4 ms·
Your argument doesn't seem to make any sense. You say that the F-35 engine would be picked up by upgraded sensors on next-gen planes ? But next-gen planes don'
by threeseed 11y ago
Your argument doesn't seem to make any sense.
You say that the F-35 engine would be picked up by upgraded sensors on next-gen planes ? But next-gen planes don't exist yet. So that means the F-35 would dominate older generation planes when in its preferred position. Which makes it anything but worthless does it not ?
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI'm saying that tests already prove outdated planes would kill it in a dogfight and there are concerns about long-range. Here's those: https://medium.com/war-is-boring/no-the-f-35-can-t-fight-at-long-range-either-5508913252dd https://medium.com/war-is-boring/no-the-f-35-can-t-fight-at-... Contrary to your post, the goal of F-35 isn't to defeat outdated tech: must defeat old and next-gen tech. Performance at long-range looks like it was optimized to defeat old tech with a bit of improvement. The enemy's new tech is very improved and China straight up stole F-35 tech for theirs. With that, we must assume theirs is at least as good as F-35. Maybe more given that they eliminated its weaknesses in their version. Add Russia and the new radars to get anything but assurance that F-35 will deliver. It might. So far it's failed on everything else, though, while specifically eliminating strengths in its design for politics essentially. Enemies's designs aren't doing that. So, I'm not betting on F-35 in any scenario.
- alkonaut 11y agoThe Chinese 5gen we don't even know what it's for. It's not stealthy like the F-35, only from the front. The Russian 5gen (T-50) looks like what the F-35 would have looked like if it was made as a 5gen fighter for the USAF without the stovl crap bolted on. As such it can get a huge energy/payload/maneuverability advantage over the F-35, like the F-22. In any case, the F-35 might run into problems when pitched against 4.5gen or 5gen craft, if the battle isn't decided at long range before the F-35 is detected. A large part of the problem lies in the payload capacity; if you face an adversary carrying 2-4 times as many bvr missiles per craft you are at a huge disadvantage.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"The Russian 5gen (T-50) looks like what the F-35 would have looked like if it was made as a 5gen fighter for the USAF without the stovl crap bolted on." One of my biggest gripes with the program right there. F-35 seems setup to fail against 5gen's while others aren't doing that in design decisions. I'll take everyone's word for it that the others' designs aren't finalized or sufficiently detailed to tell what they can do overall.
- engi_nerd 11y agoCombat effectiveness testing is done on all aircraft the US introduces. So the question of "can we succeed against other types of aircraft that we will encounter?" will be examined in great detail. Nothing on that yet, so it remains an open question with respect to the F-35.