5 ms·
Well your argument isn't exactly strong either. What is "socially necessary abstract labor-time"? You didn't say why did you start debunking his confused theori
by yread 17y ago
Well your argument isn't exactly strong either. What is "socially necessary abstract labor-time"? You didn't say why did you start debunking his confused theories from this point. Wikipedia says:
The simplest definition of socially necessary labour time is the amount of labour time performed by a worker of average skill and productivity, working with tools of the average productive potential, to produce a given commodity.
but none of the examples you gave actually are comodities. Somebody would have to pay for them - obviously that's possible but lets see how:
Pasteurization is an invention - the patent system is at least as flawed as Marx's theories
Creating GMail - software patents QED
Picasso - work of art, copyrights, again a very hot topic even now
Besides is it such a central point anyway?
Obviously his theories led to people dying. Then again without the threat of communism we would be probably still forced to work without unions, without social and health security and a million of other beneficial things.
How can you judge Marx's contribution to history only negatively as a "no friend of humanity" is beyond me.
You cannot see the world around you just in black and white!
- CWuestefeld 17y agoMarx's work predates the marginal revolution, so he can't be personally faulted for not understanding concepts like marginally decreasing utility. But at least as I understand his work, much rest on his association of labor with value. And if you want to focus only on commodities, well, this is where the effect of marginal utility is most pronounced. And since marginal utility pretty much destroys the relationship between labor and value, it should be sufficient to discredit Marx's economics. (not that this is the only argument) without the threat of communism we would be probably still forced to work without unions... I can't imagine how you built such an idea. Particularly since unions in particular are fundamentally communist.