10 ms·
Google is really good at being Google. A drop-in replacement for Google would need to be better at being Google than Google is, and I don't see that happening.
by simonh 11y ago
Google is really good at being Google. A drop-in replacement for Google would need to be better at being Google than Google is, and I don't see that happening.
The way to compete with them is through asymmetric warfare. Compete in such a way that they can't effectively fight back. For example pick off one (or a few) of their products and differentiate like crazy. Apple got stuck in a situation where they neede their own maps service. That's cost the badly because they're goign head-to-head, but at least they have the advantage of leveraging their ownership of the iOS platform. Meanwhile they're trying to differentiate by using an aerial 3D view instead of streetview, and now coming out with a competing local search service to streetview without it being just a clone. Duck-Duck-go competes with Google Search on privacy. Facebook competed by being completely unlike anything Google produced at the time.
Trying to beat Google at their own game is a failing strategy. Microsoft tried it with Bing search and Bing Maps, but just can't differentiate effectively. Look at how Apple competes with Microsoft. Received wisdom for decades was that Apple should make itself more like Microsoft to compete with them, but in the end their success has been based on what they do differently, not on what they do that's the same.
- feelix 11y agoWith google's recent bias towards becoming more and more product oriented in their first page of results (which is good for their bottom line), alongside their tendency to become worse for academic purposes over time (for example making it so that searching for things in quotes doesn't actually return only exact results), they have left a gap for an unbiased and exact search engine for power users and geeks to come in. Google are not perfect. It's hard to compete with their sheer processing power and the size of their databases, however storage is getting cheaper and processing power is getting more abundant. It may not be feasible to compete with them head on at present, but during the coming years the likelihood of them maintaining their dominant position decreases with time, it doesn't increase. Since the question is "whether there WILL be a full replacement for google" in short I would say most certainly - the question is how long it will take. I would be astonished if google were still the dominant search engine 20 years from now. 10 years? Even that would be a surprise.
- jpatokal 11y agoBut is storage getting cheaper and processing power getting more abundant faster than the size and complexity of the Internet is growing? Because if not, Google will keep winning.
- V-2 11y ago> Trying to beat Google at their own game is a failing strategy. I don't think Microsoft ever even dreamed of actually BEATING Google with Bing... Realistically speaking all they wanted was to mitigate their dependence on Google services... and stealing SOME market share. They probably hoped for more than they actually got at the end (especially outside of the US, where Bing isn't doing that great), but I find it difficult to believe they expected catching up with Google, much less beating them