3 ms·
It's good that the court somewhat clarified previously-fuzzier law. The underlying problem is that insider trading as a crime is so ad hoc to begin with. TFA no
by jessaustin 11y ago
It's good that the court somewhat clarified previously-fuzzier law. The underlying problem is that insider trading as a crime is so ad hoc to begin with. TFA notes the hodgepodge of agencies, laws, regulation, rulings, etc. that "define" insider trading today. I doubt if any legal thinker's interpretation of the current understanding were codified into a single bill, that that bill could pass in Congress. Codifying what currently exists would make obvious what a boon it is for powerful executives. A codification of what the public imagines exists, would never get past those executives' lobbyists.
Nearly all executives trade in the securities of the corporations that employ them. Very few are ever charged with insider trading. (I'm not suggesting they should be!) However, whenever company management catches wind of transactions that annoy them, they always have a friendly ear at the prosecutor's office.
Long before major stock [EDIT:] moves, many "insiders" knew what was coming. Perhaps some told themselves, like Madoff, that they could get everything turned around. Regardless, insiders know before the public knows. Insider trading prohibitions serve to prolong the public's ignorance, and so deepen the public's trading losses. No one is better placed to dance right up to the line concerning investment decisions and public disclosure, than the firm's executives are. That's why the majority of insider trading prosecutions that succeed, are against outsiders like Martha Stewart or the subjects of TFA. Insider trading is a crime because it's valuable for the executive class to punish early defectors.
- cperciva 11y agoNearly all executives trade in the securities of the corporations that employ them. Lots of executives exercise stock options and sell shares. I think executives buying securities on the open market is far less common. The 'insider trading' issue with the timing of when executives sell shares is why SEC rule 10b5-1(c) exists: It allows executives to establish in advance plans for selling their shares, such that their future trades cannot be deemed to be the result of inside information.
- walshemj 11y agoare you sure Director buying is well reported the Investors chronicle has a weekly run down of which listed company's directors have brought/sold shares.
- cft 11y agoExcept that the executives usually have automatic sales, to shield themselves from illegal insider trading. This usually happens inside the trading windows, and mostly using pre-scheduled recurring sales. A public company normally has a lawyer that specifically deals with this compliance.