4 ms·
The question is, what do our defence contractors care more about: making their weapons actually work? Or merely selling them?
by potatolicious 17y ago
The question is, what do our defence contractors care more about: making their weapons actually work? Or merely selling them?
- vaksel 17y agoi'm sure lack of reliability is part of their business plan. You make the perfect humvee, and suddenly the army stops buying as many. There is a reason the AK47 is so much more reliable than the M16. And it's been out for like 60 years now.
- likpok 17y agoThe AK is more reliable because it is less accurate. The tolerances on the various mechanical parts are higher, but as a result they are looser.
- malkia 17y agoAK is the Perl of the weapons. I had to use AK-47 for year (serving in the Bulgarian army). It was easy to clean, assemble, disassemble, but every weapon was a bit-off due to the production (or heavy usage, don't know). So to get good results you have to learn where your weapon strays.
- roundsquare 17y agoHow much does that affect a user? I mean, if you take the time to learn how much it strays, are you at that point just as accurate as someone with a more accurate weapon? I've never used a gun so I'm curious.
- gaius 17y agoAll rifles do this a bit; snipers/designated marksmen get very accustomed to their personal weapons, and need to take time to re-acclimatize with any other rifle. For a regular line infantryman in a modern army who is mainly using his rifle for suppressive fire it doesn't significantly reduce his effectiveness.
- TallGuyShort 17y agoIn real close-to-mid-range combat, this matters even less (unless you're a marksman). It's rare that you'd have time to properly line up the sights and take one really good shot. What really matters in that situation is knock-down power, reliability, and the shooter's training.
- elblanco 17y agoThey are also stupid easy to manufacture. The design has been copied numerous times as well. Basically, they are the Honda Civics of military weapons. Cheap, easy to use, reliable, easy and cheap to fix when they do break, and lasts forever. I've seen AKs in 3rd world countries that were probably less than 20% original parts.
- rdtsc 17y agoThat's part of the design. Judging by the use and adoption of AK-47 I'd say it is a better weapon in general than M16. Usually an inacurate weapon is better than a stuck weapon when the soldier is facing an enemy.
- stcredzero 17y agoThe M16 would've been fine, if the brass hadn't skimped on the propellant.
- xsmasher 17y agoIf the AK fires fine with cheap powder, then that's another advantage for tightwad armies.
- bootload 17y ago"... There is a reason the AK47 is so much more reliable than the M16 ..." There is nothing worse than "language" or "editor" wars, except maybe arguments over "weapon of choice" ~ http://atwar.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/03/m16-vs-ak47-iraqi-viewpoints/ http://atwar.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/03/m16-vs-ak47-iraqi-...
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jimbokun 17y agoI could hardly find a single person in that discussion advocating for an M16 over an AK47.
- bootload 17y ago"... I could hardly find a single person in that discussion advocating for an M16 over an AK47. ..." I wouldn't expect too many combat vets to be hanging around HN (or the NYT blog). "... Becca: early issued M16 had jamming problems...by the time I got to Nam thing were worked out and the 16 wasa great piece ..." It's not wise to take the advice of non-experts, "Doc" is so I listen to him ~ http://www.flickr.com/photos/13184821@N07/4011451162/in/set-72157601943765946/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/13184821@N07/4011451162/in/set-... (read the comments)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 17y agoThe later is true. There is a large, high througput, revolving door between DoD and large contractors. Yesterday's generals are today's board members and C*Os of large defense contractors. When something is purchased, or a bid is chosen, it is often because of those conections not because a product is inherently better. The result is a lot of overpriced, under-performing equipment. The amount of waste is just ridiculous, even for a $650 billion market (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_United_States_federal_budget http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_United_States_federal_budg...).
- rarrrrrr 17y agoThis is also an apt description of the relationship between the FDA and large pharmaceutical companies. Also, the USDA and large food companies. There are likely many more examples. It's a systemic problem of our structure of government.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoit's not necessarily our structure of government. regulation (using the law to prevent certain economic activity rather than economic incentives) is always prone to falling under the influence of those it is trying to regulate. I believe it was taleb who compared financial regulation to a chess game between regulators and the regulated.
- roc 17y agoThe trick is: who better to run a military contractor than former military men? Who better to run a food company than someone who has worked in the USDA? These are natural career paths for those individuals that make perfect, natural sense and --in and of themselves-- aren't a real issue. The real issue is that our government can too easily reward individual companies or industry groups with hand-outs. If a single general couldn't essentially hand a contract to a supplier on his say-so, that supplier gains nothing by bribing them with a future board position. What we really need, is for it to be more difficult for individuals to drive contract selection and for the standards for passing a bailout, tariff or corporate welfare program to be much higher. Perhaps by requiring such legislation to be stand-alone bills, and requiring an oversight office to evaluate contract selection.
- stcredzero 17y agoImproper use of encryption has been a military problem forever. (I seem to recall problems even in Classical warfare.) It just gets bigger with more communication technology.