3 ms·
I think what makes most religions so inflexible is having a canon which can be difficult to circumvent. If a secular order is based on the opinions of the found
by tootie 11y ago
I think what makes most religions so inflexible is having a canon which can be difficult to circumvent. If a secular order is based on the opinions of the founders who are treated as wise humans instead of divine, it becomes easier to accept that they could be wrong or just misinformed.
- nicklaf 11y ago"Herding cats"
- tome 11y agoI'm sadly skeptical, given how much weight Americans seem to give to the intentions of the founding fathers when it comes to discussing the constitution.
- cicero 11y agoI think it's only a small (though vocal) minority of Americans who care about that. It certainly doesn't affect the majority of the Supreme Court.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoOn the other hand, that inflexibility may be what just makes it work. Being held to the same strict standard makes the community much stronger.
- shanusmagnus 11y agoThis makes sense -- I was trying to figure out why various secular groups with which I'm involved (e.g., improv theatre, or the guys at the gym) don't have any of the church-like feel. I think it's because they're too flexible -- people are always leaving, forming sub-groups, etc. I like those people but they would never show up at my house to mow my lawn, as another commenter described. Or maybe 'flexibility' is the wrong word, since the groups I mention are activity-specific, and one's interest in the activity ebbs and flows, whereas one's interest in fellowship with other people in the quest for some kind of human-level goodwill would presumably be constant.
- xupybd 11y agoBased on my own reflections on the Christian community I am part of, I'd have to agree. I believe one of the things holds the community together is that every sticks to the same set of rules. And is willing to change if they find they are living outside of the rules. Not everyone's cup of tea but it's a life I enjoy. Perhaps similar systems outside of religion could help people.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI grew up in a Christian community and it's something that I miss - the feeling that you strive to uphold rules that are greater than yourself, and everyone around you fights with their own bodies and minds to do the same. In the group I used to be a part of, the mentality of "we're all in this together" was strong.