Y
HN Search
Hacker News Search
new
|
comments
|
top
|
jobs
aldarion
searching PlanetScale…
1.
▲
2.
▲
3.
▲
4.
▲
5.
▲
6.
▲
19 ms
·
61.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Yeah, the article is bullshit. Serbian Wikipedia is far worse in that regard.
62.
▲
Basic mistakes in worldbuilding a feudal monarchy
(mythicscribes.com)
2 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
1 comments
63.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
World doesn't consist of historians and animals, you know. Most people are not historians and (unfortunately) get their "historical" "education" from popular culture. Hence, articles like this matter.
64.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
"where men would be rounded up and marched off against their will to die" That is the thing, however - they weren't, at least not in feudal system. Peasants would be present only as personal servants of nobility, but weren&#x
65.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Point wasn't that it was never used, though, but that it wouldn't have been the first choice. But yeah, bit of a weird wording.
66.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Castle garrisons were small. Even a large-ish castle probably didn't have garrison larger than 25 - 30. And food doesn't take that much space either. Consider how Age of Sail ships would spend months at sea without resupply, and h
67.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Precisely. First World War has fundamentally changed our society - including our attitude towards the war.
68.
▲
Modern misconceptions about medieval warfare
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
78 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
66 comments
69.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
I really hope we never do get there...
70.
▲
Fantasy Anime – Noragami
(fantasyview.wordpress.com)
2 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
71.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Didn't know that there was anyone arguing it doesn't, but... nice article.
72.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
So what are best forums for discussing anime and similar? I found AnimeVice and that's it.
73.
▲
Galley vs. Sailing Ship in Combat
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
1 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
74.
▲
Navy in Middle Earth
(fantasyview.wordpress.com)
1 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
75.
▲
18th Century Ship of the Line
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
2 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
76.
▲
Numenorean Defensive Works
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
2 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
77.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
He didn't. He was in fact quite clear that Lord of the Rings was inspired in large part by his experiences in the First World War: Dead Marshes especially, but also Sauron and Saruman and their forces of industrialization.
78.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Agreed. Still, said narrow slice of fantasy is often in love with plate armor, which coexisted with gunpowder.
79.
▲
Why Fantasy Avoids Gunpowder
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
34 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
108 comments
80.
▲
Stupid Fantasy Armors
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
4 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
81.
▲
Fantasy Weapons – Red Queen from DMC4
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
1 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
82.
▲
Building Fantasy Army – Dwarves
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
1 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
83.
▲
Designing Army of Fantasy Elves
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
1 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
84.
▲
Building a Fantasy Army
(warfantasy.wordpress.com)
2 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
1 comments
85.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Rest of the series: https://warfantasy.wordpress.com/2023/08/07/building-a-fanta... https://warfantasy.wordpress.com/2023/08/08/building-a-fanta... https://warfantas
86.
▲
Laptop vs. Desktop
(butterbinn.wordpress.com)
2 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
1 comments
87.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
ASOIAF is a postmodernist cynical take on fantasy. But that does not mean it is realistic. In fact, it is less so than Lord of the Rings.
88.
▲
Luigi Cadorna
(acoup.blog)
1 points
by
aldarion
3y ago
|
0 comments
89.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
I have found that the main prerequisite for a successful adaptation is finding the people who love the original work. Just read up on how much influence Sir Christopher Lee had on Lord of the Rings movies.
90.
▲
by
aldarion
3y ago
Tolkien was actually the master of fridge logic... and fridge horror. Martin describes everything in detail... with Tolkien, he only hints at things, but when you understand things he is hinting at... let's just say that Middle Earth h
More ›