7 ms·
Wasn't that historically how laws have changed? More particularly, the people want this. Because the people like it. The economy is rough for everyone outside
by Swizec 11y ago
Wasn't that historically how laws have changed?
More particularly, the people want this. Because the people like it. The economy is rough for everyone outside Silicon Valley right now and they love the fact that with some hustling they can make a good side income. Any company that helps people make money will be loved by people and when the people pressure the government, that's a very powerful thing.
Remember, Al Capone was loved by the people because he funneled a lot of his money into helping the poor and funding soup kitchens and things like that. That made it much much harder for the government to take him out.
But unlike Al Capone, who was considered a gangster and a crook even by the people who loved him, the sharing economy is seen as morally good. People think they should be able to rent out their apartment whenever they want. They think they should be able to give people rides and so on. These companies are doing nothing wrong in the eye of the people, they only laws they are breaking are bureaucratic laws. Which are the kind of laws people break all the time anyway.
Not saying those laws don't exist for a reason, because they do. But they've been in effect for so long that the reason has fallen out of the public conscience and people don't understand why these "outdated" laws shouldn't be broken.
At the end of the day, taxis don't drive around London with a bale of hay in their trunk like they're supposed to.
I may have trailed off there, my point is that in the eye of the masses, these companies are doing the right thing. And that's powerful.
- zajd 11y agoYes, some laws are silly. Worker protections though? I don't think there's much to cheer about when the reason many of these sharing companies are so profitable is because they basically eliminate using employees for their "unskilled"(read: job markets with an excess of employable people) labor. Also I would dispute that people(edit: this is basically impossible to prove, it'd be nice to see some data) see the sharing economy as "morally good". I certainly don't. Not because I don't think people should be allowed to share, but because I don't think corporations should be able to 1099 what are obviously employees in order to cut costs. edit. I guess I'm getting downvoted because worker protections actually are considered a bad thing here? smh
- jlarocco 11y agoI agree with you, and I think companies are abusing the word "sharing." If I lend my neighbor a tool, that's sharing. If I bring cookies in to work and put them in the break room for everybody, that's sharing. If I visit a website, order something and pay for it, then it's not sharing - it's ordering a product or service. I don't care who actually owns the car or the room.
- icebraining 11y agoWhich worker protections? AirBnB has no unskilled labor, and Uber is replacing an industry where the workers were already contractors with no benefits - in fact, an industry where workers had to rent medallions to work. Which companies are eliminating employees?
- zajd 11y agohttp://www.vox.com/2014/6/10/5785928/the-democratization-of-butlers http://www.vox.com/2014/6/10/5785928/the-democratization-of-... I specifically mentioned AirBnB is not one of the companies screwing their employees in the name of profits, but Uber/TaskRabbit/etc most certainly are. As far as "well, it's better than what existed" w/r/t Uber, It's still illegal. http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-and-lyft-employee-lawsuits-could-change-business-models-2015-6 http://www.businessinsider.com/uber-and-lyft-employee-lawsui...
- icebraining 11y agoAs far as "well, it's better than what existed" w/r/t Uber, It's still illegal. ... in California. In any case, I was disagreeing with the claim that they are "eliminate using employees". Not using employees was already the status quo, so Uber couldn't eliminate it if they wanted to.
- zajd 11y agoI guess that depends if you consider Uber some kind of brand new business type or just a lower class limo service combined with a taxi dispatch. Because there are plenty of drivers out there that do receive benefits, even if Taxi drivers aren't one of them.
- 542458 11y ago> the people A certain subset of the people want this. Others (such as those in areas where rent and property prices have been driven up by AirBNB) don't. > These companies are doing nothing wrong in the eye of the people I've only rented an AirBNB place once, and when I did one of the neighbours gave me a blast about how having new people going in and out of the AirBNB rented apartment was disturbing his peace and the security of his own apartment. I can understand his viewpoint, and I doubt he's alone in it. I'm not saying that AirBNB is right or wrong, and I get where you're coming from - I just think you're oversimplifying the complexities of public opinion on the matter.
- pron 11y ago> But they've been in effect for so long that the reason has fallen out of the public conscience and people don't understand why these "outdated" laws shouldn't be broken. Sometimes that's the case and sometimes it isn't, and, as others have noted, it is not at all clear that "the people" want the sharing economy. The question is whether the law should be changed by breaking it first. I'm not saying it's always morally wrong, but I sometimes find it amusing to see VCs, accelerators etc. be somehow nonchalant about their companies breaking those laws while at the same time being completely livid and unforgiving if you dare to break their own. I don't mind general irreverence towards any kind of law in general, but discounting state/city laws while taking your own rules extremely seriously seems to express a certain disrespect towards the population at large, as if saying "their laws don't matter but ours do because unlike theirs, our rules are logical because they're made by smart people; theirs are stupid or irrelevant relics".