7 ms·
One Way to Fight California's Drought: Desalt the Ocean
- pbreit 11y agoCan't we find something a little more natural like capturing more rain water before it goes into the ocean? Edit: there's plenty of rain water. http://www.forbes.com/sites/ashoka/2015/04/15/why-does-california-let-billions-of-gallons-of-fresh-water-flow-straight-into-the-ocean/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/ashoka/2015/04/15/why-does-calif...
- jebblue 11y agoOur HOA has a rule against collecting rain water. I remember a man in Oregon a few years ago got jail time for refusing to remove his rainwater bins.
- pbreit 11y agoI'm guessing there's a reason and possibly even a good one. Care to take a crack at it?
- FooBarWidget 11y agoI think that's called a river. And it's running dry.
- alwaysdoit 11y agoThat's what we normally do. The failure case we have encountered, however, is sometimes there isn't any rain.
- KaiserPro 11y agoThat and cheaper too. http://www.notechmagazine.com/2015/06/water-johads-a-low-tech-alternative-to-mega-dams-in-india.html http://www.notechmagazine.com/2015/06/water-johads-a-low-tec... LA has a drainage system that tries to get water out to the sea as fast as possible. If the water is not hanging around, its not going to evaporate. So no clouds to be blown inland. Evaporating water takes energy, which lowers ambient temperature, etc. Johads are dirt cheap, simple and effective. The basic premise is you put in half moon banks every n 100 meters. The idea is that it keeps back a certain amount of water. Excess water overflows into the same channels as before, so there is no risk of flooding. Failing that, solar stills are much cheaper than reverse-osmosis to build, and in south California with loads of sun cheap and effective. However you still have to transport the water.
- skaevola 11y agoHow do you deal with mosquitos?
- m_samuel_l 11y agoWe deploy spiders
- chc 11y agoThere's lots of rainwater in aggregate if you look at very large areas, but I'm not sure if collecting rainwater over a huge area is necessarily more practical than desalination. I honestly haven't studied the matter, but judging from the fact that this guy's credentials seem to amount to "Has planted a bunch of trees," I'm unsure how much of an expert he is either. He says it isn't being pushed because there isn't any industry behind it, but that seems to be begging the question. Why is no one taking this field by storm if it's actually a more practical solution? Why isn't he making money hand over fist doing this? The disconnect between the reality he suggests and the reality we observe makes me doubtful about whether this is actually a more realistic approach than desal.
- mturmon 11y agoWow, you opened a lot of boxes. Lipkis is actually much more than a guy that planted a bunch of trees. His organization, and a couple of others like FOLAR (https://folar.org https://folar.org), have been changing the way the city of LA approaches storm water. As a nearby comment mentions, building regulations had been designed to convey rain water to the sea as fast as possible, due to a justified fear of floods. At the micro level, this means diverting rain water to concrete channels (e.g., streets or drainage channels). For instance, when I put in a building in my back yard, I had to install a pump to pump the water from a tank filled by the rooftop gutter into the street, rather than letting it soak in to my yard. Now, multiply that by millions, and you can see we're wasting a lot of water. Changing the whole conception of storm water ("collect and dispose of" -> "disperse and soak in") involves changing building codes and city/county/state infrastructure practices. Because ground water is all externalities, there is no ready market solution.
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoWhy is no one taking this field by storm if it's actually a more practical solution? Because there isn't as much money in it as in ginormous megaprojects? E.g. the "train to nowhere"[1] in California had the support of a Teamster leader because: The legislators in Sacramento got it right when they voted to fund this project since it will help hundreds of people find good union jobs and his quote continues and the high speed rail line will provide a viable alternative to car and plane travel in the state. I don't think that HSR from Madera California to Bakersfield California will be a "viable alternative" to anything. Follow the money.[2]: a catchphrase ... which suggests a money trail or corruption scheme within high (often political) office. Same with water. Too many dollars at stake, and too many special interests, for simple commonsense solutions to be "practical". [1] http://www.laweekly.com/news/california-bullet-train-to-nowhere-gets-6-billion-via-state-lawmakers-2386440 http://www.laweekly.com/news/california-bullet-train-to-nowh... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Follow_the_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Follow_the_money
- InclinedPlane 11y agoStep 1 should be upgrading water treatment facilities into water recycling facilities.
- mc32 11y agoWhatever happened to the idea of tugging broken off icebergs as source of freshwater. It could lessen the impact on rising seas, to some extent. Desalting of course would lessen it too. perhaps neither would be enough to counteract the overall melting. But both can address droughts.
- j-pb 11y ago> It could lessen the impact on rising seas, to some extent And where do you think that water goes, after it has been put on the fields?
- kaybe 11y agoIce bergs are nearly neutral as far as water level goes, since they displace about the volume of water they contain (if melted). If all the sea ice melts, the sea will rise on the order of mm. (I have the calculations around somewhere if you want details.) The problem is the ice currently located on land.
- j-pb 11y agoEven in it has an almost neutral effect, it still doesn't lessen the effect of rising seas.
- timdierks 11y agoI've always wondered why desalination is so hard. From a thermodynamics perspective, dissolving salt into water isn't particularly enthalpic (the water doesn't get warmer when you do it), so it's never been clear what the fundamental challenges to reversing that dissolution are. It's surprising there isn't some chemical reaction to precipitate out the sodium and chloride atoms bonded to something else, or whatever.
- aqme28 11y agoFrom a thermodynamic perspective, un-mixing two mixed things always requires energy.
- timdierks 11y agoFrom a first-law standpoint, how can it fundamentally require more energy than is released by mixing them?
- nanofortnight 11y agoThere are [multiple desalination methods](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination). My favourite is [reverse osmosis](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_osmosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_osmosis), though it does cost about $1.2 per cubic meter of water. To answer your question, ion exchangers do what you ask, using sulfuric acid and sodium hydroxide, and produce a ton of sodium sulfate in the resulting desalinated water.
- stephengillie 11y agoElectrolysis is a rather energy-intensive desalinization method.
- chadgeidel 11y agoI always assumed the big question was "where do you put the brine"? (forget the name of the by-product of desalination) Do you dump it back into the sea? I don't actually know.
- gus_massa 11y ago
- bradleyjg 11y agoAs I said the last time this came up: It makes no sense at all to pay $2k an acre-foot for desalinated water in a state where millions of acre-feet are being used to grow alfalfa that sells for less than $400 per acre-foot of water consumed. This isn't a lack of water problem, it is an poor governance problem.
- maratd 11y ago> it is an poor governance problem No, it's a poor pricing problem. The price of water should be directly related to the cost of delivery and supply. Unfortunately, virtually everywhere, you are merely charged for the cost of delivery. If we tie the price of water to something like rainfall, we'll all be much better off. Inefficient use of water will disappear very quickly.
- rodgerd 11y ago> Inefficient use of water will disappear very quickly Yeah, I'm sure that will have no public health consequences whatsoever.
- Terr_ 11y agoWhat exactly are you dancing about here? Are you seriously trying to imply that people won't wash their hands because they're worried about the cost? If the water-shortage is already so bad that it could cause prices like that for individuals, then you've already got a problem that'll cause health issues.
- studentrob 11y agoWater is subsidized because it is considered a human right.
- Terr_ 11y agoYes... and? Subsidizing water for individuals who need to drink and wash? Sure, I can get behind that. However, that's totally different than granting similar rights and subsidies to acres of cash-crops and chemical-refineries!
- clumsysmurf 11y agoI recently read about a project in the Hudson Valley, where United Water would use desalination to draw water from the Hudson river. Most of the negatives / cons I have heard before (impact on wildlife, where to discharge brine, energy, etc) ... but one thing stood out: "Haverstraw Bay is polluted with contaminated sediments, sewage and urban runoff, and the plant’s intakes would be approximately 3.5-miles from Entergy’s Indian Point nuclear power plant, which releases radionuclides to the Hudson." I guess many people are concerned that (1) the technology to remove these pollutants either does not exist, or is very expensive and (2) being a privatized water company, it may put profits over water quality. My question then, is what kinds of things are in sea water that should ideally be removed beside salt? What is more contaminated source.. sea water, or water from land based sources?
- maratd 11y agoJust as aside, I've dealt with quite a few utilities and United Water is by far the best among them. They are an excellent company.
- vilhelm_s 11y agoI was curious how much radionuclides are in the water. Apparently, "nuclear plants typically release between a few curies and one thousand curies per year of tritium in liquid effluents; releases of mixed fission and activation products are much smaller (in the range from 0.001 to 0.01 curies per year)."[1] For comparison, it seems a glowing tritium keyring contains 0.4 curies.[2] One thousand curies would be 0.104 grams of tritium. Also, there is an online database for this! [3] E.g., if I read it correctly, in 2008, Indian Point 1,2 released 0.09 Ci of liquid effluvents. (No tritium in the table?) [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK201991/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK201991/ [2] http://depletedcranium.com/my-attempt-to-import-tritium-key-chains/ http://depletedcranium.com/my-attempt-to-import-tritium-key-... [3] http://www.reirs.com/effluent/EDB_Main.asp?l=n http://www.reirs.com/effluent/EDB_Main.asp?l=n
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoThat's just crazy. Rewind 130 years and you find a handful of reservoirs, some tunnels and viaducts, and gravity. That's all you need to provide some of the country's finest drinking water to 8 million people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_york_city_water_supply https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_york_city_water_supply People were smarter then, because the technology didn't exist for them to be so stupid.
- Havoc 11y agoThis is one of the reasons I'm hoping fusion gets off the ground fast. Oceans + Lots of power is a decent recipe for fixing humanities fresh water problem.
- oehokie 11y ago(It's called desalination) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desalination
- bozoUser 11y agoWhen did desalination become cheaper? Saudi Arabia can be afford it because of the petro money but how about United States and reading the env. impacts not sure which way to look for water.