3 ms·
Now if they ask me (wouldn't that be odd? "let's ask one of those guys on the Internet..."). After the F-35 program is cut back from a couple of thousand to a
by alkonaut 11y ago
Now if they ask me (wouldn't that be odd? "let's ask one of those guys on the Internet...").
After the F-35 program is cut back from a couple of thousand to a few hundred craft, and then completely cancelled, this is what I think should happen:
1) extensions and upgrades to old platforms. Aesa/irst and modern bvr for all craft.
2) Make a new cheaper "4.5 gen" multirole platform with low operation costs, and no silly budget-breaking features: no full
Stealth, no jumpjet. Instead just low radar cross section, supercruise, and lots of payload (f-35 can carry very little because of stealth and jumpjet design constraints). Looking at the Gripen, this should be possible at a fraction of the cost of an F-35.
3) tell the marines they can stop using jumpjets and use choppers or drones or whatever. Jumpjets are a dead end.
4) Make a few more F-22's in case the ultra expensive air superiority is needed.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoSounds like good ideas. No 3 in particular might save Marine's lives if they get rid of the Osprey. There's a new counterargument: stop killing your own people and get them to the battlefield instead.
- engi_nerd 11y agoSo you get rid of the Osprey. Congratulations, now you have a tactical gap because you have no more medium transport capability. The CH-46 (the previous medium lift helicopter for the USMC) is officially retired as of August 1, 2015. Now you need to develop a new aircraft. Even if you choose a civilian aircraft and militarize it, you're looking at a decade where you have no medium lift.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou assumed I'd do it instantly. That's a bad assumption and you came up with the reasons yourself. It would take time.
- engi_nerd 11y agoWell, you seemed so...cavalier about it.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI do have an odd way of speaking sometimes. Nothing gets created in defense sector without time. I guess I figured people would assume there'd be some process to getting rid of them.
- engi_nerd 11y agoThe Osprey, from what I have heard, seems to be doing okay now. But, as you referred to, it has a rough history. Have you read "The Dream Machine: The Untold History of the Notorious V-22 Osprey" by Richard Whittle? I read through it, and found no glaring technical errors (though my experience with a V-22 involves climbing inside one, once, to look at home someone did something I needed to replicate on something else, and a quick test flight in a V-22 simulator years ago as part of a "hey come work here we are really cool" career fair I attended). It's competently written and talks about the issues the V-22 encountered in detail.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoSounds interesting but I'll probably not have the time to spare. The radical nature of the craft means it would definitely have issues. That was going to be true from the get go. Other commenter implied the things that came before it were much worse and if true then it's necessary evil. Cool that you got to get in one, though.
- engi_nerd 11y agoInterestingly enough, while I was in the sim, another person was flying and managed to put the aircraft into vortex ring state -- the exact cause of a real-world V-22 crash. That person crashed in the sim, too. The flight controls won't stop you from doing so. But the aircraft does detect flight conditions where it's likely to happen and warns "SINK RATE, SINK RATE" over the crew's headsets. So then it's the pilot's responsibility to knock it off.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoEnemies have their work cut out for them.
- protomyth 11y agoI take it you haven't look at the stats for the helicopters the Osprey is replacing? The media doesn't cover helicopter crashes like it does the Osprey, but it doesn't cover the CDC top ten killer list either.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI haven't done a full look at the stats vs what it replaces or alternatives that were available. A bias on Osprey from media and/or soldiers that talk about it could certainly affect my view. How bad were they?
- engi_nerd 11y agoI bet you're getting tired of hearing from me. But I did do some work on a CH-46. That was the previous medium lift helo for the Marines (and the Navy until they retired the type in 2004). So one CH-46 got shot down in Iraq by a MANPAD. Here is the video from the persons who did it http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=efb_1196612143 http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=efb_1196612143 So there's a clear vulnerability there. Various attempts to address this met with mixed results. Here is one aircraft so modified https://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5603/15563054829_09753417c0_b.jpg https://c2.staticflickr.com/6/5603/15563054829_09753417c0_b.... It's sitting in a museum this way, so this stuff (which is not at all old) clearly didn't work. Plus it was getting difficult to keep the things in the air...the youngest CH-46s were made in the early 1970s, but most dated from 1965-68. So, 40+ years old. There are even documented cases where a father and son (and even one father/daughter pair) flew the exact same CH-46 into combat, 4 decades apart. The 46 is slow. You might push it up to 120 knots. And it was made in the era before digital avionics. The 46-E standard at least gave the aircraft a digital flight computer (not flight controls, but avionics control and some decent comms), but even that is now ancient and antiquated. That's the basic answer about the 46 -- good at its creation, one hell of an airframe, lasted longer than it should have by all rights, but it is just time to say goodbye. As I said elsewhere, August 1 (today, now!) marks the final flight of HMM-774's last CH-46 to the Udvar-Hazy center in Dulles, VA, where the type will be officially retired. HMM-774 then officially becomes VMM-774 flying the V-22, and the conversion is complete.