3 ms·
Interesting read, two things stand out for me, one is that the ship breaking in India/Pakistan/Bangledesh is not cost competitive given what seems like no, or v
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Interesting read, two things stand out for me, one is that the ship breaking in India/Pakistan/Bangledesh is not cost competitive given what seems like no, or very little (note the comment about cementing an area) investment in the facilities.
And the second is the huge export boosts from China in iron and steel. (alleged in the article to be below cost but there wasn't really any support for that argument.)
Any insights on why companies doing ship breaking wouldn't invest at least some of the returns into their own facilities? I could understand if it was a sort of "one and done" thing where you never expected to break a second ship, but since they suggest there is 30 years of experience here, what is the process whereby people don't figure out ways to do it better/more efficiently/safer? I would expect that eventually this would be an ideal robotics sort of application (assuming you are ok with a mobile robot carrying around a plasma torch :-)
As for China, their behavior has been consistent over the last 50 years at least, which is that acquiring foreign currency reserves are more important than profits. They still import a lot of "stuff" so that is going to be critical to economic growth. There is a long tradition of exporting natural resources to fund those reserves, whether it is Russian's oil, or South Africa's mineral wealth. But if they are being forced to cut prices to keep those reserves flowing, that's an interesting data point on their economic health.
- JacobAldridge 11y ago"And the second is the huge export boosts from China in iron and steel. (alleged in the article to be below cost but there wasn't really any support for that argument.)" The quote from the article is “China is selling below the price of recycled steel”. I interpreted that to mean that at current prices new steel from China sold at the market rate is cheaper than recycled steel. So no 'below cost' shenanigans, just comparable products moving in out-of-sync market cycles. And yes, businesses the world over can be guilty of not reinvesting in facilities. There's a mantra for change that says "If we always do what we've always done, then we'll always get what we've always got". Unfortunately, many business owners in good times think that's true as well! And so they fail to make the necessary improvements when they can, and can't afford it when they have to.
- wisty 11y agoOr it could be that Chinese companies were stockpiling steel (as the price was rising), and are now trying to sell it off now that the price is dropping. So if you've got a great big lump of steel, it's not cost effective to break it apart to sell right now.
- bigger_cheese 11y agoI work in the steel industry, virgin steel not recycled steel and we are having the same problems. China has so much excess domestic steel capacity that they are now flooding the international export market and the price of Coil has tanked. http://www.smh.com.au/business/mining-and-resources/chinese-steel-is-now-cheaper-than-cabbage-20150708-gi81ea.html http://www.smh.com.au/business/mining-and-resources/chinese-... 'When asked about the cabbage conundrum, one trader told Platts he would be "better off going home to plow the fields rather than try to make money selling steel".'
- rational-future 11y ago>> And the second is the huge export boosts from China in iron and steel. (alleged in the article to be below cost but there wasn't really any support for that argument.) It's just a well known fact. The major iron and steel mills have 100K or so employees each. They receive billions of $ subsidies annually to save those people from unemployment and potential social unrest.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe transformative event seems to be the EU environmental regulations (where prior to the change they were cost competitive without making investments).
- jallmann 11y ago> Any insights on why companies doing ship breaking wouldn't invest at least some of the returns into their own facilities? > people don't figure out ways to do it better/more efficiently/safer? From the article, it sounds like cost is really the only competitive advantage the Southeast Asian shipbreakers have. The capital and maintenance expense of facility upgrades would probably destroy any (cost-based) competitive advantage. Labor is really, REALLY cheap in India. The corresponding economic gap is actually a big catch-22 insofar as investing in automation, but that's a discussion for another time...
- cmdkeen 11y agoThere was a documentary a while ago about the building of the QE2 in Scotland in the mid 60s. One of the former trade union leaders interviewed remarked that in hindsight the giveaway that things for the UK shipbuilding industry was going to go badly was they were using equipment built in 1905. We see this stuff all the time across the world. The short term risk of upgrading can be an awful lot more than financial. Vested local interests can often cause all sorts of problems. Especially if your investment in new equipment leads to you essentially trying to compete on highlighting local environmental and labour abuses. Combine that with humanity's natural "it's been good so far, why wouldn't it continue?" inclination...