3 ms·
Wasn't DualEC the default algorithm used by a bunch of RSA products that were incorporated elsewhere?
by nitrogen 11y ago
Wasn't DualEC the default algorithm used by a bunch of RSA products that were incorporated elsewhere?
- csandreasen 11y agoDual_EC was the default PRNG for the RSA BSAFE library. The only actual numbers I've seen regarding how popular the library was this researcher's findings[1] in which he did a scan of 21.8 million IP addresses and managed to find 720 servers using it (to be fair, that's a lower bound as there were two implementations of BSAFE and only one was detectable remotely). It was generally easier use a PRNG provided by the OS or use an open source library for free. As a testament to how unpopular Dual_EC was, there was a bug in OpenSSL for years that prevented it from working at all when Dual_EC was enabled, and it wasn't discovered until after Snowden. [1] http://dualec.org/ http://dualec.org/
- tptacek 11y agoIn 10 years of doing software security assessments I saw a total of zero (0) systems use BSAFE. It may have been popular with government contractors. Later There was also a period during which the Red Hat Secure Server that shipped with Red Hat Professional linked against BSAFE. Its release timing doesn't square with Dual_EC though.