7 ms·
Sadly, I'm actually being quite serious[1]. The update from last year gave a likely 2019 which was later corrected to 2017. I doubt it made it to 2015. 1) ht
by protomyth 11y ago
Sadly, I'm actually being quite serious[1]. The update from last year gave a likely 2019 which was later corrected to 2017. I doubt it made it to 2015.
1) http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/11319455/F-35-stealth-jet-will-not-be-able-to-fire-its-guns-until-2019.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/1...
- PirateDave 11y agoThis reminds me of an anecdote that a Marine officer once told me. He said that when the Air Force builds a new base, they're given a certain budget and they build every part of the base, gym, mess hall, rec facilities e.t.c. and use the entirety of the budget to make the base nice and comfortable for the airmen that are stationed there. Then, when the base is almost completed, and over schedule, the party in charge asks for more money, and more time because they still need to build the most important part of the base, the flight-line. I know this is most likely an embellishment, but being involved with government work in the past, it doesn't sound far off from the truth and felt it fit nicely in this situation.
- plonh 11y agoInterestingly, this is the similar to how municipal services are funding. Authorities build out the police and internal government pork, and then cut the parks and schools projects and go to the pulic for tax increases.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoWow. It can't even use its gun right. Mindblowing. Meanwhile outside Pentagon, university teams from across the country with limited budgets are building robots that drive, fly, make stuff, and so on with little to no human intervention.
- engi_nerd 11y agoThe gun has been tested on the ground both in and out of the plane. The software that would enable full use of the gun was delayed at program office request. It was decided that using missiles and bombs was more relevant and important. I get that you don't like the plane but your arguments do not reflect facts.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYou just admitted what the article claimed but with a different reason. We've spent X dollars for Y years for a plane with a partly usable gun? That fact is enough reason not to like the plane for situations involving guns or the program that led to that situation. That's before my arguments or personal preferences enter the situation.
- engi_nerd 11y agoSo you're a software guy, right? Ever do a phased release? Wherein you design capability to be released in different increments. I know this isn't the most popular of software methodologies, but it's how defense projects work. Your complaint is like saying, "You worked all this time to get to phase 2 and you don't have feature X done yet?" and the engineers say, "But feature X isn't even intended to be in the software until phase 4!" EDIT: I should point out that as a defense acquisition project, THIS (http://www.hjspllc.com/2014dev/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/DAUlarge.jpg http://www.hjspllc.com/2014dev/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/DA...) is what governs the F-35 and most projects the DoD does. Look upon these works, ye sorry engineers, and despair. I took several hundred hours of courses about this process and I could not even begin to explain it, it's so ridiculous. Tons of waterfall and spiral development there.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoI'm a systems & software guy w/ a high assurance focus so I'm familiar with that sort of thing. It taught me to prioritize based on what was more vs less critical. So, it's supposed to destroy targets. Means it has to take off, detect the target, destroy with missiles/guns, and return. The essentials of these get done first and then everything else. A program that's spent this money with this many features without a working gun is not how we do phases in delivery. That's defense programs gone wrong. Further, the other commenter's link shows this isn't a phase: it's a delay caused by the failure of one. Plenty of delays, overruns, and even decommissioning to make up for it support how poorly-managed this program is. And such poor management and priorities support that this isn't merely a lifecycle issue.
- robotresearcher 11y agoMany of those teams are funded by the Pentagon. The DoD has its eggs in several baskets. DARPA is a very creative organization.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoYeah, I might have gotten carried away. This is military-industrial complex's BS in action. DOD, esp DARPA, is capable of funding well-managed programs.