4 ms·
What do you consider to be "Google"? The search engine? Google Maps? The advertising company? Google Ventures? Heroku? GoogleDocs? Or the whole crazy self-drivi
by bigiain 11y ago
What do you consider to be "Google"? The search engine? Google Maps? The advertising company? Google Ventures? Heroku? GoogleDocs? Or the whole crazy self-driving cars, automatically launched wind turbine kites, GoogleWave, Project Loon, and every other successful or spectacular failure they've been involved in?
Will anybody ever "own" all the market slices Google currently plays in? I _very_ much doubt it.
Will the Google Search engine remain an effective monopoly? I doubt that too - I remember when Alta Vista was world-changingly amazing! I suspect Google have deeply entrenched themselves in the employment market for people being very smart about making search better, and the bar is way higher so I doubt it's ever going to be a couple of compsci/linguistics phd students who topple the industry (the way Alta Vista fell), but things like DuckDuckGo and Blekko exist - and no doubt other more academic and less well know ones too, it not impossible (in my opinion) that someone will roll out a "instantly and obviously better than Google" search engine one day.
- biot 11y agoSmall correction: Heroku is owned by Salesforce.com.
- bigiain 11y agoIndeed - I was thinking "App Engine" but my fingers typed "Heroku"
- fenesiistvan 11y agoOn the contrary, I feel the exact opposite: the entry bar for the search engine market is not high. Google delivered a good service from the first day, which was not improved so much since them. A newcomer have to reach only this quality and combine it with some spice, like P2P and it can reach a big market share. Although some revolutionary improvement in the search result offerings wouldn't hurt also but this has less chance (waiting for a better AI).
- mahouse 11y ago>the entry bar for the search engine market is not high You just need millions of computers, millions of petabytes of net traffic and a lot of time to have the same index as Google. Easy. For example, look at how useless Bing is. And that's Microsoft!
- kzhahou 11y agoI bet if you forced yourself to use Bing, and weren't turned off by its look and feel, you'd find it to be an equal replacement. In fact, I don't have to bet: both companies have detailed metrics that consistently show them within a few percent of each other on precision, recall, etc.
- bigiain 11y agoI suspect this in not only true, but a highly likely factor in whatever "replaces" both Google and Bing. Prediction: some near-future Snowden document release will catapult DuckDuckGo or some other privacy-oriented search alternative into the limelight in a hockeystick curve growth kind of way. Maybe something that proves the NSA is firehose sharing de-anonymised Google/Bing search data with HealthCare Companies or the Insurance Industry or the IRS, and that there's widespread punitive action going on based on simplistic or poorly thought out responses to people's search history (people being denied health insurance because they did a few too many Google searches when their mother was diagnosed with cancer, or car insurance rates being raised across the board for people who search wine labels online...) All of a sudden someone who's "good enough" at search, but has TOR hidden service endpoints and nothing associated with them that comes under Five Eyes legal jurisdictions is going to look worthwhile switching to.
- icebraining 11y agoI'm willing to bet that no significant (say, 10%) portion of the Google/Bing userbase will switch to an alternative engine in the next five years, regardless of whatever documents may be released. If some revelation like that were to happen, people would be outraged, they'd demand regulation, and meanwhile they'd continue to use Google/Bing; maybe some would switch to Incognito windows, but that's about it, in my opinion.
- Xophmeister 11y agoIsn't Heroku a subsidiary of SalesForce? Google's equivalent is Google App Engine.
- staunch 11y agoWhen Google Search is superseded Google will have no money and necessarily implode. Their services will be sold or spun off. The entire empire is built on a single point of failure.