3 ms·
It all comes down to the international laws of the sea. Planting your flag on a 1m wide rock above the high tide line enables an exclusive zone with radius 12
by logfromblammo 11y ago
It all comes down to the international laws of the sea.
Planting your flag on a 1m wide rock above the high tide line enables an exclusive zone with radius 12 NM for excluding all foreign vessels, a radius of 24 NM for enforcement of your laws, and one with radius 200 NM for exclusive economic activities, like oil drilling, undersea mining, and fishing.
It's a resource grab. China wants the fish and the seafloor.
What they're going to end up doing is forging a multilateral treaty between Vietnam, Indonesia, Malaysia, Brunei, Phillippines, and possibly Taiwan, with Australia and the USA giving a nod and a wink from the back of the room.
I think that there won't be a shooting war. It will be about 95% economic warfare.
- jcranmer 11y agoArtificially-constructed islands don't count for expanding EEZ per UNCLOS. What China appears to be doing is attempting a mixture of trying to dilute the facts so as to increase ambiguity and developing "facts on the ground" (cf. the Israeli settlement patterns in Palestinian territory) so that any grand compromise hews more to their favor. I think the last thing China wants is a multilateral treaty: the more people that are involved in a treaty, the less powerful China's negotiating time is. China has made repeated angry noises against proposals to treat the issue as a single regional issue rather than a collection of bilateral disputes. The disputes are also a large factor into why all the other south-east Asian countries (including especially Vietnam!) are trying to cozy up to the US and get the protection of the US Navy.
- logfromblammo 11y agoSome of them are natural islands that have been artificially expanded to support a military presence. The 12 NM territorial limit for a natural island certainly allows the power owning it to build barracks, airfields, and artillery batteries within that limit. And that prevents other countries from claiming or disputing the island.
- run4yourlives2 11y agoIt's not a resource grab... those are major shipping routes. It's an economic control grab.
- fraserharris 11y agoThe shipping routes are in international straights. China would not disrupt them because Chinese ships would be at risk in other waterways they can not project power to.
- run4yourlives2 11y agoIf you look at the map, China is attempting to claim ownership of said straights. Your second point is accurate, but China having the ability to disrupt a route brings it up to par with other powers, whereas right now they are solely at the mercy of foreign nations wrt other waterways, with no ability to respond in kind. This gives them that ability.
- fraserharris 11y agoThat is illegal under the Innocent Passage clause of the UN Law of the Seas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innocent_passage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Innocent_passage
- rwhitman 11y agoI agree, it goes against the best interest of any of these countries to risk a military clash with China over it building infrastructure on some unoccupied patches of sand in the middle of the sea.