9 ms·
From a million miles away, NASA camera shows moon crossing face of Earth
- aspirin 11y agoIs this the real reflectance of the moon? Seems so dark. Usually we see the moon at night surrounded by night sky, which probably skews our perception of the real color of the surface material.
- MindTwister 11y agoAccording to TFA the earth is just so much brighter.
- aspirin 11y agoYes, indeed. The eposure of the photo must have been set to make earth look as bright as we expect, and leaving the moon darker.
- ChrisGranger 11y agoYes, Earth's average albedo is around 0.3 while the Moon's is only around 0.12. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albedo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Albedo
- rogeryu 11y agoProbably because that's the Dark Side of the Moon? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dark_Side_of_the_Moon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dark_Side_of_the_Moon
- gonvaled 11y agoIs that a joke? The dark side of the moon is not more often dark than the visible side. It is just never visible from Earth.
- grokys 11y agoI'd suggest following the link that was posted.
- jeffwass 11y ago"There's no dark side of the moon, really. Matter o' fact, it's all dark."
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoThank you thank you thank you. I couldn't stop chuckling for at least five minutes. I waited 24+ hours to respond because I didn't want to call undue attention to your comment. I didn't want anyone to downvote you for violating HN's unwritten proscript about humor.
- kuschku 11y agoThe moon has approximately the same color as fresh asphalt, so it’s expected. It only looks bright on the night sky because everything else (including the stars) is just far darker.
- jeffwass 11y agoConversely, what I thought was pretty cool is seeing the reflection of the sun off the oceans, roughly in the middle of the earth 'disc'. You can see a fuzzy bright spot that stays in the middle of the disc as the earth spins.
- kazinator 11y agoYes. I remember reading somewhere (Wikipedia probably) the moon is only about as reflective as asphalt, believe it or not. Imagine how much brighter moonlight would be if it were painted brilliant white (e.g. titanium dioxide pigment). I'd love to see a simulation. Would it be bright enough so we could see enough scattering that the sky would appear blue, I wonder.
- hetman 11y agoFor anyone looking for the original link: http://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/from-a-million-miles-away-nasa-camera-shows-moon-crossing-face-of-earth http://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/from-a-million-miles-awa...
- gonvaled 11y agoMoon is tidally locked to Earth, which is interesting. How long will this last? How long has this been going on? Does this happen to all satellites in all planets? Another question: is the Moon orbiting plane aligned with the Earth rotation axis? Why or why not?
- avar 11y agoYou can get the answer to all these questions by reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tidal_locking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tidal_locking and: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbit_of_the_Moon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbit_of_the_Moon
- coldtea 11y agoThe magic of reading!
- gonvaled 11y agoSo, the Moon orbiting plane is close to the ecliptic, and the satellite is in the ecliptic (L1 is in the ecliptic). I do not get this: > About twice a year the camera will capture the moon and Earth together as the orbit of DSCOVR crosses the orbital plane of the moon. (nitpick: the DSCOVR has no "orbit" around the Earth, since it is in the L1 point) Since the Moon's orbit and the ecliptic are so close, I would expect this crossing to happen more often (on every turn of the Moon around the Earth)
- robbrown451 11y agoCool that California is so clearly visible. Too bad you can see the multiple exposures, one for each of red, green, and blue, on the hi-res image. Otherwise it is quite the perfect picture.
- geofffox 11y agoMaybe as interesting is where this satellite is: The Lagrange L1 point. The 5 Lagrange points in essence allow orbiting bodies to break Kepler's laws. A satellite a million miles closer to the Sun shouldn't have the same orbital period as the Earth... but it does.
- gonvaled 11y agoSo the satellite is not orbiting Earth? What is the advantage of putting the satellite there, as opposed to a regular orbit?
- Cogito 11y agoThe satellite, like everything in our solar system, is orbiting the sun. The sun-earth L1 lagrange point is between the sun and the earth (in every two-body gravitational system there are 5 lagrange points, so there are earth-moon lagrange points etc) These points are interesting because the orbit behaviour of items in them is weird! Specifically, the gravitational effects of the two bodies involved work in tandem to produce interesting effects. Any bodies positioned at the L1 lagrange point of a two-body system will stay in the same position relative to both the larger bodies. Normally, the closer you get to the thing you are orbiting the faster you orbit. If you are appropriately near another large body (like the earth) that second body "pulls" back on you [edit: as long as you are on the inside of it - if you're on the outside it pulls you forward, and you get the L2 point], causing your orbit to slow down. At L1, those forces are balanced, and the third, smaller body has the exact same orbital period as the second body. That is, the satellite is always on a straight line drawn between the earth and the sun. The main reason for it to be there is to measure the solar wind, an early detection system. It also happens to be in a great position to take pictures of the sunlit side of the earth.
- gonvaled 11y agoInteresting, thanks. I understand that the satellite needs to have some form of propulsion to keep it at L1 (it is unstable), so it must have a limited life. How long?
- bumbledraven 11y agoWhy aren't the stars more visible in the background? Does it have to do with the camera's exposure?
- gerhardi 11y agoEarth is a sunlit object in this picture, the luminosity is the same level as during the day on earth - would you see stars in your photos if you took a correctly exposed photo of something during daylight on earth? I don't think this would happen :) The dynamic range difference between day light objects on earth and the stars on the sky is huge.
- bumbledraven 11y agoThe satellite is 1 million miles away from Earth at the L1 Lagrange point. What is it about optics that allows us to compare a photo of the stars taken at such a distance with one taken from the surface of the earth? [Edit: "compare", in the sense of understanding whether or not the stars will or won't show up in each case. I get that the laws of optics are the same throughout the universe.] > The dynamic range difference between day light objects on earth and the stars on the sky is huge. I agree, but would a person sitting in the satellite see stars if they looked in that direction? If so, do our eyes just have better dynamic range than the camera used by the satellite?
- mnw21cam 11y agoYes, our eyes just do have a fantastic dynamic range. Having said that, if you were sitting on the satellite, you would see even more stars if you blinkered out the brightness of the sun, moon, and earth.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoDon't cameras have much better dynamic range, but we just limit it in software by reducing everything into 8-12bit/color images? After all, the hardware is just a bunch of sensors counting photons.
- xedarius 11y agoShould I be able to see Earth orbiting satellites in this picture?
- InclinedPlane 11y agoHow close are satellites to the spacecraft that took these photos? Well, it's about a million miles from Earth, generally the farthest satellites away from Earth are at about 40,000km altitude in geostationary orbit, which would put them maybe 4% closer to the spacecraft than Earth, so it wouldn't affect perspective hardly at all. So that leaves resolution and physical size. How big are satellites? About the size of cars or maybe a bus? Can you see cars in this picture?
- bumbledraven 11y ago> it's about a million miles from Earth, generally the farthest satellites away from Earth are at about 40,000km altitude in geostationary orbit, which would put them maybe 4% closer to the spacecraft than Earth No, that puts satellites in geostationary orbit 2.5% as close to Earth as the satellite that took this picture (in other words, it is 40 times as far away from Earth).
- Osmium 11y agoNo more than you'd expect to be able to see a car, I don't think.
- mnw21cam 11y agoYou mean like the moon? Yes. You mean like meteosat? No. A 4 metre wide object is going to be such a small proportion of the size of a single pixel that it will be completely invisible.
- lqdc13 11y agoDoes anyone know why they decided to go with just a 4 megapixel camera? I guess they could settle for taking more narrow images and recombining later but it seems better to take one image and crop if they are just interested in small parts. Plus you have the option for digital zoom.
- gojomo 11y agoThese pictures, at this angle, imply that the Earth regions under the moon were experiencing a solar eclipse, right? (Odd that the NASA article doesn't mention this.) EDIT: There was no solar eclipse at the "last month" time-frame these pictures were taken. So that isn't a real earth-shadow under the leading edge of the moon, and as close as the moon seems to pass over the perspective-center of Earth, it must have actually been off somewhat, casting its shadow into space.
- krallja 11y agosee discussion on this topic at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10015354 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10015354
- gurtwo 11y agoWhy don't we see the Moon's shadow projected over the Earth in the pic? I guess it has to do with the relative distances of the 2 bodies to the Sun and the Moon's penumbra or something. Can someone make a digital image simulation of this to verify?
- gojomo 11y agoI thought the dark edge at the top-left of the moon was a shadow, but there was no solar eclipse in the time-frame reported for these pictures. So, even though a perfect alignment of DSCOVR (at L1), the moon, and Earth would mean a shadow and thus eclipse, the moon must be a little off that alignment on this pass, throwing its shadow into dark space, even though it looks very nearly aligned in the photos.
- jeffwass 11y agoThat dark edge is an artefact of the delay in capturing the three monochrome pictures through the different RGB filters. The article says : "Combining three images taken about 30 seconds apart as the moon moves produces a slight but noticeable camera artifact on the right side of the moon. Because the moon has moved in relation to the Earth between the time the first (red) and last (green) exposures were made, a thin green offset appears on the right side of the moon when the three exposures are combined. This natural lunar movement also produces a slight red and blue offset on the left side of the moon in these unaltered images."
- mark-r 11y agoIt also says "A thin sliver of shadowed area of moon is visible on its right side." which is a better explanation. It's not a shadow on the Earth, it's the dark part of the moon.
- gonvaled 11y agoThe lunar orbit is inclined to Earth's ecliptic plane by 5.1°. That is enough to throw the shadow of the Moon outside the Earth most of the time (expect in cases of solar eclipses, which are rare)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Tobold 11y agoSomeone tweeted this yesterday and some of the replies were really disheartening. Several people were calling it fake, with varying explanations of either "The earth is flat" or "Everybody knows the whole space program is fake". I knew people out there actually believe this, but damn...
- 13hours 11y agoI find Twitter to be second only to YouTube in comment trolls.
- bhaak 11y agoI have to say that the images look like badly photoshopped fakes to me as well. If they weren't on a NASA page, I wouldn't believe them to be real. Sometimes, reality is quite different from what we expect it to be.
- lcswi 11y agoDon't consider all comments to be honest, there are tons of bored trolls.
- bdavisx 11y agoBut also don't underestimate the stupidity, ignorance and/or anti-intellectualism of the general American (as well as other countries) population. Remember that 1/3 of Americans do not believe in evolution...
- hyperpallium 11y agoactual image http://cdn.phys.org/newman/gfx/news/2015/fromamillion.png http://cdn.phys.org/newman/gfx/news/2015/fromamillion.png nasa website used up 20MB of mobile data then crashed my browser (stock android)
- acqq 11y agoThe image NASA links is actually a 3MB GIF http://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/styles/full_width/public/thumbnails/image/dscovrepicmoontransitfull.gif http://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/styles/full_width/pu... My iDevices accidentally work with the NASA page. If your device crashes it's because of the other unfortunate "modern" web development practices that are really too resource heavy. Somebody inclined to analyze more can certainly find a lot of problems with their presentation (I see a lot of articles are on the same page, for example).
- Vanayad 11y agoWhat is the green "shadow" on the right of the moon? I'm not saying this is fake, but it looks like what I see in some greenscreen videos. I am really curious.
- aik 11y ago"EPIC’s “natural color” images of Earth are generated by combining three separate monochrome exposures taken by the camera in quick succession. EPIC takes a series of 10 images using different narrowband spectral filters -- from ultraviolet to near infrared -- to produce a variety of science products. The red, green and blue channel images are used in these color images. Combining three images taken about 30 seconds apart as the moon moves produces a slight but noticeable camera artifact on the right side of the moon. Because the moon has moved in relation to the Earth between the time the first (red) and last (green) exposures were made, a thin green offset appears on the right side of the moon when the three exposures are combined. This natural lunar movement also produces a slight red and blue offset on the left side of the moon in these unaltered images."
- gjm11 11y agoYou'd think they could be smarter about combining the R,G,B images. E.g., allow for the thing under each pixel to have moved a little from one image to the next, look at all their narrowband images (which will typically be strongly correlated, especially for nearby wavelengths) to estimate how fast each part of the image is moving, and then to get a pixel in the final image combine its G with slightly offset (maybe interpolated) R and B. Fiddly but hardly, er, rocket science. (Of course for some purposes you really need the unaltered R,G,B images. But if you're producing a single RGB JPEG image for public consumption, that's not one of those purposes.) [EDITED to add:] More difficult, I guess, is dealing with things that appear in only some of the planes. E.g., if G is taken last then there will be bits of Earth at the trailing edge of the moon in the G frame that have no counterparts in the R,B frames because the moon occluded them in those frames. So there will still be artefacts in the image. But I'd have thought they'd be less objectionable than the ones you get from just naively stacking the R, G, and B.
- jsingleton 11y agoThe probe that took this photo is the Deep Space Climate Observatory (DSCOVR) and it "was the first time a SpaceX rocket launched an object into deep space". http://spaceprob.es/dscovr/ http://spaceprob.es/dscovr/
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- UserRights 11y agoIt is really cool how the NASA gives us a better understanding of the universe and our place in it by publishing all these nice pictures. However, I would like to have one easy accessible source for all the nice pictures that is daily updated and could be synchronized to a local school server e.g. with rsync. Is there one "ḧere-are-all-the-pics"-ftp server anywhere? It is quite time consuming to browse the hundreds of NASA sites and download pictures manually - instead I would like to spend that time browsing a local incoming folder to select the best pictures. Would be a great service to the world to have easier access to these pictures.
- 2Pacalypse- 11y agoNot quite what you requested, but NASA's Astronomy Picture of the Day[1] is very cool. It has an archive dating back to the 1995! [1] - http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/
- leonardinius 11y agoThanks for sharing. I think I will spend next several hours digging through.
- mattlutze 11y agoCompletely unnecessary side note: It's run by one of my old professors[1]! The whole physics department at Michigan Tech is a cool little diamond in the middle of the Upper Peninsula rough. 1: http://www.phy.mtu.edu/faculty/Nemiroff.html http://www.phy.mtu.edu/faculty/Nemiroff.html
- _spoonman 11y agoWhat strikes me is the vastness of the oceans from above.
- Bohahahaha 11y ago"This is no moon!"
- oaktowner 11y agoWhat struck me about this was how huge the moon looks compared to the earth. We are used to seeing this as a small object in the sky (after all, it's 2000 miles across and 200000 miles away). But when viewed from afar...you're seeing an object with an 8K mi diameter and another with a 2K mi diameter, not that different in size at all. Which, I guess is another way to say: the earth just ain't that big.
- bpeebles 11y agoThese pictures were taken "only" 1,000,000 miles away, so the Moon is significantly closer to the camera than Earth was, which makes it appear larger compared to Earth than it really is. The true size comparison is more like [0]. The effect is also more because the [0] http://qph.is.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5bff56bc0b31f8b7395bdbe8cdd65a76 http://qph.is.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-5bff56bc0b31f8b7395bdbe...
- wlesieutre 11y agoThe relative sizes of objects in a photo like this will vary depending on whether you're close up and using a wider angle lens, compared to being far away with a very zoomy telephoto. It approaches an "apples to apples" size comparison asymptotically as you move infinitely far away with an infinitely zoomed lens. For a quick illustration: http://i.imgur.com/zME26IW.png http://i.imgur.com/zME26IW.png When you're up close, the moon obscures a much larger portion of the Earth, even though they're not changing size.
- jgalt212 11y agoEveryone gets excited about a journey to Mars (and other manned spaceflight ventures), but NASA's unmanned probes are far and and way the best science its done.
- kenbellows 11y agoHonest question: Why don't the clouds seen on Earth show any activity or movement over the course of this time lapse?
- LesZedCB 11y agoIt's only about 20 pictures at 30 second intervals each, which is only 10 minutes. From a million miles away, you wouldn't see noticeable changes in ten minutes. Much like when you are flying in a plane over the ocean and the waves look still.
- lyschoening 11y agoThe pictures were taken over 5 hours. You can see that the satellite is in a stationary position over the day side of earth.
- mxfh 11y agoThere definitely is some movement: Look at the fine features of the northern arm of the vortex in the South, they change quite a bit. Also, there are some clouds growing just east of the Gulf of California. [EDIT] As it's arguably hard to spot with the low frame rate and movement I uploaded a stabilized and sped up version. It's centered on a cloud patch in the Pacific. You can now clearly see a cloud west of it disappear as well as a lot of movement in that jet stream(?) next to it. http://i.imgur.com/Sg28xqu.gifv http://i.imgur.com/Sg28xqu.gifv (legacy GIF 8MB: http://i.imgur.com/Sg28xqu.gif http://i.imgur.com/Sg28xqu.gif) Closeup: http://i.imgur.com/wYfbnoU.gifv http://i.imgur.com/wYfbnoU.gifv
- Thiz 11y agoTake an orange and a lemon and separate them two yards away. That's how they'd look from space.
- happyscrappy 11y agoI always heard a basketball and a tennis ball 24ft apart.
- exodust 11y agoHere's what one million miles looks like side on...(whipped up in Photoshop) Best viewed at 100%. The image is more or less to scale. Scroll a million miles to the right to find moon and camera. (don't worry it's only a 300K jpeg) http://ozimg.s3.amazonaws.com/earth-moon-from-million-miles.jpg http://ozimg.s3.amazonaws.com/earth-moon-from-million-miles....
- markbnine 11y agoNice. Also THEMIS took a shot in 2001 as it was headed to Mars that captured this distance. http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/spaceimages/details.php?id=PIA00559 http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/spaceimages/details.php?id=PIA00559
- vinhboy 11y agoDang.. it never occurred to me how big the moon is. Looking at this picture, it's hard for me to comprehend why the moon would orbit the earth and not fall into the sun.
- Retric 11y agoIf you take the earth away the moon would still be orbiting the sun. So sure, the moon is far from the earth, but that just means it takes ~28 days to orbit the earth. PS: The moons orbit is actually 29.5 or 27.3 days depending on how you count it.
- Tuna-Fish 11y agoThe gravitational influence of the Sun on the Moon is greater than the gravitational influence of the Earth. In a very real way, the moon is orbiting the Sun. However, the orbit it flies around the Earth only very slightly modifies it's orbit around the Sun. The lunar orbital speed around the earth is ~1km/s, while the orbital speed around the sun is ~30km/s. That is, it never loops backwards on it's path around the sun, it's orbital velocity is at most only reduced by about 3%. Picture from wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Moon_trajectory1.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Moon_trajectory1.svg
- hybridtupel 11y agoThe only thing I could think about was Iron Sky busted :D
- ams6110 11y agoA lot of cool stuff on that site but annoying that they hijack the "back" button.
- stove 11y agoUnmanned NASA probes are Earth's selfie stick.
- xigency 11y agoThis looks unreal.
- Zaheer 11y agoHa! Love the image file name "epicearthmoonstill"! http://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/thumbnails/image/epicearthmoonstill.png http://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/thumbnails/image/epi...
- betimsl 11y agoOh good, there isn't a hidden civilization there. Whew.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Falcon9 11y agoThis is exactly the shot I've been hoping for since we got that first image of the Earth from DSCOVR. I tried to make an educated guess of how large the moon would appear from a million miles away, and I have to admit I far underestimated how large it would appear.