5 ms·
Just a personal observation, the instruments that are typically identified as "endangered," are all ridiculously hard to learn as an adult, even if you've playe
by analog31 11y ago
Just a personal observation, the instruments that are typically identified as "endangered," are all ridiculously hard to learn as an adult, even if you've played another instrument. Bassoon has bizarre fingerings compared to the other woodwinds. Viola has that damned clef. Double bass is physically dangerous to play. French horn is just hard.
- EvanAnderson 11y agoI'd agree re: the bassoon being "ridiculously hard to learn". I've never considered myself a good woodwind player, but at the point I tried to learn bassoon I'd played a reasonable amount of saxophone (alto and tenor) and clarinet. None of that prepared me for the oddness and difficult of the bassoon. I found it to be a supremely unrewarding instrument to attempt to learn (albeit I recognize that I'm the kind of person who is quick to give up if I don't feel like I'm making any progress at something). My instructor told me that I'd likely need to learn to make my own reeds, too. That wasn't something that made me any more enthusiastic for the instrument.
- mattlutze 11y agoOn top of different fingerings, it's tough when the instrument isn't one of the "cute" ones, like big cats and other mammals getting more attention from conservation efforts. Its inability to find a home with a lot of popular genres over the last hundred or so years has let it fall further from the public consciousness, and its tonal sweet spot being so low means it can't easily slide into the parts written for other more pop-friendly instruments. It's a bit harsh as well, when we're comparing to alto saxophones and clarinets and such. I learned it and played it for years growing up and loved the bassoon. (For what it's worth, I also cut my fingers on a viola before that, so I may just have made a point to pick the odd instruments.) I'd certainly like to see it revived or even see it find a niche in modern music. I'm just not sure where that would be.
- jboggan 11y agoBizarre fingerings and a lot of very unstable harmonics scattered throughout. You can't just hit the fingerings and expect the right pitches to come out, a lot of the notes (F# below middle C in particular) take throat contortions to get the note to land in tune, and of course you're changing this as you are fingering different pitches. Not to mention the challenges of quickly tonguing passages with a chunk of heavy cane in your mouth. The unstable pitches do tend to develop a young musician's ear mightily though. It's an instrument that forms an odd bond as well; I recently met another bassoonist and we dropped everything we were doing to make reeds together.
- cturner 11y agoI was thinking about clefs recently. Why are we so fixed on two clefs? All that a clef needs to do is to indicate (a) where the G is and (b) which octave it is in. When I play with ideas I just put a 'x' on the G line with a superscript 4 next to it. Music theory could be taught in a way so that students learnt to find the G as a matter of course. But for some reason we've been beaten into thinking in terms of these two clefs. It might have something to do with the way a conductor reads full-score. With typesetting technology it should be mess important to have conductor and accompanist on the same clef. We're not far from a point where everything could move to e-ink. It'll probably take another century for music libraries to have been completely moved to digital.
- cynicalkane 11y agoI've played the violin and the viola. If you're a violinist you can get a good sound out of the viola after literally a few minutes of practice. Reading the viola clef is strictly less difficult than reading the transposing clefs used by brass and winds. I don't know what "the double bass is physically dangerous to play" means. If you mean you can get RSI from it, you can do that on any instrument.
- mveety 11y agoWhen the strings on a Bass go, they really go. I've been hurt once or twice from strings breaking.
- analog31 11y agoThat's true. And approaches to each instrument, to avoid injury, have become a pretty mainstream part of teaching. I actually suspect that bass isn't all that endangered, and that it has had somewhat of a resurgence. There were quite a few kids playing bass at the school string concerts that my kids play in. Of course bass has the problem of being every parent's nightmare due to its size. ;-) For me, the endangered-ness of the bass, at the time, was a blessing because it meant that I could serve a role in an ensemble without being a virtuoso.
- rwmj 11y agoEven common musical instruments have terrible user interfaces. I only realized this after playing with a Tenori-On[1] which is really easy to pick up and make music on. Making music doesn't need to be hard and shouldn't require thousands of hours of practice. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenori-on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenori-on
- gtani 11y agoHmm, yes, there's VST's, ribbon controllers, ableton Push and the samplers, arpeggiators and sequencers builtin to DAWs and many synths. And Max for Live is amazing. I have devoted thousands of hours voluntarily as an adult to guitar, mandolin, clarinet, violin and viola, among others (after many years of involuntary music lessons as a kid), I think it's worthwhile, but there's definitely a trend to using e.g. drum VST's in recordings in such a way that it's hard to discern that they're not live drum tracks.
- gtani 11y agoI've tried most of the non-brass instruments: alto clef, not that hard to transpose to anybody that's able to read a piano's grand staff. Tenor clef does require work, and reading, say a Bach chorale in SATB, oof. But violists seem to have a high incidence of injury (i have never played one bigger than 15" Cello and especially double bass do require buildup of strength in the left hand, and fingers start high and come flying down onto the string (composite winds have a lot less tension than steel tho). French horn embouchure and intonation are hard, as you say.
- vacri 11y agoWhen I was 10 years old, my school required us to learn an instrument. I selected the bassoon, because 'no-one plays the bassoon!'. Lasted less than a week - my little hands couldn't reach around the instrument to do the correct fingerings...