4 ms·
You're right, of course. And yet Marx himself was not, himself, a despot or murderer. He was probably a pretty nice guy. Your description is therefore simila
by ajross 17y ago
You're right, of course.
And yet Marx himself was not, himself, a despot or murderer. He was probably a pretty nice guy. Your description is therefore similarly incomplete. He can be both things. History is complicated, and not well served by summary arguments.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 17y agoYeah. All he did was advocate violence, he didn't actually commit any. All around pal.
- ajross 17y agoThomas Jefferson did almost exactly the same thing. As did Nelson Mandela. There's a pretty big moral space between advocating the overthrow of a government and the behavior of a Stalin or Pol Pot. Marx belongs to the former category, not the latter. But because of events that happened decades after his death, he's remembered as something he wasn't. His crime was being wrong, not evil.
- w00pla 17y ago> As did Nelson Mandela. Yes, and he was imprisoned for it. But what made Mandela great is that he changed and became a reconciliation figure. The young MK starter and ANCYL member did not deserve a Nobel Peace Prize. But the Mandela in 1991 did.
- access_denied 17y agoBecause he had no power to be a despot - that's all.