4 ms·
It is beyond offensive to imply that 60 year old individual is worth less to society than a 30 year old individual, and that there are life-saving measures appr
by pc86 11y ago
It is beyond offensive to imply that 60 year old individual is worth less to society than a 30 year old individual, and that there are life-saving measures appropriate for the latter that are too costly for the former.
- DiabloD3 11y agoI don't know why this comment is being downvoted. If medicine still advances at the rate it is now, by the time we will be 60, the average old age will be in the 100s.
- hessenwolf 11y agoDue to "rectangularisation of the survival curve", probably not (there appears to be a max age of around 110). Current rates are 3 months more life expectancy per calendar year. However, in the US and various other places the improvement is seriously wobbling due to wobbly bellies.
- hessenwolf 11y agoLet's say the treatment guarantees until life expectancy of 88, ignoring a few details. Do we say that 28 years of life is worth the same as 58 years of life, keeping in mind budget is fixed?
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoI mostly disagree although I understand and appreciate the sentiment of your post. You have to consider first of all that we're working with scarce resources. When we're not, it's not even an issue to compare two lives if you can save them both. But in the case that there are limited resources and you happen to have to choose between focusing on two different groups of people and make that tradeoff, you inevitably have to base your decision on something. Now if you have a 15 year old kid and an 80 year old person, and both are dying from some preventable disease at a rate of 1% per year, and you have a scarce budget to focus on researching one particular disease, which one do you choose to focus on? Well flipping a coin is probably shit. But making a ranking based on qualify adjusted life years[0] probably makes more sense. Of course it's not perfect, but it's not beyond offensive if you ask me to go about reasoning like this to partially inform policy decisions. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year
- sago 11y agoI suspect the idea sounds 'wrong' when talking about adults, but most people feel it is intuitive when talking about young children. Which person should you rescue first, the 4 year old or the 64 year old? These issues I suspect are very rife for post-hoc rationalisation around gut-feelings of morality: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5YL3LT1ZvOM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5YL3LT1ZvOM
- melling 11y agoWhat scarce resources are you referring to in the developed world? Bill Gates turns 60 this year. It's pretty safe to assume he'll accomplish more in the next 20 years than you will in your lifetime.
- IkmoIkmo 11y ago> What scarce resources are you referring to in the developed world? What kind of question is this? You think we have infinite medical researchers with infinite resources and infinite budgets? All countries, including the richest ones, have budgets. > Bill Gates turns 60 this year. It's pretty safe to assume he'll accomplish more in the next 20 years than you will in your lifetime. Oh god you can't really think that's a good argument, can you? Citing Gates as your anecdotal evidence to make a point about policy that affects millions of people is outright silly. It's like saying government policy should prevent people from going to university, and dropping out once they get in, because hey Bill Gates did it and look how that turned out. Why refer to one of the most extreme outliers in modern history as a justification for medical policy for completely different, average people? I don't even get what your point is. I made the point that it probably makes more sense to save 1% of 15 year olds (or 25 year olds for that matter, considering the other post on how children distort our perspective of morality), than 1% of 80 year olds, or 60 year olds for that matter, given a common situation of scarce resources and the need to make a trade off. (again in cases where resource scarcity doesn't matter, the discussion is irrelevant). If you want to counter that with the point that 'but some 60 year olds are still productive, look at bill gates, his impact will be tremendous the next decades' then you fail to see how statistically that 60 year old may have already been dead 35 years earlier, and that statistically for every bill gates you'd save at 60, in this hypothetical situation, you'd give up a younger bill gates who now dies at 25, and it may be said that despite his tremendous impact late in life, it doesn't rival his impact earlier in life, and that this (having more impact before 60 than after 60) probably holds true on average, generally speaking. No amount of anecdotal evidence changes that fact.
- barrkel 11y agoResources are scarce; their use must be prioritized. The answer to the difficult question of how to apportion health spending is not to take offense at being asked. You don't get to take that way out; it's not an option.