Y
HN Search
Hacker News Search
new
|
comments
|
top
|
jobs
grandalf
searching PlanetScale…
1.
▲
2.
▲
3.
▲
4.
▲
5.
▲
6.
▲
2386 ms
·
4741.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
I don't think you have refuted my speeding analogy. Do you ever drive in an area with ice on the roads? I recommend that you observe the phenomenon before you dismiss it. I do not think you have refuted my claim that regulation leads to p
4742.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Excellent point. You're right, a basic humility about the human ability to understand and control complicated systems is at the root of libertarian principles. I think it's somewhat absurd that Obama and Bush even pretend they can do anyt
4743.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
My point is just that a rational person generally uses his/her cognitive faculties to assess risk, but that regulation often leads to short-circuiting of critical thought. The heuristic becomes one of people believing that the government mu
4744.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
I may have inadvertantly replied to the wrong post...
4745.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Take the passage of Prop 8 in California -- libertarians do not think that marriage should be something that the state meddles in at all. Examples abound. I just mentioned one deregulation example because such things are often touted as li
4746.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Take slicehost or S3. To give you more RAM means that someone else has to need more CPU to make their virtualization strategy work. I think once Amazon got enough volume it could begin offering high CPU and high RAM instances without dimi
4747.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
I consider the government one of those "large, centralized power structures". It has its pluses and minuses. At present I pay it thousands of dollars every month to help fund a massive war in the middle east and an enormous bailout of Wal
4748.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
One example that is often cited is the so-called "deregulation" of energy markets. There was not actually deregulation. The markets were still highly regulated, so the act of deregulating part of them threw the whole system out of whack an
4749.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Capitalism and human nature tell us that lobbying and corruption will be a consequence of regulation. Libertarians simply realize that regulations are not just the "grand vision" that they are presented as... they create winners and losers
4750.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Balanced by who? Jesus? Greenspan? Paulson? Bush? Obama?
4751.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Why is perfect information required? If I walk into a bank and consider depositing my hard earned cash, perhaps I'd demand enough transparency to determine whether to trust that entity with my cash, in exactly the same way that I must trust
4752.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
I'm arguing that a paper seatbelt is a deception. Metaphorically, if you know a car doesn't have a seatbelt you'll drive more cautiously, or possibly have a seatbelt installed that you know works. In other words, you'll use your cognitive
4753.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Not at all. In an environment where the government decides what is prudent, there is no incentive for a bank to say "We are sounder than our competitors because we keep more reserves". Why not? Because they would be competing against the
4754.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Speed limit signs set a minimum and a maximum speed, yet I always see drivers careening along on icy roads at the posted maximum. They must have more faith in planners than I do, as I try to determine how icy the road is and go at a safe s
4755.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
True, but have you ever been driving on an icy road and seen people going the speed limit, 55 miles per hour? The psychology people seem to have is to believe that if the government regulates it, then anything that falls under the regulatio
4756.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
I don't think you offer any evidence to support your point. I'd argue the opposite, that a big, opaque regulatory state is the perfect environment for corruption.
4757.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Libertarians generally tend toward a property rights framework to handle things like this, as opposed to a "greater good" framework. In other words, if you put toxic waste on your property, that's fine UNLESS it leaks onto someone else's pr
4758.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
You seem to be getting caught up in the most extreme version of libertarianism. Consider this: If more big problems were solved in various ways at the state level, there would be COMPETITION and government might be BIGGER in some areas and
4759.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
Libertarians do not oppose this stuff, they merely want to consider other approaches. I think pollution can be dealt with purely from a property rights framework, not a greater good framework. Again, this is a low priority issue, and the t
4760.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
I think the meat of your comment is in the story about how Citibank's failure makes it harder for you to find a job. First, note that if it weren't for regulators deciding on the amount of reserve capital Citibank was required to hold, the
4761.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
When you cross the street at a traffic light, do you look at the color of the light and immediately propel yourself into the intersection? Or do you take a few seconds to glance from left to right to make sure that there isn't a vehicle ca
4762.
▲
A Defense of libertarianism (and response to Zed, etc.)
90 points
by
grandalf
18y ago
|
175 comments
4763.
▲
by
grandalf
18y ago
my main projects go in /home/myusername/ and the rest go in /home/myusername/projects/ and stuff that I'll delete soon goes in /home/myusername/test
4764.
▲
by
grandalf
19y ago
Maybe the reason Google is getting the most mobile traffic from the iPhone is b/c gmail for mobile is still not as good as the built-in Blackberry email client!
4765.
▲
by
grandalf
19y ago
are you guys still using Nuance?