4 ms·
This is legitimate as they do the same to us. They're one of the most capable countries doing espionage against U.S. military and industry. They've stolen plent
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
This is legitimate as they do the same to us. They're one of the most capable countries doing espionage against U.S. military and industry. They've stolen plenty of I.P.. At one point, NSA intercepted a communication from Mitsubishi that contained President's Daily Brief. We have to spy on countries like this to even out the negotiations or else they become quite one-sided without us knowing why.
- justinpombrio 11y agoBy this argument, basically every other country in the world should spy as much as possible on the US, since our surveillance is so ubiquitous. Do you agree?
- mikeash 11y agoDon't they already do this? Everybody spies on everybody, to the extent that they can. That's how the world works.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYes, I agree they should play by the same rules as us or pull even more stuff. A NSA proponent worded situation nicely: "most countries make espionage against them illegal while making espionage for them legal and even funded in form of intelligence agencies." That's the game. Better play it or competition wins.
- ccvannorman 11y ago"This is legitimate as they do the same to us." Can we talk about this not being okay (for a long term human future)? Imagine a world where groups of people didn't constantly put effort into undermining other groups in secret.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoThere it goes. The inevitable "What if utopia existed? What if U.S. and Japan didn't continue to provide a lifestyle to their citizens based on mass exploitation and harm in other countries? What if nobody cheated to get ahead? What if human nature itself was rewired and all of existence did a 180?" I can't answer these because everything from my World History book back in school to the present news feed shows what you imagine has never existed. The only "What if?" I know the answer to is what happens when one side uses every tool to get ahead and one plays Scout's Honor: the side hustling ends up ahead. Best to focus our questions and efforts of changing our world on possibilities that might actually happen. Eliminating espionage isn't one of them.
- mikeash 11y agoLet's start with imagining how to make such a world come about. Until we have some idea of how to get there, there isn't much point in imagining what it would be like. Whether something is "okay" just doesn't matter here. International relations are the ultimate anarchy. There are no rules and no law, just what the participants can get away with.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoExactly. Even with rules preventing most of it, esp industrial espionage, you still need spy agencies to peak at other side to make sure they follow the rules. That's what US claims they do. They did in fact catch numerous attempts to steal big contracts with bribery. So, the game will continue to exist one way or another. And if public sector had total openness, they'd just use private contractors as they already do for some covert and especially criminal ops.