3 ms·
Wow. It can't even use its gun right. Mindblowing. Meanwhile outside Pentagon, university teams from across the country with limited budgets are building robot
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
Wow. It can't even use its gun right. Mindblowing.
Meanwhile outside Pentagon, university teams from across the country with limited budgets are building robots that drive, fly, make stuff, and so on with little to no human intervention.
- engi_nerd 11y agoThe gun has been tested on the ground both in and out of the plane. The software that would enable full use of the gun was delayed at program office request. It was decided that using missiles and bombs was more relevant and important. I get that you don't like the plane but your arguments do not reflect facts.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou just admitted what the article claimed but with a different reason. We've spent X dollars for Y years for a plane with a partly usable gun? That fact is enough reason not to like the plane for situations involving guns or the program that led to that situation. That's before my arguments or personal preferences enter the situation.
- engi_nerd 11y agoSo you're a software guy, right? Ever do a phased release? Wherein you design capability to be released in different increments. I know this isn't the most popular of software methodologies, but it's how defense projects work. Your complaint is like saying, "You worked all this time to get to phase 2 and you don't have feature X done yet?" and the engineers say, "But feature X isn't even intended to be in the software until phase 4!" EDIT: I should point out that as a defense acquisition project, THIS (http://www.hjspllc.com/2014dev/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/DAUlarge.jpg http://www.hjspllc.com/2014dev/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/DA...) is what governs the F-35 and most projects the DoD does. Look upon these works, ye sorry engineers, and despair. I took several hundred hours of courses about this process and I could not even begin to explain it, it's so ridiculous. Tons of waterfall and spiral development there.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI'm a systems & software guy w/ a high assurance focus so I'm familiar with that sort of thing. It taught me to prioritize based on what was more vs less critical. So, it's supposed to destroy targets. Means it has to take off, detect the target, destroy with missiles/guns, and return. The essentials of these get done first and then everything else. A program that's spent this money with this many features without a working gun is not how we do phases in delivery. That's defense programs gone wrong. Further, the other commenter's link shows this isn't a phase: it's a delay caused by the failure of one. Plenty of delays, overruns, and even decommissioning to make up for it support how poorly-managed this program is. And such poor management and priorities support that this isn't merely a lifecycle issue.
- engi_nerd 11y agoWell, you would have to prioritize how you wanted to kill targets, as you say. The program has chosen to delay focus on the gun until later. Was that a wise decision? I honestly don't know. And also, history nerd that I am...most of the high profile defense programs that I can think of were off the rails at one point or another. This is not to excuse anything (boy, people love that argument, that other programs had issues but turned out fine, so this will, too...I don't like that one), but to point out the fact that we as a society really don't understand how to do this kind of thing well. F-15 and F-16 were both lampooned in their day as being bloated and late and ineffective (I can anticipate the objection now -- not to this same degree -- and cannot argue against it). The Bradley's problems were so famous that HBO made "The Pentagon Wars" (which is a movie that I would actually highly recommend). The A-10 was not paid much attention to publicly but the Air Force of the 1970s hated it and wanted it to die before it ever left a drafting board (they were wrong, of course).
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI was saying the program has had many delays and overruns in general with the gun issue maybe being part of that trend rather than pure design decision. Each possibility paints it in a different light. Regardless, I agree that many programs have had issues despite making it. I did watch Pentagon Wars and was amazed that some issues even existed. I think the main concern, outside the original link, is that this plane is one of the most expensive we've ever done while not delivering the value or effectiveness a few different, focused planes would. They still could've consolidated on radar, comms, weapon/missile systems, and so on while making the plane physically ideal for its missions. In process, they could leverage proven approaches in other best of breed fights. That is what I meant by upgrading our current best stuff. You can straight-up improve their existing configuration. Or you can create new planes with their best qualities with vastly improved capabilities. As illustrated above, there's still plenty of consolidation allowed and would probably be cheaper (in development) due to less troubles.
- protomyth 11y agoMy argument is the gun software is not the ready which you have confirmed. Also, for a CAS platform the pathetic 220 rounds is really going to be a problem. http://www.dodbuzz.com/2015/01/08/pentagon-f-35-gun-will-fire-in-2017/ http://www.dodbuzz.com/2015/01/08/pentagon-f-35-gun-will-fir...
- engi_nerd 11y agoYup, there's no denying the software is not ready. As I pointed out, the gun is still being tested. And let's be clear about that 220 rounds -- that's only on the F-35A. The number is less for the other two variants (180) which have to carry the gun externally in a pod. So that is even worse!
- robotresearcher 11y agoMany of those teams are funded by the Pentagon. The DoD has its eggs in several baskets. DARPA is a very creative organization.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYeah, I might have gotten carried away. This is military-industrial complex's BS in action. DOD, esp DARPA, is capable of funding well-managed programs.