2 ms·
Thank you for pointing this out. I think the argument leading up to that conclusion is also interesting: "Whether disclosure is a breach of duty therefore dep
by mannykannot 11y ago
Thank you for pointing this out.
I think the argument leading up to that conclusion is also interesting:
"Whether disclosure is a breach of duty therefore depends in large part on the purpose of the disclosure. This standard was identified by the SEC itself in Cady, Roberts: a purpose of the securities laws was to eliminate 'use of inside information for personal advantage.' 40 S.E. C., at 912, n. 15. See n. 10, supra. Thus, the test is whether the insider personally will benefit, directly or indirectly, from his disclosure. Absent some personal gain, there has been no breach of duty to stockholders." [1] (My emphasis.)
Surely the 'thus' is unjustified here, given that the quote from the SEC is a purpose of the laws, not the purpose; some other purpose of the law might establish additional tests for a breach of duty. Furthermore, the quote from the SEC does not limit the purpose of the law to situations where the leaker is the beneficiary, yet that is claimed to be part of the conclusion that follows from it.
For completeness, I will point out that the next sentence says "And absent a breach by the insider, there is no derivative breach." This cannot be used to establish that no breach has occurred, because it is predicated on that assumption.
[1] https://casetext.com/case/dirks-v-securities-and-exchange-commission https://casetext.com/case/dirks-v-securities-and-exchange-co...