALT-DEL right into the steering wheel, seriously :)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- breser 11y agoThere's a much better article on Wired that goes into more details: http://www.wired.com/2015/08/researchers-hacked-model-s-teslas-already/ http://www.wired.com/2015/08/researchers-hacked-model-s-tesl... It's also worth noting that Tesla pushed a patch to all of their cars for this yesterday.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 11y agoFiat/Chrysler - recalled 1.4M cars, estimate 80+% will get fixed. Tesla - pushed an OTA update, done. That pretty much paints the future of "smart software" in cars. That said, every science fiction book I've ever read where vehicles could be patched over the air, has been been used as a plot device and gone badly for the hero of the story. Interesting times indeed.
- bentcorner 11y agoHas there been an incident where an OTA mechanism resulted in something bad? (E.g., MITM attack pushes down evil bits) It could be argued that the existence of an OTA mechanism incentivizes lower quality (RTM patches); I'd counter that it might do so in the short term only, although I have no data.
- wodzu 11y agoI would rather worry about bad guys pushing a harmful update to all the Tesla cars. Rather than hacking all the individual cars, hack the Tesla server and push the updates. Happened few times to open source software.
- selestify 11y ago> Happened few times to open source software Interesting, what are some examples?
- chambo622 11y agoSounds like Tesla worked with these guys to patch this for all owners before it was disclosed. And they hired Chris Evans from Chrome/Project Zero to lead security. To me those are signals that they take this seriously.
- vilda 11y agoIn first place let's frankly say that interconnecting entertainment system with anything that affects safety is dump idea. They top-notch security professionals should know that. I was developing entertainment system for Volkswagen's cars a while ago. At the time their cars have several networks interconnected with a simple firewall. They were separated into domains, if I remember correctly it was core (engine, steering wheel), first level (reporting, airbags, etc.), second level (opening windows, etc.), and then entertainment system. The firewall was one-way. Systems on lower level are able to intercept some messages from higher levels, but are unable to send anything to higher level (with some exception between core and first level). That also means that the entertainment system is unable to open/close windows for example - you have physical buttons for that. It was a while ago and my memory is rusty. But you get the idea that car systems can be build securely with competent engineers.
- varjag 11y agoI'm not sure if it was the case here, but Tesla has an over-the-air update channel, allowing to adjust overall performance envelope including acceleration, braking and suspension via update from the mothership. As long as you allow for that feature, the penetration vector is unavoidable and can't be engineered away.
- teacup50 11y agoIf they took this seriously, they wouldn't have their cars connect to anything, or at the very least, the connected parts would be fully air-gapped. How is it that we can be repeating the exact same mistakes made in software over the past 40 years, without anyone questioning whether the dangers of cloud-enabling cars is remotely justified by the features provided?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mshenfield 11y agoTesla seems much better prepared to deal with this than most car manufacturers. A downloadable update is a world away from the recall Chrysler had to issue.
- joosters 11y agoTrue. However, Tesla owners have to accept an 'always on' car, sharing who-know-what with Tesla over its cellular connection. Is there any way to just get OTA updates without giving away personal data (like location) to the company?
- angersock 11y agoHow would you know? EDIT: I meant that seriously--any functionality which can update the firmware can, by definition, remove your ability to tell that it's doing other things, too. See also "Reflections on Trusting Trust". EDIT2: And another downvote. Some people are absurd and clearly don't understand what is a completely reasonable comment about the nature of the security here. It's not, "How would you (somebody unskilled in these things, snarf snarf, mere mortal compared to angersock) know (anything about this)?". It's, "How would you (consumer without access to the source code being deployed) know (given that the machine can be made to fake output to whatever is most likely to make you think it's behaving normally)?" Jesus.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- eclipxe 11y agoI didn't read it that way at all. I read it as "how would you [any consumer] know if personal data was being shared?" not "how would you [comment op] if personal data was being shared?"
- joosters 11y agoFrom Tesla's privacy policy: * Telematics Log Data: To improve our vehicles and services for you, we collect certain telematics data regarding the performance, usage, operation, and condition of your Tesla vehicle, including the following: vehicle identification number, speed information, odometer readings, battery use management information, battery charging history, electrical system functions, software version information, infotainment system data, safety‐related data (including information regarding the vehicle’s SRS systems, brakes, security, e‐brake), and other data to assist in identifying and analyzing the performance of the vehicle. We may collect such information either in person (e.g., during a service appointment) or via remote access. * Remote vehicle analysis: We may be able to dynamically connect to your Tesla vehicle to diagnose and resolve issues with it, and this process may result in access to personal settings in the vehicle (such as contacts, browsing history, navigation history, and radio listening history). This dynamic connection also enables us to view the current location of your vehicle, but such access is restricted to a limited number of personnel within Tesla. Maybe there is a way to opt out of this, but I can't see it.
- danbruc 11y agoOff-topic - when did sentences and paragraphs become the same thing? I noticed this several times during the last months but may have overlooked it before. Is there something behind that?
- dangoor 11y agoI wonder if there's a difference for people writing for TV (this article is on the BBC website) and people writing for "print". It's hard to imagine the NYT publishing an article where each paragraph consists of a single sentence, short of that being the point of the article.
- hoopism 11y agoCan we generalize this a bit in light of all the recent car hacks? "Experts Reveal Connected Devices Are Vulnerable to Hacking"
- baseballmerpeak 11y agoBetter than Chrysler's approach of making the owner download the patch, copy it on to a blank flash drive, and load it via the in-dash USB.
- jakeogh 11y agoSome of us don't want wirelessly connected cars.
- jcadam 11y agoThis is what you get for buying modern vehicles. Just you try hacking my rusty '86 Pontiac. ... I can't even get the radio to play anything other than a faint static hum.
- johnward 11y agoThis required physical access. I'm sure I could do some damage with physical access to any vehicle.
- moistgorilla 11y agoFor your '86 pontiac it's even easier. All I need to do is cut the brakeline
- cmiller1 11y agoI posted about this in another thread about this Tesla "hack", but they required physical access to the INSIDE of the vehicle. An access port in the driver-side footwell. How is this a security problem? If someone malicious has physical access to a normal car they could cut the brake lines or drain the oil, without even needing to unlock the car. If I'm inside a car I own I think I'd PREFER it to know I can hack into the car's systems rather than it being totally locked down.
- jlg23 11y agoFrom the wired article: But they also found that the car’s infotainment system was using an out-of-date browser, which contained a four-year-old Apple WebKit vulnerability that could potentially let an attacker conduct a fully remote hack to start the car or cut the motor. Theoretically, an attacker could make a malicious web page, and if someone in a Tesla car visited the site, could gain access to the infotainment system. “From that point, you’d be able to use a privilege escalation vulnerability to gain additional access and do the other stuff that we described,” Rogers says.
- cmiller1 11y ago> Theoretically Well, when they show, in practice, that such an attack is possible, then we can have news headlines about it. By presenting it like this so Tesla had to patch it to save face, I'm sure they just closed the loophole that would allow consenting car owners to modify their car's software. As a gear-head and life-long tinkerer, I WANT to be able to mess with my car.
- boeing_boing 11y agoNeeding physical access isn't a limitation here given the browser exploit, but even if it was it is still a security problem. Cutting the brake lines and draining oil are very obvious methods of sabotage. Two minutes of investigation will make it clear that someone with malicious intent caused an accident. Malicious code uploaded to a car is hard to detect. The inconveniences, property damage, injuries, deaths and the ability to frame the individual as the cause of those intended consequences are incredibly valuable.
- legulere 11y agoThe situation with security vulnerabilities in software maybe should be a warning to not use (network-connected) computers to control everything. The internet of everything will probably mean that everything will become hackable.