6 ms·
Cute idea. Needs a better example document to really be judged properly (for example, this document has a far too many large and imposing headings), but in any
by jacobolus 11y ago
Cute idea. Needs a better example document to really be judged properly (for example, this document has a far too many large and imposing headings), but in any case, some comments:
Would be better with less leading, a smaller text size, smaller left margin, and more characters per line. This current version has a text block more like a newspaper column width than a book, and the large type and unnecessarily generous leading (especially in block quotations!) make it feel a bit like a children’s book. Not much content fits on screen at any time.
Small caps shouldn’t be used with a typeface/browsers that don’t properly support them and just shrink capital letters instead, they just look spindly and bad. Either find a real small caps font, or skip the idea. Likewise for italics: use a real italic font instead of a browser-generated oblique version of the roman font.
If you want it to look like a nicely typeset book, use an indented first line for new paragraphs rather than a blank line.
Lots of other parts need tweaks, but it would take making several sample documents and then judging how the parts interact.
Final note: Tufte’s books don’t look good because of the basic style choices, but because of the incredible care and attention he puts into writing and composing them. Crappy content is not going to suddenly become amazing when a different stylesheet is slapped onto it, and any document that aspires to be as pretty as a Tufte book is going to take many hours of manual composition.
- jfb 11y agoI get why people want their web sites to look as good as Tufte's books, but since they can't, I wish they wouldn't try. Make things that look good in the medium you're working in; don't blindly copy the rules from other media.
- zach 11y agoFine advice for experts, surely. Those who recognize they are blind should copy. Copying Tufte seems like a reasonable way to open their eyes and save everyone else's.
- daveliepmann 11y agoI agree that design is medium-specific, but I think the idea of "looking as good as Tufte's books" is an underspecified one. Can a webpage be a better book than a book? No. Can a webpage be a better webpage by borrowing some ideas from books, then modifying those ideas to fit its own purposes? I think yes.
- sombremesa 11y agoI find that columns with smaller width and larger text are far more readable - any text that is the raison d'être for the page should be readable first, with worries about looking like a "children's book" becoming second concern. “Critics who treat 'adult' as a term of approval, instead of as a merely descriptive term, cannot be adult themselves. To be concerned about being grown up, to admire the grown up because it is grown up, to blush at the suspicion of being childish; these things are the marks of childhood and adolescence. And in childhood and adolescence they are, in moderation, healthy symptoms. Young things ought to want to grow. But to carry on into middle life or even into early manhood this concern about being adult is a mark of really arrested development. When I was ten, I read fairy tales in secret and would have been ashamed if I had been found doing so. Now that I am fifty I read them openly. When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up.” - C.S. Lewis
- unicornporn 11y ago> I find that columns with smaller width and larger text are far more readable The 55-75 CPL seems to stem from research done on readability on paper. 95 CPL seems more apt for the desktop browser when it comes to reading speed. When it comes to overall satisfaction the result is interesting. http://psychology.wichita.edu/surl/usabilitynews/72/LineLength.asp http://psychology.wichita.edu/surl/usabilitynews/72/LineLeng...
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoThat article is a bit suspect, since it found the max to be more readable. I would like to see what the curve is really like...how do lengths above 95 CPL begin to get harder to read?
- jacobolus 11y agoI don’t have anything against children’s books; I love children’s books! If the goal is to fit 2 sentences on a page with a big picture and individual letters that are easy to discriminate to help when just learning to read, then large text is a perfectly reasonable part of the design. Large widely spaced text is just not necessarily appropriate for other types of material, where fitting more text on the screen is an important design feature. This is especially relevant when we’re talking about Edward Tufte: Tufte devotes a huge portion of his books to emphasizing that information presentation is improved when more information is presented in a smaller space, to facilitate references and comparisons between different items/sections. “Information wants to be spatially adjacent so as facilitate comparisons made within the common eyespan of the viewer.” As a concrete comparison, here’s what fits in my browser view in this “Tufte CSS” document: http://imgur.com/iLNgoaU http://imgur.com/iLNgoaU Here’s what fits on a page in an Edward Tufte book: http://imgur.com/dTLcDx2 http://imgur.com/dTLcDx2
- alwillis 11y agoSmall caps shouldn’t be used with a typeface/browsers that don’t properly support them and just shrink capital letters instead, they just look spindly and bad. Either find a real small caps font, or skip the idea. Likewise for italics: use a real italic font instead of a browser-generated oblique version of the roman font. Totally agree. At least with italics, you can use CSS to instruct the browser to not create fake italics using the font-synthesis property: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/font-synthesis https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/font-synthe.... Also, setting the document font size to 11px is a bad idea for a whole lot of accessibility reasons. The current best practice is to leave the global font size at 100%, which in most browsers is 16px by default. This allows users to scale the type up (or down) as needed, unlike various versions of IE which won’t allow this if the base font-size is set in pixels. This allows the media queries to work correctly, since they always assume 1em = 16px. Resizing the fonts should be done in rems, with pixels as a fallback for non-supporting browsers.
- blwsk 11y agoI found this post useful regarding small caps. It seems as though if the typeface contains the glyphs and you're using Chrome or Safari, you can use font-feature-settings: "smcp" http://usabilitypost.com/2014/05/10/using-small-caps-and-text-figures-on-the-web/ http://usabilitypost.com/2014/05/10/using-small-caps-and-tex...
- daveliepmann 11y agoI agree regarding the example document. It's been troubling, because the fact of the matter is that those headings are legitimate, it's just that there's a mismatch between the goals of the description document and the goals of the kinds of documents that Tufte CSS is best suited for. I agree strongly with your idea of making several sample documents to experiment with. See https://github.com/daveliepmann/tufte-css/issues/26 https://github.com/daveliepmann/tufte-css/issues/26 I'll try to look into your points about leading, text size, and so on, but it would help a lot more if you could open a GH issue for them. As I've noted elsewhere in this thread, a real italic font has been added, and I'm considering what to do about small caps. To me it doesn't look so bad as-is. I don't want Tufte CSS to look like a nicely typeset book, and it would take a lot to convince me to indent the first line of new paragraphs. I find that repulsive on the web. Your last paragraph is gold. I wrote something similar about the table style earlier today. For me, I think this project is an exercise in making style choices using a rough template as a guiding star. I too worry that others will focus more on the finger than that star it is pointing at, by slapping this on top of existing content and calling it a day.