6 ms·
SolarCity didn’t invent solar panel, but it invented something more important
- kumarm 11y agoFrom Wikipedia: In 2008, SolarCity introduced a new solar lease option for homeowners that significantly reduces or eliminates the upfront cost of installing solar power. Several companies were offering Solar lease in 2007. The article seem to imply that SolarCity invented Solar Leasing which is inaccurate.
- oinksoft 11y agoIt looks like that was added in 2008[1] by an anonymous editor likely affiliated with SolarCity[2]. This is par for the course for a Wikipedia article about an operating business. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=SolarCity&type=revision&diff=242570383&oldid=237603630 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=SolarCity&type=re... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/UVHaight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/UVHaight
- Animats 11y agoFive editors with Solar City only editing interests have edited that article, including one called "AvalonPRlosangeles". I put a notice on Wikipedia's conflict of interest noticeboard, which will start the process by which promotional edits are dealt with.
- x5n1 11y agoThey were doing that at least 5 years before that
- justincormack 11y agoCredit is hardly a new innovation.
- martin1975 11y agoBe that as it may, leasing vs buying is always bad, IMO. We just installed our PV system in SoCal - I get the rebate, I own the system, when selling the home eventually the new owner knows what he/she is getting and isn't encumbered by the lease.... However you slice it, biting the bullet and buying your own PV system is way way better than leasing it. Maybe there are cases where leasing makes sense...but those are few and far between...or maybe SolarCity counts on people being uninformed/clueless, which is why this 'lease' model works. IMHO, it's total ripoff.
- cbhl 11y agoIIRC the argument for the lease is not having money up front, having someone else bear the cost of installing PV, and getting a "free" discount on your PG&E bill in exchange for a monthly payment.
- jbuzbee 11y agoI've always preferred to buy vs. lease rationalizing that I'm taking the profit away from the middle-man for myself. And I'm interested in solar, but I've been hesitant to contact any solar installation outfit because I fear the installer's sales pitches, confusing contracts, phone calls, etc. Can I ask ballpark figure what it costs to outright purchase panels for a typical house? I realize that there are lots of variables such as house orientation, roof size, electric usage, etc.
- martin1975 11y agoThe guy who did it for me is one of my best friends and he's been at it for a few years - he's been in sales overall for 20+ years, but lately he's been doing PV installations. He's fully licensed and bonded in CA. If you are in the SoCal area, I can send you to him for a friendly rate and I am 99% certain he will beat any other quote you get. Mine was 18k for a 5k system, using Solarworld's Sumodule Protect ... Everyone else quoted me higher. Post a (disposable) email address where I can reach you with his info if you're in SoCal.
- jbuzbee 11y ago
- sokoloff 11y ago"Mickey D's first introduced a lobster roll — then called the "McLobster" — nationally in 1993" [1] IMO, no one reads that and assumes that McDs invented the lobster roll. Why then would someone read the Wikipedia quote and assume Solar City was first or assume that's what the wikipedia quote was implying? That was when Solar City first introduced their new product: a lease. 1 - http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/eats/mcdonald-start-selling-lobster-rolls-article-1.2275615 http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/eats/mcdonald-start-se...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 11y agoThe processes mentioned still sorta basic but I think it's always useful to point out that innovation extends beyond tech. Also, I wonder where any of this (solar city, spacex and tesla) would be without government help?
- dylanjermiah 11y agoMusk has said Tesla didn't need the government money, it was just used as a cash buffer (which of course was repaid early with interest). As for SpaceX, they've been profitable for 7+ years and NASA is a client so not sure. As for Solar City unsure, but government money doesn't make a business succeed. No matter how much. (Solyndra) c
- sremani 11y agoFederal Credits are crucial for SolarCity. Most of the SolarCity customers do not own their Solar plants and SolarCity quotes a "very high" price if any one asks for a SolarPV to own.
- lotharbot 11y ago> "SolarCity quotes a "very high" price if any one asks for a SolarPV to own" My rooftop solar (I believe it'll be ~6kw; installation is soon) is around $20,000 to own outright, which includes 30 years of maintenance, whether or not I pay it off early. Once it's paid, it's mine. That's actually not a "very high" price compared to decades of electricity, particularly not once you include the federal tax credit (30% of the system price). So you're right that the federal tax credit is a big deal, but I wouldn't have described the system as a "very high" price (it's around the same amount as the average "minor" kitchen remodel.) EDIT: the big deal with the federal tax credit is that it can be used as a down payment, which makes the overall system payments begin at a lower price than grid electricity rather than a slightly higher price. This means monetary savings is immediate.
- sremani 11y agoIn 2013, for 10.5KW plant I was quoted $40K+ and I ended up with 20 year leasing (paying entire amount upfront) for a notch less than $10K. Even adding all the credits the ownership would have cost me 25K+. That is a huge difference. Of course the numbers vary a bit by state.
- aharonovich 11y agoThe amazing part of it imo is that no matter the industry, a high tech company with the high tech standards of IT, customer service and efficiency will win, as long as it completes against classic industrial/commercial companies
- diafygi 11y agoHoly hell is this a puff piece. Don't get me wrong, I'm a huge fan of SolarCity, but this story is written as if they invented the solar boom that's happening now. Three major factors contributed to making solar as viable as it is now, none of which Solar City invented (but it is executing on them better). 1. Germany basically subsidizing China (and others) to build the massive solar panel production pipeline it has now that are producing ridiculously cheap panels[1]. 2. Financial innovation to allow consumers and installers to pay for panels over time (PPA, leases, loans, etc.). These were originally pioneered by SunEdison[2], and the industry has been innovating on them since (including SolarCity with its MyPower Loan). 3. The California Solar Initiative[3] and Department of Energy's Sunshot Initiative[4]. Both were incredibly well designed to gradually wean solar off of subsidies and foster innovation through strategic grants, and they have worked incredibly well at teaching the solar industry to stand on its own two feet. We are well on our way to $1/watt[5]. SolarCity has executed incredibly well in this industry, so they definitely deserve tons of credit for installing so much solar. But it's a disservice to the rest of the companies, governments, and financiers to say they invented the recent growth. Everyone, including SolarCity, has come together to build a mature and exponentially growing industry that was 1 out of every 78 jobs last year. [1]: http://qz.com/41166/how-germanys-energy-transformation-has-turned-into-a-crisis/ http://qz.com/41166/how-germanys-energy-transformation-has-t... [2]: http://archive.onearth.org/article/selling-the-sun http://archive.onearth.org/article/selling-the-sun [3]: http://www.gosolarcalifornia.ca.gov/csi/index.php http://www.gosolarcalifornia.ca.gov/csi/index.php [4]: http://energy.gov/eere/sunshot/sunshot-initiative http://energy.gov/eere/sunshot/sunshot-initiative [5]: http://cleantechnica.com/2015/07/10/price-solar-hits-record-low/ http://cleantechnica.com/2015/07/10/price-solar-hits-record-...
- minthd 11y agoFictional myth building around Elon Musk is a recurring activity.For example, the hyperloop: "Two weeks before his Hyperloop announcement, Musk quietly met with the founder of ET3, an even-faster, already patented[since 1999] tube transport system."[1]. That's not to say Elon didn't help the hyperloop - he helped greatly by exciting the public's and investors imagination. But he didn't invent the thing. [1]http://www.fastcoexist.com/3015704/futurist-forum/how-much-did-this-hyperloop-lookalike-inspire-elon-musk http://www.fastcoexist.com/3015704/futurist-forum/how-much-d...
- delbel 11y agoBig deal. They introduced the what is now called the "Financialization" of the solar panel. They weren't even the first to do this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financialization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financialization You can do this to almost anything, here's a goofy example. I hate tying my shoelaces and they always come undone, but I can't justify spending $70 on Velcro shoes because of personal preference: basically I'd rather deal with the annoyances of tying my shoe then to fork out $70 for Velcro shoes at the moment. But, Wal-Mart sells a low quality Velcro tennis shoe for $10. The problem is it only lasts about 6-8 weeks before the it falls apart. But by converting the $10 shoe into a subscription service at $5 a month, a company can turn a shoe into financial instrument, and poof, magically it matches my lower price point and I can justify a $5 subscription instead of a $70 sale. So, for $5 a month, or $60 a year, I will receive replacement shoes in the mail every eight weeks. Like I said, that was a goofy example. Replace shoes with solar panels and subscription with a lease agreement.
- realusername 11y agoYeah, I don't really understand, "Financialization" of solar pannels has always been quite obvious (because it's an expensive and long term product) and almost every solar company has always proposed some options for that, I has been there since the birth of the industry.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jusben1369 11y agoThere's a lot of negativity around this piece usually in the form of "some other company had a lease program" etc. The author's main point to me was that SolarCity is executing best across a wide range of areas to bring solar to the masses and growing TAM via new markets etc. Pointing out they weren't the first with X is like poo poohing MSFT in the 90's because Apple had a GUI first.
- don_draper 11y agoAnybody know how these companies continue to get money from investors? SolarCity, Tesla, Sun Edison lose money year after year. None of them are profitable. And they won't be for years. I guess the thinking is that once, or if, they get profitable they will benefit from being the established players.
- spenrose 11y agoWRT SolarCity, and solar generally, you spend something like $2,000 (haven't looked it up) to manufacture a panel that generates a kilowatt at peak, you wire it up, and you generate power (and revenue) every sunny afternoon for the next 25 years. "The thinking" -- or as I prefer to call it, "the physics" -- is that you create value over time.
- jkestner 11y agoYeah, it's called a startup. Amazon has similarly avoided making profits while it can roll money back into expanding its dominance. The key is to articulate and stick to a long-term plan.
- rogerbinns 11y agoI am interested in what is going to happen to the housing market. These systems typically have a 20 year contract. If the house is sold before that, then the purchaser has to assume the contract and the solar system. Those contracts could be extremely undesirable if the energy rates change a lot, better panels come out, financing/subsidies differs, it is better to use solar for hot water instead of electricity, battery storage turns out better, or a whole host of other scenarios. If you were looking to buy a house, and it was 7 years into a 20 year solar contract (hence locking in the rates/financing of 7 years ago), wouldn't you want it either removed so you can put in something better, or be compensated for taking on such obligations? I can't find out how often houses are sold in California, but it seems like ~7 years is normal.
- rbosinger 11y agoYeah I have a small investment in SolarCity and I keep meaning to find out how they handle this situation. Imagine in 5 years some stories coming out regarding home owners having trouble selling (or losing value on) homes they equipped under a solar loan. That would likely affect future sign-ups.
- cjensen 11y agoCalifornia plans to change to "time-of-use" pricing of electricity [1]. How will that affect the savings currently seen by folks who lease from SolarCity and other providers? [1] http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2015/05/20/california-electricity-rates/27688891/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2015/05/20/califor...
- Terr_ 11y agoTo quote Schlock Mercenary: > "Your kind began as self-repairing distributed storage systems for our supercomputers. [...] No, I didn't create you. Engineers did. > I created something far more powerful... The marketing campaign that made you profitable."